Considering adaptive genetic variation in climate change vulnerability assessment reduces species range loss projections.
Razgour O, Forester B, Taggart JB, Bekaert M, Juste J, Ibáñez C, Puechmaille SJ, Novella-Fernandez R, Alberdi A, Manel S. · 2019
Read Considering adaptive genetic variation in climate change vulnerability assessment reduces species range loss projections. by Razgour O, Forester B, Taggart JB, Bekaert M, Juste J, Ibáñez C, Puechmaille SJ, Novella-Fernandez R, Alberdi A, Manel S. (2019) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc6535011.txt.
Introduction
Razgour and co-authors test a new way to forecast how climate change will shrink species' ranges, writing in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. Standard forecasts treat a whole species as one unit. That misses local adaptation, since populations in warm spots may already carry genes for heat. The team built that variation into their models.
They used two cryptic Mediterranean bat species as the test case, linking gene variants to local climate. Counting adaptive variation cut the projected range losses for both bats. It also raised the odds the two species will compete as their ranges shift. Ignoring within-species differences, the authors warn, overstates future biodiversity losses. They urge protection of landscape links so helpful genes can spread.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Razgour O, Forester B, Taggart JB, Bekaert M, Juste J, Ibáñez C, Puechmaille SJ, Novella-Fernandez R, Alberdi A, Manel S. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2019 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 37 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Considering adaptive genetic variation in climate change vulnerability assessment reduces species range loss projections By Orly Razgour, Brenna Forester, John B. Taggart, Michaël Bekaert, Javier Juste, Carlos Ibáñez, Sébastien J. Puechmaille, Roberto Novella-Fernandez, Antton Alberdi, Stéphanie Manel Published in: Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America DOI: 10.1073/pnas.1820663116 ABSTRACT Significance Forecasts of species vulnerability and extinction risk under future climate change commonly ignore local adaptations despite their importance for determining the potential of populations to respond to future changes. We present an approach to assess the impacts of global climate change on biodiversity that takes into account adaptive genetic variation and evolutionary potential. We show that considering local climatic adaptations reduces range loss projections but increases the potential for competition between species. Our findings suggest that failure to account for within-species variability can result in overestimation of future biodiversity losses. Therefore, it is important to identify the climate-adaptive potential of populations and to increase landscape connectivity between populations to enable the spread of adaptive genetic variation. Climate change is predicted to result in widespread population and species extinctions (1), and climate-related local extinctions have already been observed in hundreds of species (2). However, an equivalent number of species did not experience local extinctions at their warm range edge (2), indicating that either phenotypic plasticity or genetic adaptations may enable some populations to persist under warmer conditions. This highlights the importance of incorporating intraspecific adaptations into climate change vulnerability assessments (3, 4). However, methodologies to adequately incorporate genomic data into projections of species responses to current and changing climatic conditions (5) and into conservation management strategies (6) are still missing. Vulnerability to climate change is most commonly assessed based on forecasted distributional changes using ecological niche modeling approaches (also known as species distribution models), which project future changes in the distribution of suitable climatic conditions that characterize species’ current ranges (7). A major limitation of these approaches, which can lead to erroneous predictions and misplaced conservation efforts, is the disregard of intraspecific climatic adaptations and the consequent differences in population responses to climate change (8). Evidence of contrasting patterns of physiological variation in thermal tolerance among and within species highlights the importance of incorporating intraspecific variation in climatic adaptations into ecological niche models (ENMs) (9). However, such model improvements are limited by the paucity of observational and experimental studies of local climatic adaptations (10). To date, studies attempting to incorporate genetic variation into ENMs primarily use neutral markers to identify phylogeographic structure and generate separate models for each genetically distinct population. These have resulted in more pessimistic forecasts than traditional ENMs, predicting increased threats from climate change due to range losses in vulnerable populations (11), but have not affected projections of range size changes at the species level (12). These attempts are limited in scope because neutral markers provide information on the species’ evolutionary history and barriers to gene flow but not on the ability of individuals to adapt and survive under changing conditions. Moreover, range shifts under future climate change are predicted to result in genetic homogenization across species ranges and loss of historic and current population subdivisions (13). More recent studies integrated genomic adaptations with ENM projections to identify vulnerable populations that will need to adapt to survive under future climate change (14, 15). However, genetic data related to intraspecific variation in climatic adaptations have yet to be directly incorporated into ENMs. To address this gap, our study develops an approach to forecast range changes under future climate change for individuals adapted to different climatic conditions and to determine the evolutionary rescue potential of populations [the ability of populations to persist through adaptation to the novel conditions (16)]. This requires first identifying local climatic adaptations in wild populations by using genotype–environment association (GEA) analysis and then incorporating this information directly into ENMs and projections of future range losses (Fig. 1). The applicability of our approach is tested using spatial and genomic data from a pair of cryptic Mediterranean bat species with relatively limited long-distance dispersal abilities, Myotis escalerai and Myotis crypticus, that have only recently been confirmed as separate species (17, 18). M. escalerai is endemic to the Iberian Peninsula (Spain, Portugal, and the Balearic Islands) and the eastern French Pyrenees, while M. crypticus is found across Italy, southern France, the Pyrenees, and the north of Spain (19). The current distributions of both species overlap across the north of the Iberian Peninsula but are likely limited by interspecific competition (20). As such, these species offer a good study system to simultaneously look at the effect of local climatic adaptations and interspecific interactions on the current and future distributions of species that are restricted to areas particularly vulnerable to the effects of climate change. [Figure: Framework for incorporating within-species climatic adaptations into projections of future range losses and evolutionary rescue potential.] RESULTS AND DISCUSSION Incorporating Local Adaptations into Climate Change Vulnerability Projections. Traditionally, local adaptations were identified through common garden experiments (3), but the advent of high-throughput sequencing techniques opened the door to the use of genomic approaches to identify signatures of local adaptations by relating genetic variation and environmental variables (21). We combined two GEA methods and used two key climatic variables that are likely to directly affect bat survival and reproductive success (maximum temperatures and summer rainfall; SI Appendix) to identify 32 potential climate-adaptive SNPs in M. escalerai and 38 in M. crypticus (see SI Appendix for population structure and GEA results; Dataset S1). It is important to note that our study is based on reduced-representation genomic datasets, which do not capture all adaptive genomic variation and therefore only offer an indication of SNPs under (or linked to) climate-related selection (22). However, subsetting our data illustrates how downstream results are robust to smaller numbers of SNPs (SI Appendix, Table S1). Plotting the multilocus adaptive genotypes of individuals in a constrained ordination space, we classified 34% of M. escalerai individuals as adapted to hot–dry conditions, 50% as adapted to cold–wet conditions, and the rest as intermediate genotypes. Based on the proportion of these individuals in each population (sampled from cave roosts), we classified six M. escalerai populations, mainly from Portugal and southern Spain, as primarily adapted to hot–dry conditions; eight, mainly from northern Spain and the Pyrenees, as cold–wet adapted; and four as mixed (SI Appendix, Fig. S1). In M. crypticus, 45.6% of individuals were classified as adapted to hot–dry conditions, and 36.8% were classified as adapted to cold–wet conditions. Most of the cold–wet-adapted individuals were found in the Pyrenees, Alps, and Massif Central, France (SI Appendix, Fig. S2). Population data are not available for M. crypticus because it primarily roosts in trees and switches roosts regularly, and therefore, colony roost locations are unknown. Intraspecific variation in local climatic adaptations was incorporated into ENMs by generating separate models for hot–dry- and cold–wet-adapted individuals and comparing predictions to models generated using all of the known geographic location records of each species. ENM projections are sensitive to variability resulting from the modeling approach, general circulation model (GCM), and greenhouse gas emission scenario used. To address these sources of variability, which can affect future range loss projections (23), we employ an ensemble modeling approach (24), averaging