Best practices and benchmarks for intact protein analysis for top-down mass spectrometry.

Donnelly DP, Rawlins CM, DeHart CJ, Fornelli L, Schachner LF, Lin Z, Lippens JL, Aluri KC, Sarin R, Chen B, Lantz C, Jung W, Johnson KR, Koller A, Wolff JJ, Campuzano IDG, Auclair JR, Ivanov AR, Whitelegge JP, Paša-Tolić L, Chamot-Rooke J, Danis PO, Smith LM, Tsybin YO, Loo JA, Ge Y, Kelleher NL, Agar JN. · 2019

Read Best practices and benchmarks for intact protein analysis for top-down mass spectrometry. by Donnelly DP, Rawlins CM, DeHart CJ, Fornelli L, Schachner LF, Lin Z, Lippens JL, Aluri KC, Sarin R, Chen B, Lantz C, Jung W, Johnson KR, Koller A, Wolff JJ, Campuzano IDG, Auclair JR, Ivanov AR, Whitelegge JP, Paša-Tolić L, Chamot-Rooke J, Danis PO, Smith LM, Tsybin YO, Loo JA, Ge Y, Kelleher NL, Agar JN. (2019) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc6719561.txt.

Introduction

Donnelly and co-authors set out best practices for measuring whole proteins by mass spectrometry. One gene can yield many protein forms, called proteoforms, each with its own mass. Top-down mass spectrometry reads whole proteins at once, so it can tell those forms apart. The authors belong to a consortium for this field.

Their paper gives a decision tree that leads researchers to sturdy protocols. It covers antibodies, membrane proteins, and mixtures of varying complexity. Shared standard samples let labs grade their own skill across instrument types. The benchmarks help new users match expert results. The guide aims to make intact protein analysis more reliable everywhere.

Catalog record

CREATORDonnelly DP, Rawlins CM, DeHart CJ, Fornelli L, Schachner LF, Lin Z, Lippens JL, Aluri KC, Sarin R, Chen B, Lantz C, Jung W, Johnson KR, Koller A, Wolff JJ, Campuzano IDG, Auclair JR, Ivanov AR, Whitelegge JP, Paša-Tolić L, Chamot-Rooke J, Danis PO, Smith LM, Tsybin YO, Loo JA, Ge Y, Kelleher NL, Agar JN.
YEAR2019
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE59 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC6719561

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Best practices and benchmarks for intact protein analysis for top-down mass spectrometry By Daniel P Donnelly, Catherine M Rawlins, Caroline J DeHart, Luca Fornelli, Luis F Schachner, Ziqing Lin, Jennifer L Lippens, Krishna C Aluri, Richa Sarin, Bifan Chen, Carter Lantz, Wonhyeuk Jung Published in: Nature Methods DOI: 10.1038/s41592-019-0457-0 ABSTRACT Abstract One gene can give rise to many functionally distinct proteoforms, each of which has a characteristic molecular mass. Top-down mass spectrometry enables the analysis of intact proteins and proteoforms. Here members of the Consortium for Top-Down Proteomics provide a decision tree that guides researchers to robust protocols for mass analysis of intact proteins (antibodies, membrane proteins and others) from mixtures of varying complexity. We also present cross-platform analytical benchmarks using a protein standard sample, to allow users to gauge their proficiency. Subject terms: Proteomics, Proteomic analysis, Proteins, Mass spectrometry MAIN Mutations, polymorphisms, RNA processing and post-translational modifications (PTMs) such as acetylation, methylation and phosphorylation can lead to a single gene producing many functionally distinct ‘proteoforms’1. These proteoforms can have different effects on important biological processes, including gene regulation, cell signaling and protein activity; consequently, the ability to characterize these species is essential for an understanding of the biological response to disease. The identity of a proteoform can often be inferred2 from an accurate experimentally determined intact mass3. One can increase the sensitivity of intact-mass-based proteoform identification by determining the relative abundance of a particular amino acid by using isotopic labeling, by using mass similarities to cluster proteoforms into gene families and by reducing the search space using sample-specific search databases2. Localizing PTMs, and in some cases the definitive proteoform identifier, requires tandem mass spectrometry (MSn) analysis. The measurement of intact protein mass followed by MSn has been coined ‘top-down’ mass spectrometry4–8, with its origins in Fenn and colleagues’ discovery that large biomolecules could be ionized9 and fragmented10–12 using electrospray ionization (ESI)-MS. Top-down MS protocols, unlike widely used bottom-up protocols13,14, do not require endoproteinase digestion before analysis, do not conflate proteoforms and tend to complement native MS analysis. One advantage of ESI over the alternative ‘soft’ ionization method, matrix-assisted laser desorption-ionization (MALDI), is that ESI imparts more charge per protein. This enables the mass determination of large biomolecules using mass analyzers with moderate mass-to-charge ratio upper limits (for example, m/z ≤ 4,000), which happen to offer the highest resolving power. Higher charge per molecular mass also facilitates gas-phase fragmentation and, therefore, the characterization of primary sequence and PTMs by MSn (refs. 15,16). Because of this superior fragmentation and the ability to interface with liquid chromatography (LC) systems, ESI is used for most top-down MS experiments. Projects requiring rapid MS analysis17, the ability to analyze hundreds of proteins in a single spectrum, protein imaging capabilities, or less signal suppression by common protein buffer components18 may be better suited for MALDI-MS. Compared to bottom-up workflows, top-down approaches provide additional layers of information, including detecting modifications that are removed or scrambled19 during peptide sample preparation (for example, S-thiolation), elucidating functional relationships (for example, cross-talk) between PTMs on the same protein molecule, characterizing drug–target interactions, observing important modifications on biopharmaceuticals, and identifying and quantifying distinct proteoforms that would have been convoluted by endoproteinase digestion20–24. In addition, sample preparation for intact protein MS comprises fewer steps than bottom-up approaches and does not require chemical modification (for example, reduction and alkylation), thereby reducing the number of experimental artifacts25. Current top-down sample cleanup methods (for example, protein precipitation26 and molecular weight cut-off (MWCO) ultrafiltration) are not applicable to all sample types or downstream MS analyses. The demand for robust, generally applicable methods for intact protein MS is the most common request made to members of the Consortium for Top-Down Proteomics27,28 (http://topdownproteomics.org/). Our goal here is to address this unmet need, by providing a guide to enable users with all levels of expertise to acquire high-quality intact protein mass spectra by ESI-MS. First we discuss signal suppression associated with common buffer components and biotherapeutic excipients. This provides the rationale for most failed intact MS measurements and, in addition, a path to designing MS-compatible buffers. Then, we present a decision tree based on sample composition and experimental goals, which guides users to a best-practices protocol and corresponding benchmark data. ORIGINS OF SIGNAL SUPPRESSION AND SIGNAL SPREADING Biological, biochemical and biotherapeutic sample preparations usually contain numerous interfering substances (for example, salts, detergents, chaotropes and buffers) that lead to signal suppression during ESI-MS analysis. To provide a theoretical context, we describe the two major drivers of the quality of intact protein (positive ion) ESI-MS and how these are affected by interfering substances. The first driver of quality is the formation of desolvated protein ions, which can be understood in terms of a few critical steps during the ESI process16,29,30. Interfering substances generally affect the ESI process after the formation of nanodroplets at the Rayleigh charge limit. Two salient, often opposing, processes that occur within these nanodroplets are the partitioning of net charge toward the droplet surface and the minimization of solvation energy. Polar species such as salts and native proteins partition toward the droplet interior to optimize solvation energy; their ionization, therefore, requires evaporation of solvent molecules16. Hydrophobic species such as detergent monomers and unfolded proteins migrate to the droplet surface to optimize solvation energy and, in a faster process that requires less energy, evaporate or are ejected. Many of the techniques presented here for reducing signal suppression can be rationalized within the framework above. For example, organic solvents that decrease surface tension should promote the ionization of both polar and nonpolar analytes; detergents partition to the surface, where they can outcompete analytes for a limited number of protons; organic solvents and acids that unfold proteins should promote ejection-based ionization; native MS (nMS) requires greater desolvation energy and is more sensitive to polar contaminants. The second driver of the quality of intact protein MS is signal spreading (that is, the distribution of the signal from a single proteoform across multiple channels), which increases with protein mass. Each channel has its own respective noise; consequently, the cumulative noise increases proportionally to the number of channels. The ESI process promotes signal spreading, via adduct formation, by increasing the concentrations of interfering substances and proteins. Heavy isotopes and charge states further distribute signal intensity across multiple channels; the former can be mitigated by isotope depletion31. Here we describe experimental techniques that minimize signal spreading (increase signal-to-noise ratio, or S/N), including using nMS to reduce the number of charge states, and the use of volatile salts (for example, ammonium acetate) or purification to minimize the effects of alkaline salts. SIGNAL SUPPRESSION BY COMMON BUFFER COMPONENTS Using the intact protein standard mixture (ubiquitin, myoglobin, trypsinogen and carbonic anhydrase) established by the National Resource for Translational and Developmental Proteomics (NRTDP) (http://nrtdp.northwestern.edu/protocols/), we evaluated common buffer components (Fig. 1) to quantify the concentration required for 50% signal suppression during direct infusion ESI. By analogy to half-maximum inhibitory concentration (IC50) nomenclature, we termed this metric the half-maximum suppression concentration (SC50) (Fig. 1, Supplementary Fig. 1). At their typical concentrations, all common buffer additives suppressed ESI signal considerably. Consistent with the mechanisms of ESI ionization described above, detergents produced the most signal suppression, less volatile (for example, metallic) salts produced

Read the complete text