Frameworks for supporting patient and public involvement in research: Systematic review and co-design pilot.

Greenhalgh T, Hinton L, Finlay T, Macfarlane A, Fahy N, Clyde B, Chant A. · 2019

Read Frameworks for supporting patient and public involvement in research: Systematic review and co-design pilot. by Greenhalgh T, Hinton L, Finlay T, Macfarlane A, Fahy N, Clyde B, Chant A. (2019) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc6737756.txt.

Introduction

Greenhalgh and co-authors reviewed frameworks for involving patients and the public in research. Many such frameworks exist, but the literature is scattered and built on mixed theories. The team searched six databases, eight journals, and expert contacts. They graded the frameworks with a Canadian evaluation tool and tested findings in five co-design workshops.

The final set held 65 frameworks, most scoring highly. They differed in origin, purpose, strengths, and limits. The authors grouped them into five families. Few frameworks had clear records of real use. The review aims to help researchers pick and apply the right framework. It also offers design principles to make future frameworks easier to use.

Catalog record

CREATORGreenhalgh T, Hinton L, Finlay T, Macfarlane A, Fahy N, Clyde B, Chant A.
YEAR2019
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE75 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC6737756

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Frameworks for supporting patient and public involvement in research: Systematic review and co‐design pilot By Trisha Greenhalgh, Lisa Hinton, Teresa Finlay, Alastair Macfarlane, Nick Fahy, Ben Clyde, Alan Chant Published in: Health Expectations : An International Journal of Public Participation in Health Care and Health Policy DOI: 10.1111/hex.12888 ABSTRACT Abstract Background Numerous frameworks for supporting, evaluating and reporting patient and public involvement in research exist. The literature is diverse and theoretically heterogeneous. Objectives To identify and synthesize published frameworks, consider whether and how these have been used, and apply design principles to improve usability. Search strategy Keyword search of six databases; hand search of eight journals; ancestry and snowball search; requests to experts. Inclusion criteria Published, systematic approaches (frameworks) designed to support, evaluate or report on patient or public involvement in health‐related research. Data extraction and synthesis Data were extracted on provenance; collaborators and sponsors; theoretical basis; lay input; intended user(s) and use(s); topics covered; examples of use; critiques; and updates. We used the Canadian Centre for Excellence on Partnerships with Patients and Public (CEPPP) evaluation tool and hermeneutic methodology to grade and synthesize the frameworks. In five co‐design workshops, we tested evidence‐based resources based on the review findings. Results Our final data set consisted of 65 frameworks, most of which scored highly on the CEPPP tool. They had different provenances, intended purposes, strengths and limitations. We grouped them into five categories: power‐focused; priority‐setting; study‐focused; report‐focused; and partnership‐focused. Frameworks were used mainly by the groups who developed them. The empirical component of our study generated a structured format and evidence‐based facilitator notes for a “build your own framework” co‐design workshop. Conclusion The plethora of frameworks combined with evidence of limited transferability suggests that a single, off‐the‐shelf framework may be less useful than a menu of evidence‐based resources which stakeholders can use to co‐design their own frameworks. BACKGROUND It is a truth universally acknowledged by policymakers, researchers and research funding bodies that patients and the public should be “involved” in research, though there are different perspectives on what such involvement should look like and why it should happen. Other authors have summarized a diverse literature on this topic (see in particular a recent BMJ editorial1 and these theoretically informed reviews2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8). In sum, three main arguments prevail. The first argument, described by some as normative and others as emancipatory, holds that patients have a right to have an input to research on their condition and that reducing the known power imbalances between researchers and patients is a moral duty of researchers, especially with oppressed and seldom‐heard groups.2, 3, 4, 9 The second, which some have described as consequentialist or efficiency‐oriented,3 is that patient and public involvement, by bringing a real‐world and lived‐experience perspective, improves the efficiency and value of research via a number of mechanisms: increasing its relevance to patients; improving recruitment and retention rates of research participants; extending the range of people represented in research studies; and improving dissemination of findings beyond academic audiences6, 7, 10, 11—though the evidence base for all these claims has been questioned.10, 12 The third argument is political and practical: that forming alliances with patients and the public is a defining feature of contemporary Mode 2 science (in which knowledge is co‐constructed by scientists and citizens, often beyond the walls of the university13); it increases the accountability and transparency of research and may be an effective way of attracting resources.5, 10 Notwithstanding the different (and to some extent incommensurable) perspectives represented by the above literature, it is clear that improving patient and public involvement in research is a high priority for research policymakers,14, 15, 16 research funders,17, 18, 19, 20 researchers,21, 22, 23 some academic journals1 and patient and lay organizations.24, 25, 26 Many of these groups have developed or are in the process of developing, structured frameworks, tools, guidelines and checklists in an attempt to improve their own performance and (in some cases) critique or assess the performance of others. As a multi‐stakeholder research collaboration based in one of the UK's leading medical and biotechnology research regions, we had a strong commitment to strengthening patient and public input to our research. When we began this study, the UK National Institute for Health Research had recently put out for consultation its draft benchmarks for patient involvement in research.27 The conditions of our funding required us to report annually on our patient and public involvement activity. We sought, therefore, to identify one or more tools or frameworks that would help us support, evaluate, improve and report on the patient and public involvement work of research teams across our collaboration. An initial browsing search identified numerous potential frameworks in both academic and grey literature, many of which appeared to have been carefully researched and some formally validated and field tested. Different groups had produced different frameworks, drawing on different principles, applying different theories and prioritizing different potential use cases. It was clear that developing a new framework from scratch was almost certainly unnecessary, but that the existing literature could benefit from a taxonomy and improved accessibility. Accordingly, we set out to achieve three objectives. First, to identify, critically examine, summarize and synthesize existing tools, frameworks, benchmarks, guidelines and critical appraisal checklists for patient and lay involvement in research. Second, to determine which of the frameworks were actually used and why (and explain why others were not used). Third, to work with patient and lay groups and designers to adapt, simplify and annotate existing frameworks and improve their aesthetic appeal and usability. As the study unfolded (and for reasons explained in the results section below), this last aim evolved to incorporate a major focus on optimizing the process of running workshops aimed at generating and adapting and operationalizing frameworks for involving patients and lay people in research. METHOD Study design Narrative systematic review, drawing on the principles of hermeneutic review,28 along with lay consultation and co‐design.29 Hermeneutic review consists of two interlinked cycles (described in more detail below): (a) accessing and interpreting the literature and (b) developing an argument. Searching is systematic but flexible and iterative. As sources accumulate, it becomes necessary to interpret, clarify and understand the emerging ideas and perspectives and to reject less relevant sources through progressive focusing. We have argued elsewhere that narrative review, which adds successive primary studies to an increasingly rich picture of a complex field of study, is the method of choice for synthesizing and making sense of a large and diverse body of primary literature where different groups of authors have approached the topic in very different ways.30 Data sources We searched six databases (PubMed, Embase, Cinahl, Social Science Citation Index, Science Citation Index and PsycINFO) to end 2018 using the following concepts and key words (adapted from a strategy used by previous authors31): (a) consumer or community or patient or citizen or user or lay or public or stakeholder; (b) participate or engage or involve or consult or empower or collaborate or inform; (c) health or medical or biomedical or nursing; (d) research or evaluation; (e) tool or toolkit or framework or guideline or checklist. We hand‐searched eight journals (Health Expectations, BMC Research Involvement and Engagement, International Journal of Consumer Studies, International Journal of

Read the complete text