The 3Rs and Humane Experimental Technique: Implementing Change.

Hubrecht RC, Carter E. · 2019

Read The 3Rs and Humane Experimental Technique: Implementing Change. by Hubrecht RC, Carter E. (2019) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc6826930.txt.

Introduction

Hubrecht and Carter introduce a special issue of Animals on the 3Rs of animal research. The 3Rs stand for replacement, reduction, and refinement. They were set out by William Russell and Rex Burch in a 1959 book on humane technique. The framework now guides lab animal welfare law and practice around the world.

The authors trace how the ideas spread, helped by the Universities Federation for Animal Welfare. Laws such as the European Directive of 2010, in full force from 2013, wrote the 3Rs into rules on housing and review. The piece then previews the issue's papers on putting the principles into daily practice.

Catalog record

CREATORHubrecht RC, Carter E.
YEAR2019
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE39 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC6826930

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The 3Rs and Humane Experimental Technique: Implementing Change By Robert C Hubrecht, Elizabeth Carter Published in: Animals : an Open Access Journal from MDPI DOI: 10.3390/ani9100754 ABSTRACT Abstract Simple Summary The 3Rs: Replacement, Reduction and Refinement, formulated by William Russell and Rex Burch, have become synonymous with the measures to improve the welfare of animals used in research and are now used as an ethical framework for improving laboratory animal welfare throughout the world. This introduction to a special issue on the 3Rs explains how a non-confrontational and scientific approach led to their development, and briefly summarizes their adoption around the world. Abstract In 1959, the Universities Federation for Animal Welfare (UFAW) Scholars Russell & Burch published the Principles of Humane Experimental Technique in which they laid out the principles of the Three Rs. However, the Three Rs owed much to others. It was UFAW and, in particular, UFAW’s Founder and Director, Major Charles Hume who identified the problem that needed to be tackled, and who developed the non-confrontational approach that was needed to both formulate the questions that needed answers and to obtain the answers from the research community. Russell & Burch’s work was also guided by an expert scientific and technical committee chaired by the Nobel Prize winner Sir Peter Medawar. This essay describes the history of the Three Rs using publications by the protagonists and others as well as material from UFAW’s archives. It describes the background to the employment of Russell & Burch, the methodology of Russell & Burch’s approach and the impact of their work up to the present day—where the Three Rs are incorporated in legislation throughout the world. Keywords: the 3Rs, the Three Rs, replacement, reduction, refinement, alternatives, housing and husbandry, laboratory animals 1. INTRODUCTION The use of animals for research purposes (drug testing, models of disease, safety testing, or for the advancement of knowledge) has long been a matter of controversy, with concerns raised about animals’ sentience, the, sometimes, very significant harms that might be caused to them and whether the justification for such harms is acceptable. Most researchers working in the biosciences field and who use live animals in research will have heard of the Three Rs principles and understand that implementing them is the accepted way to address at least some of these concerns. Some will be aware of the impact that the Three Rs principles have had on the welfare of animals used in research and that they are now internationally accepted as the ethical framework under which animal experimentation should be conducted. However, many may not know that the Three Rs were developed as much as 60 years ago and that, although animal research was deeply controversial, they came out of a uniquely collaborative approach between an academic animal welfare organisation and the scientific community. The Three Rs, as originally proposed by the Universities Federation for Animal Welfare (UFAW) scholars Russell and Burch [1] (The Principles), were defined as: Replacement: The substitution for conscious living higher animals of insentient material; Reduction: Reduction in the number of animals used to obtain information of given amount and precision; Refinement: Any decrease in the severity of inhumane procedures applied to those animals, which still have to be used. Russell and Burch described them in this order reflecting the order in which they should be addressed: (1) that sentient animals should not be used if non-sentient alternatives are available; (2) if animals do have to be used, then the project’s design and analysis should be such that the minimum number of sentient animals are used compatible with achieving the objectives of the research; and (3) that appropriate measures should be taken to mitigate any pain suffering or distress that the animals might feel. The Three Rs have remained much the same since their original publication, although there have been minor changes of emphasis and of definition. For example, Russell & Burch were much occupied with achieving reduction by reducing variation due to differences in the animals’ genotype, interactions with environmental variables such as temperature, and by dealing with disease, which was an important issue at that time. Today, the health status of animals used in research is usually far better defined and maintained (e.g., [2]) and environmental variables are better controlled, so more emphasis is usually placed on achieving Reduction through good and appropriate experimental design. Research techniques have also evolved since The Principles. For example, with the development of transgenic research in the 1980s welfare concerns were raised, that were largely based on unpredictable effects and the numbers of animals involved [3,4]. However, various publications have considered the welfare assessment of genetically modified animals and ways to refine techniques involved in their production e.g., [5,6,7,8,9] and the welfare issues raised by genetic modification are not so different from those that arise in other areas of research [10,11]. As Russell & Burch wrote in The Principles “As new fields of biology open in the future, it may become a matter of routine to apply the lessons of the past and turn as soon as possible to the techniques of replacement”. Another area where the emphasis has changed relates to animal care. Refinement is often implemented by either choosing less severe research protocols, or by ameliorating their effect by, for example, the use of appropriate anaesthesia or analgesia. However, the husbandry and handling of animals used in research or for breeding stock can also cause significant distress if it fails to meet their needs. It is clear that this was understood by Russell & Burch, as they wrote that “we cannot even in principle separate husbandry from the conduct of the experiment itself”. Nonetheless, since the publication of The Principles, Refinement has sometimes been defined in ways that have either omitted or appeared to omit husbandry [12] and this has led to a suggested redefinition of Refinement that: (1) clearly includes both breeding and research animals; (2) emphasises the importance of husbandry as well as changes to the design that impact on welfare and; (3) incorporates the concept it is important to consider how to positively impact well-being as well as minimise adverse effects on the animals [12]. 2. THE GENESIS OF THE THREE RS As in so many other areas of scientific endeavour, the Three Rs concept was not entirely novel. Richmond describes how some of the concepts, or parts thereof, were already being promoted many years earlier [13,14]. Marshal Hall, in 1831, in an introduction to his volume on the circulation of the blood [15] and also in 1847 [16] describes five principles for the prosecution of physiology, which embodies much of the Three Rs, and the need for necessary ethical justification: - We should never have recourse to experiment in cases which observation can afford us the information required. - No experiment should be performed without a distinct and definite object and without the persuasion, after the maturest consideration, that the object will be attained and produce a real and uncomplicated result. - We should not needlessly repeat experiments. - That it should be instituted with the least possible infliction of suffering. - Every physiological experiment should be performed under such circumstances as will secure due observation and attestation of

Read the complete text