Integrated evolutionary analysis reveals antimicrobial peptides with limited resistance.
Spohn R, Daruka L, Lázár V, Martins A, Vidovics F, Grézal G, Méhi O, Kintses B, Számel M, Jangir PK, Csörgő B, Györkei Á, Bódi Z, Faragó A, Bodai L, Földesi I, Kata D, Maróti G, Pap B, Wirth R, Papp B, Pál C. · 2019
Read Integrated evolutionary analysis reveals antimicrobial peptides with limited resistance. by Spohn R, Daruka L, Lázár V, Martins A, Vidovics F, Grézal G, Méhi O, Kintses B, Számel M, Jangir PK, Csörgő B, Györkei Á, Bódi Z, Faragó A, Bodai L, Földesi I, Kata D, Maróti G, Pap B, Wirth R, Papp B, Pál C. (2019) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc6778101.txt.
Introduction
Spohn and co-authors tested how easily germs learn to resist antimicrobial peptides. Such peptides are promising new antibiotics, but fears of resistance dog them. The team grew E. coli in the lab against 14 diverse peptides and 12 standard drugs. They then measured how much protection the germs gained, and whether it crossed from one drug to the next.
Against some peptides, such as tachyplesin II and cecropin P1, the germs stayed nearly defenseless. Gene changes and gene gains gave them only weak shields. Germs already proof against standard drugs gained no extra safety from these peptides. DNA from soil germs conferred none at all. Plain physical and chemical traits foretold which peptides would hold up. Such peptides could make durable new drugs.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Spohn R, Daruka L, Lázár V, Martins A, Vidovics F, Grézal G, Méhi O, Kintses B, Számel M, Jangir PK, Csörgő B, Györkei Á, Bódi Z, Faragó A, Bodai L, Földesi I, Kata D, Maróti G, Pap B, Wirth R, Papp B, Pál C. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2019 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 77 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Integrated evolutionary analysis reveals antimicrobial peptides with limited resistance By Réka Spohn, Lejla Daruka, Viktória Lázár, Ana Martins, Fanni Vidovics, Gábor Grézal, Orsolya Méhi, Bálint Kintses, Mónika Számel, Pramod K Jangir, Bálint Csörgő, Ádám Györkei Published in: Nature Communications DOI: 10.1038/s41467-019-12364-6 ABSTRACT Abstract Antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) are promising antimicrobials, however, the potential of bacterial resistance is a major concern. Here we systematically study the evolution of resistance to 14 chemically diverse AMPs and 12 antibiotics in Escherichia coli. Our work indicates that evolution of resistance against certain AMPs, such as tachyplesin II and cecropin P1, is limited. Resistance level provided by point mutations and gene amplification is very low and antibiotic-resistant bacteria display no cross-resistance to these AMPs. Moreover, genomic fragments derived from a wide range of soil bacteria confer no detectable resistance against these AMPs when introduced into native host bacteria on plasmids. We have found that simple physicochemical features dictate bacterial propensity to evolve resistance against AMPs. Our work could serve as a promising source for the development of new AMP-based therapeutics less prone to resistance, a feature necessary to avoid any possible interference with our innate immune system. Subject terms: Antimicrobial resistance, Experimental evolution, Bacteriology INTRODUCTION Antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) are short, structurally diverse peptides with a broad spectrum of antibacterial activities. Although there is considerable diversity in the amino acid content, length, and structure among peptides, typically, they are positively charged and amphipathic1. AMPs are present in all classes of life, and are inherent part of the defense mechanisms against microbial pathogens. In vertebrates, many provide protection against pathogens and also have modulatory roles in the innate immune system2,3. AMPs frequently target the bacterial membrane by forming pores on it. This process is initiated by the interaction between the positively charged AMP and the negatively charged components of bacterial cell wall, including lipopolysaccharides (LPS) and phospholipids4. AMPs can also interfere with central cellular processes, such as DNA and protein syntheses, protein folding, and cell wall synthesis5,6. Given their broad spectrum of activity, much effort has been made to find potential novel antibacterial drug candidates among AMPs, although skeptics have raised issues concerning low peptide stability, costly production, and pleiotropic biological effects7,8. Evolution of resistance against AMPs was initially thought to be less likely due to the rapid bactericidal effects and multiple potential bacterial targets of these compounds1,9. However, small-scale studies indicate several major mechanisms of resistance, including the bacterial release of molecules that neutralize the exogenous peptide, enzymatic decay by bacterial proteases, and the modification of the outer bacterial membrane to prevent AMP binding or uptake10–14. Also, there are reasonable concerns that the therapeutic use of certain AMPs could drive a rapid evolution of resistance to host-defense peptides with immune-related functions in the human body15,16. This is a pressing issue, as several synthetic AMPs are currently tested in clinical trials (the majority of them are proposed for topical use)2,3. However, the scope of AMPs is broad. There are thousands of registered AMPs derived from a wide range of organisms, with distinctive physicochemical, structural and functional characteristics17,18. Therefore, major variations may exist in the probability or resistance of different AMPs. There is an increasing demand for a better understanding of AMP-specific resistance mechanisms, as it would greatly influence the capacity to design more efficient AMP-based drug candidates2,3,13. A better understanding of AMP-specific resistance demands studying multiple AMPs in a range of bacterial species. Moreover, bacteria can acquire resistance through diverse genetic mechanisms, including point mutations, amplification of genomic segments, and horizontal transfer of resistance genes. Therefore, these mechanisms should be studied systematically in the laboratory. Finally, it is of central importance to compare the rate of resistance evolution against AMPs and clinically employed antibiotics. Here we systematically characterize bacterial potential to acquire resistance against a set of chemically diverse AMPs (Supplementary Table 1). For this purpose, we combine laboratory evolution, systematic gene overexpression studies and functional metagenomics. We integrate the results of these complementary tests to get a global overview of AMP resistance evolution. We reveal a limited probability of resistance development against certain AMPs. Such AMPs could serve as a promising source for the development of resistance-free, AMP-based drug candidates. RESULTS Laboratory evolution of resistance to AMPs Our first goal was to study resistance evolution against a set of AMPs and antibiotics. We have followed established protocols with minor modifications to evolve bacterial populations under controlled laboratory conditions19,20. The applied protocol aims to maximize the level of drug resistance in the evolving populations achieved during a fixed time period. We have initiated a laboratory evolution experiment, starting with a single clone of Escherichia coli K-12 BW25113 (abbreviated as E. coli K-12 BW25113). Parallel evolving populations were exposed to increasing concentrations of one of 14 AMPs (Supplementary Table 1). Peptides were chosen based on the following criteria: diverse sources (synthetic/natural), different putative mechanisms of action, structural diversity, and clinical relevance. Another set of populations were exposed to one of 12 clinically relevant antibiotics (Supplementary Table 2), using the same protocol. Accordingly, we have propagated 10 independent populations in the presence of each AMP or antibiotic for ∼120 generations. We isolated a single, representative clone from each population, resulting in 140 AMP-adapted lines and 120 antibiotic-adapted lines. Throughout the paper, we compare the level of resistance in the evolved lines to the corresponding wild-type strain by measuring changes in the drugs’ minimum inhibitory concentrations (MIC). In agreement with prior studies, the evolution of resistance against small-molecule antibiotics was a rapid process21–23. The median antibiotic resistance levels were ~90 times higher compared to the wild-type strain (Fig. 1a and Supplementary Data 1). Resistance levels induced by AMP treatments were significantly lower and more heterogeneous on average than the resistance levels evoked by antibiotic treatments (Fig. 1a). Like most antibiotics studied here, certain AMPs are also prone to resistance. For instance, polymyxin B (PXB)—an AMP used as a last-resort drug in the treatment of multidrug-resistant Gram-negative bacterial infections24—is a notable example. During the course of our laboratory evolution, bacterial susceptibility to PXB decreased, reaching resistance levels of over 3000-fold higher than that of the wild-type strain (Fig. 1a, Supplementary Data 1). In agreement with other laboratory studies, we have also isolated resistant mutants from populations exposed to pexiganan (PEX), protamine (PROA), and PR-39 stresses25–27. [Figure: MIC and relative fitness of adapted lines after the laboratory evolution. a Relative resistance level in laboratory evolved E. coli K-12 BW2511 lines exposed to one of each 14 AMPs (blue) or 12 antibiotics (red), respectively (at least 9 parallel-evolved lines per drug). Altogether, lines exposed to AMPs (N = 138) developed significantly lower resistance, than lines exposed to antibiotics (N = 120) (P < 0.0001, one-sided permutation test). The resistance levels reached were more heterogeneous across AMP treatments (N = 14) than across antibiotic treatments (N = 12) (P = 0.03478 F-test). Each data point represents the MIC fold change of one of each parallel-evolved line. The mutD5 mutator strain exposed to TPII is marked by an asterisk (*). b Relative resistance level after laboratory evolution in clinical isolates under TPII or PXB stresses, respectively. Evolved lines exposed to TPII reached significantly lower resistance level than lines exposed to PXB (*** indicate the significant difference