Multiple health and environmental impacts of foods.

Clark MA, Springmann M, Hill J, Tilman D. · 2019

Read Multiple health and environmental impacts of foods. by Clark MA, Springmann M, Hill J, Tilman D. (2019) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc6859310.txt.

Introduction

Clark and co-authors report a study in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences comparing foods on two scoreboards at once. What people eat drives both disease and environmental harm. Food choices threaten global climate and health goals together. Yet foods are usually judged on one side only. The team set out to join the two.

They linked 15 food groups to 5 health outcomes and 5 measures of environmental damage. Foods tied to better adult health, such as whole grains, nuts, and vegetables, also tended to burden the planet least. Unprocessed red meat scored badly on both counts. The authors argue one dietary shift can serve both agendas.

Catalog record

CREATORClark MA, Springmann M, Hill J, Tilman D.
YEAR2019
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE39 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC6859310

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Multiple health and environmental impacts of foods By Michael A Clark, Marco Springmann, Jason Hill, David Tilman Published in: Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America DOI: 10.1073/pnas.1906908116 ABSTRACT Significance Dietary choices are a leading global cause of mortality and environmental degradation and threaten the attainability of the UN’s Sustainable Development Goals and the Paris Climate Agreement. To inform decision making and to better identify the multifaceted health and environmental impacts of dietary choices, we describe how consuming 15 different food groups is associated with 5 health outcomes and 5 aspects of environmental degradation. We find that foods associated with improved adult health also often have low environmental impacts, indicating that the same dietary transitions that would lower incidences of noncommunicable diseases would also help meet environmental sustainability targets. Dietary choices—the types and amounts of foods that individuals consume—are a major determinant of human health and environmental sustainability. Nine of the top 15 risk factors for global morbidity result from poor dietary quality, while diseases associated with poor dietary quality, including coronary heart disease (CHD), type II diabetes, stroke, and colorectal cancers, account for nearly 40% of global mortality (1, 2). Furthermore, agricultural food production emits ∼30% of global greenhouse gasses (GHGs) (3, 4); occupies ∼40% of Earth’s land (5); causes nutrient pollution that profoundly alters ecosystems and water quality (6); and accounts for ∼70% of Earth’s freshwater withdrawals from rivers, reservoirs, and ground water (7), among other negative environmental effects (8, 9). Here we examine the potentially complex and multifaceted food-dependent linkages between and among 5 different diet-dependent health outcomes in adults—type II diabetes, stroke, coronary heart disease, colorectal cancer, and mortality—and 5 different environmental impacts of producing the foods. Such information could help consumers, food corporations, and policy makers make better decisions about food choices, food products, and food policies, potentially increasing the likelihood of meeting international sustainability targets such as the United Nations’ Sustainable Development Goals or the Paris Climate Agreement (10, 11). Previous analyses have examined the overall health and environmental impacts of dietary patterns (e.g., refs. 12 and 13), but have not decomposed these multifaceted impacts to individual foods at quantities consumed on a daily basis. Moreover, analyses looking at individual foods commonly examine the health (e.g., ref. 14) or environmental impacts (e.g., ref. 15) in isolation of the other. In particular, we explore the multiple human health and environmental impacts of 15 different food groups: chicken, dairy, eggs, fish, fruits, legumes, nuts, olive oil (which we include as an indicator for vegetable oils high in unsaturated fatty acids because of data availability; see the discussion in SI Appendix), potatoes, processed red meat, refined grain cereals, sugar-sweetened beverages (SSBs), unprocessed red meat, vegetables, and whole grain cereals. Our analysis includes the 5 health outcomes mentioned above and 5 environmental outcomes—GHG emissions, land use, scarcity-weighted water use (water use multiplied by a constant that scales regionally based on water availability after demand from humans and aquatic ecosystems has been met) (16), and 2 forms of nutrient pollution—acidification and eutrophication. We first consider the health and environmental impacts of these foods separately, and then explore them jointly. We selected these foods and these health and environmental outcomes because plausible causal metabolic mechanisms between food consumption and health outcomes exist for these foods and because the health and environmental impacts of these foods have been well documented through metaanalyses. The health outcomes reported here are the relative risks (RRs) of disease resulting from consuming an additional serving of a food per day relative to the average intake of that food observed in a cohort study. If RR > 1, consumption of an additional serving is associated with increased disease risk compared to the average risk of that disease, and if RR < 1, this consumption is associated with decreased disease risk. The food-dependent health data are from 19 dose–response metaanalyses (see SI Appendix, Table S1, for complete list) (17–35), which follow adult populations through time to estimate how food consumption is associated with disease risk while statistically controlling for confounding factors such as age, body mass index, sex, and history of smoking. Infants and children may have different nutritional needs. The 5 environmental outcomes reported here are the impacts of producing a serving of each food group as estimated by metaanalyses of life cycle assessments (LCAs) that account for the environmental impacts of plant and animal production, including the production, manufacture, and use of agricultural inputs, seed, equipment, and cropland (15), but not transport, processing, retail, and food preparation. Because most food groups contain multiple foods, the environmental impact per serving of each food group is weighted by the global average consumption of the foods within each food group (5). RESULTS Health Outcomes of Food Groups. We found few tradeoffs among the health impacts of different foods. In particular, no food associated with a significant (at P < 0.05) reduction in disease risk for one health outcome was associated with a significant increase in disease risk for any other health outcome (Fig. 1). Indeed, Spearman rank-order correlations showed that a food group that benefitted (or harmed) one health metric tended to have similar affects on the other health metrics. In particular, we determined the rank-order correlation for each of the 10 pairwise comparisons of the 5 health impacts. Each correlation used data for the 15 food groups. We found that 8 of these 10 Spearman correlations were significant and positive (P < 0.05; SI Appendix, Table S2), while none were significant and negative. [Figure: Summary of health and environmental data. (A) Health data are reported as the RR of disease per serving of food consumed, where an RR <1 indicates that food consumption is associated with decreased disease risk and an RR >1 indicates that food consumption is associated with increased disease risk. Error bars for the health data indicate the 5th and 95th percentile confidence intervals. (B) Environmental data are shown as the relative environmental impact per serving of food produced, where a value of 1 indicates that producing a serving of food has the same environmental impact as producing a serving of vegetables. Environmental impacts are plotted on a log10 scale, and error bars for the environmental data indicate the 5th and 95th percentile impacts per serving of food produced. Water use is reported as scarcity-weighted (Wtd) water use, which accounts for regional variation in water availability. Data used to create the plots are available in Dataset S1. The association between total mortality and olive oil was estimated by weighting disease-specific contributions (e.g., CHD, stroke, and diabetes) to mortality by disease-specific relative risk (2).] As to individual food groups, nuts, minimally processed whole grains, fruits, vegetables, legumes, olive oil, and fish are associated with significantly (P < 0.05) reduced mortality and/or reduced risk for one or more diseases (Fig. 1A). Consuming an additional serving per day of these 7 foods is associated with a significant reduction in risk for 20 of the 34 health endpoints for these foods (7 foods by 5 health outcomes; dose–response data for the association between olive oil and colorectal cancer was not available) and no significant change in disease risk for 14 of 34 health

Read the complete text