Challenges and Controversies in Human Mesenchymal Stem Cell Therapy.

Lukomska B, Stanaszek L, Zuba-Surma E, Legosz P, Sarzynska S, Drela K. · 2019

Read Challenges and Controversies in Human Mesenchymal Stem Cell Therapy. by Lukomska B, Stanaszek L, Zuba-Surma E, Legosz P, Sarzynska S, Drela K. (2019) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc6481040.txt.

Introduction

Lukomska and co-authors take a critical look at mesenchymal stem cell therapy, where enthusiasm has outrun definition. More than two thousand patients have received these cells for conditions from graft-versus-host disease to heart, brain, and orthopedic disorders, and most reports confirm safety with promising, if unspectacular, benefits.

The review presses on what remains unresolved: what the cells actually do, how approaches differ between labs, and what long-term follow-up might reveal. Evidence increasingly credits secreted factors and vesicles, paracrine signaling that nudges repair and calms immunity, rather than cells engrafting and replacing tissue. Placing cells into particular niches could carry delayed risks, so the authors argue for defined products and patient watching over years.

Catalog record

CREATORLukomska B, Stanaszek L, Zuba-Surma E, Legosz P, Sarzynska S, Drela K.
YEAR2019
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE55 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC6481040

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Challenges and Controversies in Human Mesenchymal Stem Cell Therapy By Barbara Lukomska, Luiza Stanaszek, Ewa Zuba-Surma, Pawel Legosz, Sylwia Sarzynska, Katarzyna Drela Published in: Stem Cells International DOI: 10.1155/2019/9628536 ABSTRACT Abstract Stem cell therapy is being intensely investigated within the last years. Expectations are high regarding mesenchymal stem cell (MSC) treatment in translational medicine. However, many aspects concerning MSC therapy should be profoundly defined. Due to a variety of approaches that are investigated, potential effects of stem cell therapy are not transparent. On the other hand, most results of MSC administration in vivo have confirmed their safety and showed promising beneficial outcomes. However, the therapeutic effects of MSC-based treatment are still not spectacular and there is a potential risk related to MSC applications into specific cell niche that should be considered in long-term observations and follow-up outcomes. In this review, we intend to address some problems and critically discuss the complex nature of MSCs in the context of their effective and safe applications in regenerative medicine in different diseases including graft versus host disease (GvHD) and cardiac, neurological, and orthopedic disorders. 1. INTRODUCTION Mesenchymal stem cells (MSC) are of clinical interest because of their potential use in autologous transplantation. A lot of clinical trials using MSCs have been accomplished, and many others are being under examination. Recent reports demonstrated that more than two thousand patients received autologous or culture-expanded allogeneic MSCs for the treatment of different diseases [1]. In most cases, MSC therapy was quite efficient. However, the potential risk of MSC transplantation should be considered in terms of the long-lasting observations. Numerous reports from in vitro and in vivo studies provided the evidence about MSC differentiation into certain cell types [2]. However, a growing evidence from recent studies strongly suggests to focus on MSC paracrine properties including the release of extracellular vesicles containing numerous mRNAs, regulatory miRNAs, multiple bioactive proteins and compounds [3], and the production and secretion of a large number of regulatory substances rather than MSC direct differentiation and cell replacement [4]. The main therapeutic effects of MSCs are now attributed to the stimulation of several endogenous repair processes in injured tissues in vivo by secreted factors as well as the modulation of immune response, which translates into a positive outcome of MSC-based therapies. Another important aspect is the cellular heterogeneity of MSCs, which makes consistent conclusions about MSC therapeutic potential difficult, because the obtained results are frequently variable and may depend on the different MSC origin as well as harvesting and culture procedures [5]. At the same time, it makes MSCs a very interesting type of cells to be studied due to their complex nature. So far, there is no precise MSC definition, and already existing definitions only partially reflect the functional properties of these cells [6]. Due to the great interest in MSCs, a large number of publications explore the biological properties of these cells [7]. Several in vitro studies are aimed at defining compound and overlapping molecular mechanisms that may be involved in therapeutic MSC action in vivo. Besides these facts, the results of other multiple in vitro studies pave the way to possible modifications of the ex vivo culture environment and MSCs themselves to further increase their regenerative potential [7], and consequently to achieve better results in in vivo studies. In the present article, we discuss the potential side effects of exogenous MSC administration in vivo. In particular, we focus on GvHD [8] and cardiologic [9], neural [10], and orthopedic [11] patients, where MSC administration may have limited beneficial effects and provide some side effects for the recipient (Figure 1). We believe that, discussing some adverse aspects of MSC activity after their transplantation, we create a more reliable and complete view of MSC role in regenerative medicine. [Figure: The scheme of potential risks of adverse events during MSC transplantation.] 2. HETEROGENEITY OF MSCS There are reports that demonstrated that the quality of the human MSC product depends on the isolation and culture methods as well as the age, genetic traits, and medical history of the donor [12–15]. It seems that the most important factor to consider is the age of a donor so the autologous transplantation can have some limitations. The challenging issue is how to expand MSCs from elderly patients to obtain an efficient number of therapeutic cells. Moreover, it is difficult to isolate an effective population of MSCs from patients with some diseases including diabetes, rheumatoid arthritis, and other inflammatory diseases, thus regarding autologous reasons (where the cells isolated from the patient might be affected by the disease); the researchers suggest possible loss of therapeutic function by these cells [15]. Baptista and colleagues demonstrated that MSCs obtained from people with obesity have significantly impaired proliferation and differentiation potential [16]. However, due to some problems with autologous sources, we should consider immunological aspects of allogeneic MSC transplantation. Historically, MSCs have been shown to exhibit low immunogenic potential in vitro because of their limited expression of MHC I molecules, the lack of MHC II expression, and costimulatory molecules. Recent studies suggest that MSCs may not be “immune privileged” as assumed previously. It was shown that MSCs are no longer considered immunologically silent in vivo [17, 18]. Moreover, use of allogeneic MSCs has some limitations, considering risk factors including immunological response [19]. 3. POTENTIAL SIDE EFFECTS OF EXOGENOUS MSCS AFTER THEIR ADMINISTRATION IN VIVO The past decade has seen an explosion of research which directed at evaluation of mesenchymal stem cells as a cellular therapy in different debilitating diseases; however, a comprehensive analysis is needed to explain the discrepancies in clinical trials examining MSC treatment. Many negative effects are probably unreported, but they can occur. Stem cell therapies are complicated and can have serious side effects. A case report was published recently demonstrating that the patient developed a large tumor-like mass inside the spinal cord after 8 years of olfactory mucosa cell transplantation [20]. Although the trial was performed with the use of different adult stem cells than the MSC type, one should take into account that the potential mechanism of neoplastic transformation could be similar in case of MSC transplantation. Thus, more control investigations have to be performed with MSC samples prior to their transplantation to the specific niches in different tissues. In the following subsections of review, we will focus on side effects of MSCs therapy in different diseases. 3.1. MSCs as Advanced Therapy Medical Products MSCs are now determined as Advanced Therapy Medicinal Products (ATMP) and guidelines from the American Code of Federal Regulation of the Food and Drug Administration and the European Medicines Agency, and the network of national agencies defines the requirements for suitable production of these cells. These guidelines, generally called “Good Manufacturing Practices” (GMP), consist of many recommendations about cell culture procedures including validation and quality control to ensure optimal reproducibility, efficiency, and safety of the final medical product. Another classification, defined by the Food and Drug Administration guidelines, defines cultured cells as “minimally” and “more than minimally” manipulated which describe procedures “that might alter the biological features of the cells.” However, minimal manipulation conditions have not been precisely defined for the collection and isolation of various sources of MSCs [21–23]. Most of cell culture protocols that

Read the complete text