Developmental cognitive neuroscience using latent change score models: A tutorial and applications.

Kievit RA, Brandmaier AM, Ziegler G, van Harmelen AL, de Mooij SMM, Moutoussis M, Goodyer IM, Bullmore E, Jones PB, Fonagy P, NSPN Consortium, Lindenberger U, Dolan RJ. · 2018

Read Developmental cognitive neuroscience using latent change score models: A tutorial and applications. by Kievit RA, Brandmaier AM, Ziegler G, van Harmelen AL, de Mooij SMM, Moutoussis M, Goodyer IM, Bullmore E, Jones PB, Fonagy P, NSPN Consortium, Lindenberger U, Dolan RJ. (2018) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc6614039.txt.

Introduction

Kievit and co-authors offer a tutorial on latent change score models for developmental neuroscience. Their paper appears in Developmental Cognitive Neuroscience. The field asks how brain and behaviour change together. Cross-sectional data cannot show change within a person. Latent change score models fill that gap. They formalise growth and coupling between measures over time. The tutorial gives open code and worked examples. It draws on the NSPN adolescent cohort.

Two example findings show the method's reach. White matter change tracked lower processing speed gains. Frontal lobe thinning varied more in males than females. Such models test which change leads the other. They also expose individual differences in development. The authors aim to spread the approach widely.

Catalog record

CREATORKievit RA, Brandmaier AM, Ziegler G, van Harmelen AL, de Mooij SMM, Moutoussis M, Goodyer IM, Bullmore E, Jones PB, Fonagy P, NSPN Consortium, Lindenberger U, Dolan RJ.
YEAR2018
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE111 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC6614039

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Developmental cognitive neuroscience using latent change score models: A tutorial and applications By Rogier A Kievit, Andreas M Brandmaier, Gabriel Ziegler, Anne-Laura van Harmelen, Susanne MM de Mooij, Michael Moutoussis, Ian M Goodyer, Ed Bullmore, Peter B Jones, Peter Fonagy, Ulman Lindenberger, Raymond J Dolan Published in: Developmental Cognitive Neuroscience DOI: 10.1016/j.dcn.2017.11.007 ABSTRACT Highlights - •We describe Latent change score modelling as a flexible statistical tool. - •Key developmental questions can be readily formalized using LCS models. - •We provide accessible open source code and software examples to fit LCS models. - •White matter structural change is negatively correlated with processing speed gains. - •Frontal lobe thinning in adolescence is more variable in males than females. Keywords: Latent change scores, Longitudinal modelling, Development, Individual differences, Structural equation modelling, Adolescence INTRODUCTION "When thinking about any repeated measures analysis it is best to ask first, what is your model for change? (McArdle, 2009, p. 579)" Developmental cognitive neuroscience is concerned with how cognitive and neural processes change during development, and how they interact to give rise to a rich and rapidly fluctuating profile of cognitive, emotional and behavioural changes. Many, if not all, central questions in the field can be conceived as related to the temporal dynamics of multivariate brain-behaviour relations. Theories in developmental cognitive neuroscience often implicitly or explicitly suggest causal hypotheses about the direction of the association between variables of interest, the temporal precedence of their emergence, and the likely consequences of interventions. For instance, the maturational viewpoint (e.g. Gesell, 1929; cf. Johnson, 2011, Segalowitz and Rose-Krasnor, 1992) proposes that development of key brain regions (e.g. the frontal lobes) is a necessary precondition to acquiring psychological capacities (e.g. cognitive control or inhibition). This represents a clear causal pathway, where developmental change in neural regions precedes, and causes, changes in faculties associated with those regions (also known as developmental epigenesis). This is contrasted with interactive specialisation theory (Johnson, 2011), where probabilistic epigenesis posits bidirectional causal influences from mental function to brain structure and function. These competing theories make explicit claims about the temporal order of development, as well as the causal interactions between explanatory levels. Similarly, developmental mismatch theory (Ahmed et al., 2015, Mills et al., 2014, Steinberg, 2008, van den Bos and Eppinger, 2016) suggests that a key explanation of risk taking behaviour in adolescence is the delayed development of brain regions associated with cognitive control (e.g. the frontal lobe) compared to regions associated with mediating emotional responses (e.g. the amygdala). This too posits a clear brain-behaviour dynamic, where a mismatch between maturation in executive brain regions compared to emotion systems is hypothesized to affect the likelihood of certain (mal)adaptive behaviours. Empirical examples of such questions show, for instance, that frontoparietal structural connectivity (but not functional connectivity) determined longitudinal changes in reasoning ability (Wendelken et al., 2017). An active area of research where cognitive or behavioural changes are presumed to precede changes in brain structure or function is that of training-induced plasticity. For instance, Bengtsson et al. (2005) found that degree and intensity of piano practice in childhood and adolescence correlated with regionally specific differences in white matter structure, and that this effect was more pronounced in developmental windows in which maturation was ongoing. This was interpreted as evidence of training-induced plasticity, suggesting that behavioural modifications (i.e. prolonged practice) preceded, and caused, measurable changes in white matter structure.1 More direct longitudinal evidence in 845 children scanned on two occasions suggests that grey matter volume and changes in white matter microstructure are slower in individuals with more severe psychiatric symptoms, but not vice versa. This is compatible with (although not conclusive evidence of) the hypothesis that differences in structural changes are consequences, not causes, of psychiatric symptoms (Muetzel et al., 2017). Although such questions are characterized by a fundamental interest in temporal dynamics and causality, much of the literature is dominated by cross-sectional (age-heterogeneous) data that are ill equipped to resolve these questions (Lindenberger and Poetter, 1998, Lindenberger et al., 2011, Salthouse, 2014). For instance, individual differences in brain structure may precede differential changes in cognitive abilities (e.g. certain clinical conditions), or changes in cognitive abilities may trigger measurable changes in brain structure (e.g. learning-induced plasticity). Although these hypotheses imply radically different causal pathways and (potential) intervention strategies, they are often indistinguishable in cross-sectional data. Moreover, aggregated cross-sectional data can be affected by cohort effects (i.e. different populations) which in turn can lead to overestimates (e.g. cohort differences, Sliwinski et al., 2010), underestimates (e.g. selective attrition, training effects; Willis and Schaie, 1986), and even full reversals of the direction of effects observed between groups compared to within groups (Kievit et al., 2013). Most crucially, cross-sectional aggregations do capture change at the individual level, nor individual differences in intra-individual change (Baltes et al., 1977). Thus, they fail to directly address the most fundamental questions of developmental science: How and why do people differ in the way they develop? The recent rapid increase in the study of large, longitudinal, imaging cohorts (Poldrack and Gorgolewski, 2014) provides unprecedented opportunities to study these key questions. Here we introduce a class of Structural Equation Models called Latent Change Score Models that are specifically tailored to overcome various weaknesses of more traditional approaches, and are well suited to address hypotheses about temporal, interactive dynamics over time. TOWARDS A MODEL-BASED LONGITUDINAL DEVELOPMENTAL COGNITIVE NEUROSCIENCE Structural equation modelling (SEM) combines the strengths of path modelling and latent variable modelling and has a long tradition in the social sciences (Bollen, 1989, Tomarken and Waller, 2005). Path modelling (an extension of (multiple) regression) allows for simultaneous estimation of multiple hypothesized relationships, specification of directed relations that correspond to hypothesised causal pathways, and models in which constructs may function as both dependent and independent variables. Latent variable modelling allows researchers to use observed (manifest) variables to make inferences and test theories about unobserved (latent) variables. In offering a flexible framework for multivariate analyses SEM has several key strengths compared to other methods of analysis (Rodgers and Lee, 2010). First, SEM forces researchers to posit an explicit model, representing some hypothesized explanatory account of the data, which is then compared to the observed data (usually a covariance matrix, or a covariance matrix and a vector of means). The extent to which the hypothesized model can reproduce the observations is adduced as evidence in favour of, or against, some proposed model of the construct under investigation. Moreover, SEM helps make researchers aware of assumptions that may be hidden in other approaches (e.g., assumptions of equal variances across groups).2 Second, by using latent variables researchers can account for measurement error in observed scores. This strategy not only increases power to detect true effects (van der Sluis et al., 2010), but also offers greater validity and generalizability in research designs (Little et al., 1999). Specifically, it can be used to test for bias across subgroups (e.g. tests functioning differently for different subgroups, Wicherts et al., 2005) and biased estimates across developmental time (Wicherts et al., 2004), and improve the use of covariates (Westfall and Yarkoni, 2016). In recent decades, various extensions of SEM have been developed for longitudinal, or repeated measures, data (McArdle, 2009). More traditional techniques (e.g. repeated measures ANOVA) are rarely tailored to the

Read the complete text