Community participation in health services development, implementation, and evaluation: A systematic review of empowerment, health, community, and process outcomes.
Haldane V, Chuah FLH, Srivastava A, Singh SR, Koh GCH, Seng CK, Legido-Quigley H. · 2019
Read Community participation in health services development, implementation, and evaluation: A systematic review of empowerment, health, community, and process outcomes. by Haldane V, Chuah FLH, Srivastava A, Singh SR, Koh GCH, Seng CK, Legido-Quigley H. (2019) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc6510456.txt.
Introduction
Haldane and co-authors review evidence on community participation in health services. Their systematic review appeared in PLoS ONE. It covers high and upper-middle income countries. The question is whether involving local people improves services and health.
The team searched five databases for studies from 2000 to 2016. Screening began with 27,232 records. After duplicates and screening, 49 studies met the entry rules. Outcomes fell into process, community, health and empowerment groups. The authors report broad evidence of positive impact on health. Gains were strongest where organisational and community processes were strong. They stress that progress is not linear. Social and cultural factors shape each result.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Haldane V, Chuah FLH, Srivastava A, Singh SR, Koh GCH, Seng CK, Legido-Quigley H. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2019 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 50 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Community participation in health services development, implementation, and evaluation: A systematic review of empowerment, health, community, and process outcomes By Victoria Haldane, Fiona L H Chuah, Aastha Srivastava, Shweta R Singh, Gerald C H Koh, Chia Kee Seng, Helena Legido-Quigley, Cathy Maulsby Published in: PLoS ONE DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0216112 ABSTRACT Abstract Background Community participation is widely believed to be beneficial to the development, implementation and evaluation of health services. However, many challenges to successful and sustainable community involvement remain. Importantly, there is little evidence on the effect of community participation in terms of outcomes at both the community and individual level. Our systematic review seeks to examine the evidence on outcomes of community participation in high and upper-middle income countries. Methods and findings This review was developed according to PRISMA guidelines. Eligible studies included those that involved the community, service users, consumers, households, patients, public and their representatives in the development, implementation, and evaluation of health services, policy or interventions. We searched the following databases from January 2000 to September 2016: Medline, Embase, Global Health, Scopus, and LILACs. We independently screened articles for inclusion, conducted data extraction, and assessed studies for risk of bias. No language restrictions were made. 27,232 records were identified, with 23,468 after removal of duplicates. Following titles and abstracts screening, 49 met the inclusion criteria for this review. A narrative synthesis of the findings was conducted. Outcomes were categorised as process outcomes, community outcomes, health outcomes, empowerment and stakeholder perspectives. Our review reports a breadth of evidence that community involvement has a positive impact on health, particularly when substantiated by strong organisational and community processes. This is in line with the notion that participatory approaches and positive outcomes including community empowerment and health improvements do not occur in a linear progression, but instead consists of complex processes influenced by an array of social and cultural factors. Conclusion This review adds to the evidence base supporting the effectiveness of community participation in yielding positive outcomes at the organizational, community and individual level. Trial registration Prospero record number: CRD42016048244. INTRODUCTION Community participation came to the fore with the 1978 Alma Ata declaration, which framed the community as central to the planning, organizing, operation and control of primary health care [1]. In recent years, community participation has once again emerged as a priority in health globally following the initiation of the new Sustainable Development Goals. In line with the SDGs, integrated people-centered health services are key to achieving universal health coverage and attaining this goal requires participatory approaches [2]. Furthermore, with the rapid increase of chronic disease burden worldwide, intersectoral approaches encompassing community participation and engagement has been identified as key for implementing strategies in health promotion and the prevention and control of chronic diseases [3]. Over the decades, there has been much exploration, development, and debate on ways to conceptualize meaningful community participation in health services[4]. Beyond the use of community participatory approaches to promote the effectiveness of health programs implemented, engaging communities effectively is believed to have a positive impact on social capital, leading to enhanced community empowerment, and ultimately improved health status and reduced health inequalities [5]. However, despite the wide acceptance of community involvement in theory and practice, there still remains many challenges, both structural and practical, to successful implementation [5]. Furthermore, there is little concrete evidence on the effectiveness of community involvement programs, particularly on improvements in intermediate and long-term outcomes, including health related outcomes [6]. Much of the research done on community participation has also focused on low and middle income countries despite evidence of its universal utility in improving health [7]. To address this gap, this systematic review aims to examine the evidence on community involvement and participation from studies that report on program outcomes in high and upper-middle income countries. Previous systematic reviews of community participation outcomes have focused on mother and child health [2], and rural health [8]. One systematic review explored health and social outcomes of participatory approaches in the United Kingdom [9], and one systematic review of literature between 1966 to 2000 reported on the effects of involving patients in the planning and development of healthcare [10]. To our knowledge, there are no reviews of the existing systematic approaches that examine outcomes of community involvement in health service planning, implementation, monitoring, and evaluation for a variety of diseases in high and upper-middle income countries. This review seeks to fill this knowledge gap. METHODS This review was developed according to PRISMA guidelines (see S1 Table) [11] and submitted to Prospero at study initiation under record number CRD42016048244. Drawing on the definitions by George et al. (2015)[12], the concept of community and community participation is described in Box 1. Box 1. DefinitionsCommunity: Communities are defined as constituted by those with a shared social identity; that is of members of the same set of social representations, which are the meanings, symbols, and aspirations through which people make sense of their world.Community participation: Active group participation or participation of a person as representative of the group in activities where they not only provide ideas but are also involved in the intervention. Data sources We developed the search string in accordance with the underlying objective of the study and refined it with inputs from an information specialist. The following databases were searched from January 2000 to September 2016: Medline, Global Health, Embase, Scopus, and LILACs. The full search terms used for Medline are shown in Table 1. [Table: Medline search string.] Inclusion criteria We included all studies that involved the community, service users, consumers, households, patients, public and their representatives in the planning, implementation, monitoring and evaluation of health services, policy, or interventions. These included studies that involved the community in disease prevention, promotion, or healthy living, and/or health service delivery. Studies that involved patients in decision making of personal healthcare decisions only were excluded from our review. We also excluded studies where Community Based Participatory Research (CBPR) was used merely to suggest ideas rather than as part of implementation in a community program. For this review, we excluded editorials and theoretical studies but included reports which had a description of the community participation component. We did not impose any language restrictions but limited the search to published literature from high and upper-middle income countries as defined by the World Bank. Search and retrieval of studies Two reviewers (SS and AS) double screened titles and keywords for 20% of the total articles from the search in the databases (kappa coefficient = 0.82). The remaining 80% of the articles were distributed among SS and AS and screened only once due to the high initial Kappa coefficient. Following the title screenings, the abstracts included were double screened (kappa coefficient = 0.84). Any disagreement at this stage was discussed between SS and AS. In the absence of a consensus, opinion was sought from a third reviewer for resolution. Five reviewers (SS, AS, VH, FC, HLQ) conducted the full-text screening. Articles in languages other than English (e.g. French, German, Spanish, and Portuguese) were screened by a reviewer who could read and understand the article. Disagreements were resolved by a third reviewer. Only papers that reported outcomes or effects of community participation were included in this review. The details