Opportunities and challenges in long-read sequencing data analysis.

Amarasinghe SL, Su S, Dong X, Zappia L, Ritchie ME, Gouil Q. · 2020

Read Opportunities and challenges in long-read sequencing data analysis. by Amarasinghe SL, Su S, Dong X, Zappia L, Ritchie ME, Gouil Q. (2020) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc7006217.txt.

Introduction

Amarasinghe and co-authors survey the tools used to analyse long-read sequencing data. Their review appeared in Genome Biology. Long-read machines now routinely return reads longer than 10 kb, against up to 600 bases for short-read instruments. They also read native DNA and RNA directly, keeping chemical marks that copying would erase.

Accuracy and output keep improving, widening where the technology applies. Analysis software struggles to keep pace, and the tool landscape shifts fast enough to overwhelm project planners. The authors map what exists and maintain an online database, long-read-tools.org, for browsing it. Three areas get deep treatment: fixing read errors, spotting base modifications from signal quirks, and making sense of long-read transcript data. Each carries unsolved problems. The guide aims to help researchers design studies and pick tools with open eyes.

Catalog record

CREATORAmarasinghe SL, Su S, Dong X, Zappia L, Ritchie ME, Gouil Q.
YEAR2020
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE82 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC7006217

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Opportunities and challenges in long-read sequencing data analysis By Shanika L Amarasinghe, Shian Su, Xueyi Dong, Luke Zappia, Matthew E Ritchie, Quentin Gouil Published in: Genome Biology DOI: 10.1186/s13059-020-1935-5 ABSTRACT Abstract Long-read technologies are overcoming early limitations in accuracy and throughput, broadening their application domains in genomics. Dedicated analysis tools that take into account the characteristics of long-read data are thus required, but the fast pace of development of such tools can be overwhelming. To assist in the design and analysis of long-read sequencing projects, we review the current landscape of available tools and present an online interactive database, long-read-tools.org, to facilitate their browsing. We further focus on the principles of error correction, base modification detection, and long-read transcriptomics analysis and highlight the challenges that remain. Keywords: Long-read sequencing, Data analysis, PacBio, Oxford Nanopore INTRODUCTION Long-read sequencing, or third-generation sequencing, offers a number of advantages over short-read sequencing [1, 2]. While short-read sequencers such as Illumina’s NovaSeq, HiSeq, NextSeq, and MiSeq instruments [3–5]; BGI’s MGISEQ and BGISEQ models [6]; or Thermo Fisher’s Ion Torrent sequencers [7, 8] produce reads of up to 600 bases, long-read sequencing technologies routinely generate reads in excess of 10 kb [1]. Short-read sequencing is cost-effective, accurate, and supported by a wide range of analysis tools and pipelines [9]. However, natural nucleic acid polymers span eight orders of magnitude in length, and sequencing them in short amplified fragments complicates the task of reconstructing and counting the original molecules. Long reads can thus improve de novo assembly, mapping certainty, transcript isoform identification, and detection of structural variants. Furthermore, long-read sequencing of native molecules, both DNA and RNA, eliminates amplification bias while preserving base modifications [10]. These capabilities, together with continuing progress in accuracy, throughput, and cost reduction, have begun to make long-read sequencing an option for a broad range of applications in genomics for model and non-model organisms [2, 11]. Two technologies currently dominate the long-read sequencing space: Pacific Biosciences’ (PacBio) single-molecule real-time (SMRT) sequencing and Oxford Nanopore Technologies’ (ONT) nanopore sequencing. We henceforth refer to these simply as SMRT and nanopore sequencing. SMRT and nanopore sequencing technologies were commercially released in 2011 and 2014, respectively, and since then have become suitable for an increasing number of applications. The data that these platforms produce differ qualitatively from second-generation sequencing, thus necessitating tailored analysis tools. Given the broadening interest in long-read sequencing and the fast-paced development of applications and tools, the current review aims to provide a description of the guiding principles of long-read data analysis, a survey of the available tools for different tasks as well as a discussion of the areas in long-read analysis that require improvements. We also introduce the complementary open-source catalogue of long-read analysis tools: long-read-tools.org. The long-read-tools.org database allows users to search and filter tools based on various parameters such as technology or application. THE STATE OF LONG-READ SEQUENCING AND DATA ANALYSIS Nanopore and SMRT long-read sequencing technologies rely on very distinct principles. Nanopore sequencers (MinION, GridION, and PromethION) measure the ionic current fluctuations when single-stranded nucleic acids pass through biological nanopores [12, 13]. Different nucleotides confer different resistances to the stretch of nucleic acid within the pore; therefore, the sequence of bases can be inferred from the specific patterns of current variation. SMRT sequencers (RSII, Sequel, and Sequel II) detect fluorescence events that correspond to the addition of one specific nucleotide by a polymerase tethered to the bottom of a tiny well [14, 15]. Read length in SMRT sequencing is limited by the longevity of the polymerase. A faster polymerase for the Sequel sequencer introduced with chemistry v3 in 2018 increased the read lengths to an average 30-kb polymerase read length. The library insert sizes amenable to SMRT sequencing range from 250 bp to 50 kbp. Nanopore sequencing provides the longest read lengths, from 500 bp to the current record of 2.3 Mb [16], with 10–30-kb genomic libraries being common. Read length in nanopore sequencing is mostly limited by the ability to deliver very high-molecular weight DNA to the pore and the negative impact this has on run yield [17]. Basecalling accuracy of reads produced by both these technologies have dramatically increased in the recent past, and the raw base-called error rate is claimed to have been reduced to < 1% for SMRT sequencers [18] and < 5% for nanopore sequences [17]. While nanopore and SMRT are true long-read sequencing technologies and the focus of this review, there are also synthetic long-read sequencing approaches. These include linked reads, proximity ligation strategies, and optical mapping [19–28], which can be employed in synergy with true long reads. With the potential for accurately assembling and re-assembling genomes [17, 29–32], methylomes [33, 34], variants [18], isoforms [35, 36], haplotypes [37–39], or species [40, 41], tools to analyse the sequencing data provided by long-read sequencing platforms are being actively developed, especially since 2011 (Fig. 1a). [Figure: Overview of long-read analysis tools and pipelines. a Release of tools identified from various sources and milestones of long-read sequencing. b Functional categories. c Typical long-read analysis pipelines for SMRT and nanopore data. Six main stages are identified through the presented workflow (i.e. basecalling, quality control, read error correction, assembly/alignment, assembly refinement, and downstream analyses). The green-coloured boxes represent processes common to both short-read and long-read analyses. The orange-coloured boxes represent the processes unique to long-read analyses. Unfilled boxes represent optional steps. Commonly used tools for each step in long-read analysis are within brackets. Italics signify tools developed by either PacBio or ONT companies, and non-italics signify tools developed by external parties. Arrows represent the direction of the workflow] A search through publications, preprints, online repositories, and social media identified 354 long-read analysis tools. The majority of these tools are developed for nanopore read analyses (262) while there are 170 tools developed to analyse SMRT data (Fig. 1a). We categorised them into 31 groups based on their functionality (Fig. 1b). This identified trends in the evolution of research interests: likely due to the modest initial throughput of long-read sequencing technologies, the majority of tools were tested on non-human data; tools for de novo assembly, error correction, and polishing categories have received the most attention, while transcriptome analysis is still in early stages of development (Fig. 1b). We present an overview of the analysis pipelines for nanopore and SMRT data and highlight popular tools (Fig. 1c). We do not attempt to provide a comprehensive review of tool performance for all long-read applications; dedicated benchmark studies are irreplaceable, and we refer our readers to those when possible. Instead, we present the principles and potential pitfalls of long-read data analysis with a focus on some of the main types of downstream analyses: structural variant calling, error correction, detection of base modifications, and transcriptomics. BASECALLING The first step in any long-read analysis is basecalling, or the conversion from raw data to nucleic acid sequences (Fig. 1c). This step receives greater attention for long reads than short reads where it is more standardised and usually performed using proprietary software. Nanopore basecalling is itself more complex than SMRT basecalling, and more options are available: of the 26 tools related to basecalling that we identified, 23 relate to nanopore sequencing. During SMRT sequencing, successions of fluorescence flashes

Read the complete text