In their own words: stressors facing medical students in the millennial generation.
Hill MR, Goicochea S, Merlo LJ. · 2018
Read In their own words: stressors facing medical students in the millennial generation. by Hill MR, Goicochea S, Merlo LJ. (2018) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc6179084.txt.
Introduction
Hill and co-authors present a study in Medical Education Online on the stressors facing medical students, in their own words. Student stress is tied to depression, burnout, loss of empathy, and poor grades. Yet recent multi-school studies asking students directly were lacking. The team focused on the millennial generation of trainees.
Students at Florida's nine medical schools answered an anonymous online survey on wellness and distress. Their open answers name scheduling chaos and unclear academic demands as top burdens. Many said school used their time badly and changed plans without warning. The authors aim to guide programs and policies that cut student distress. The quotes give the findings a direct, human voice.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Hill MR, Goicochea S, Merlo LJ. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2018 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 39 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
In their own words: stressors facing medical students in the millennial generation By Monica R Hill, Shelby Goicochea, Lisa J Merlo Published in: Medical Education Online DOI: 10.1080/10872981.2018.1530558 ABSTRACT ABSTRACT Background: Medical student exposure to stressors is associated with depression, burnout, somatic distress, decreases in empathy, serious thoughts about dropping out of medical school, suicidal ideation, and poor academic performance. Despite this, there have been no recent, multicenter, qualitative studies assessing medical students’ perceptions of their greatest stressor(s). Objective: The goal of this study was to identify the most significant stressors noted by medical students themselves, in order to inform the development of programs and policies to reduce medical student distress. Design: Medical students from the nine schools in the state of Florida were invited to complete an anonymous online questionnaire assessing wellness and distress. Students were notified that all responses were voluntary and that individual responses would not be linked to themselves or their program. This paper focuses on students’ responses to fixed-response items regarding their experience of stress and open-ended responses to the following question: ‘What do you consider to be the greatest stressor(s) facing medical students?’ Qualitative data were analyzed using the Grounded Theory method of data analysis. Results: Results confirmed the impact of several stressors highlighted in previous studies (e.g., excessive workload, difficulties with studying and time management, conflicts in work–life balance and relationships, medical school peer relations, health concerns, and financial stressors). However, students also reported unique system-level concerns that have not consistently been highlighted in past research (e.g., medical school administrative failures, concerns about lack of assistance with career planning, and assessment-related performance pressure. Conclusions: Though individually focused interventions have demonstrated some success, medical students self-report stressors that may be better addressed through system-level changes. KEYWORDS: Medical education, wellness, stressors, medical school, qualitative research INTRODUCTION Medical students report higher levels of psychological distress than their same-age peers [1–6], despite having similar or healthier profiles than peers at the outset of medical school [7–9]. This suggests that medical education itself contributes to student distress. Studies have indeed documented that stress levels increase over the course of medical school, peaking either in the second year [7] or when students enter the medical wards [10]. While some stress may enhance academic performance [11], high levels of stress among medical students are associated with depression [7,12,13], burnout [14,15], and somatic complaints [13]. Anxiety and depression have been linked to medical students’ vulnerability to stress [16], and higher levels of psychological distress have been linked to decreases in empathy [17], serious thoughts about dropping out of medical school [5], suicidal ideation [5,10], and poor academic performance [18–20]. Previous research has explored student vulnerability to stress [4,21,22], and several studies have documented major stressors for medical students, including academics [15,18], lack of balance [23], relationships [18], poor student guidance/support [23], volume of information [18,23], finances [23], uncertainty of the future [15], lack of time to oneself [18], time and responsibility [23], and the need to succeed [18]. In addition, a recent review described six major themes associated with student distress: adjustment, ethical concerns, exposure to patient death and suffering, student mistreatment, personal life events, and educational debt [24]. However, these studies have relied on fixed-response items to assess student concerns. To our knowledge, there have been no recent, multicenter, qualitative studies designed to elicit directly from medical students what they consider to be their greatest stressor(s). An advantage of this methodology is that it allows students to freely list their concerns and thus provides a holistic picture of medical student perceptions regarding their stressors. Additionally, this methodology provides the opportunity for students to report stressors that may not have been adequately explored in quantitative studies. The present study used a mixed-methods approach to assess medical student perceptions of stressors impacting their current well-being. METHODS This project was part of an initiative to study medical student wellness in the state of Florida. The survey was created for this study by a panel of five epidemiological/clinical researchers who contributed to the initial pool of items, and content validity was established via consensus. The Florida medical school deans, administrators of the state physician health program, and medical students from multiple schools assessed face validity and provided feedback on items. No formal reliability analysis was conducted. The questionnaire included both quantitative and qualitative items assessing overall well-being, coping strategies, substance use, psychiatric symptoms, and suggestions for improving the medical school experience. This study was exempted or approved by the IRBs at all participating medical schools and was supported by the Council of Florida Medical School Deans and the state physician health program. In the spring of 2014, student leaders at the nine medical schools in Florida invited all medical students to complete an anonymous questionnaire assessing medical student wellness and distress. Students were invited via e-mail and/or class announcements and provided a link to the survey, which was hosted on www.surveymonkey.com. Students were informed the survey would require approximately 30 min to complete and were not compensated for participation. They were assured that all responses were anonymous and could not be linked to individual students or their medical schools. This paper focuses on student responses to fixed-choice questions about medical school stressors, as well as the following open-ended question: ‘What do you consider to be the greatest stressor(s) facing medical students?’ Data analysis Quantitative data were analyzed using IBM SPSS v.24. Chi-square analyses were computed to explore differences by medical school class year and gender. Weighted averages were examined to determine the ranking of reported stress among the groups. Qualitative data were analyzed using the Grounded Theory method [25] of data analysis. Researchers (LJM and MRH) independently read student responses and generated a list of codes for the data set. The researchers then compared code lists and agreed upon a common set of codes. Student responses were coded by MRH using Atlas.ti and reviewed by LJM. Coding discrepancies were resolved through discussion. The coded data were organized by general themes, and representative student quotes were identified. Some quotes were edited slightly to enhance readability (i.e., typos were corrected). RESULTS Quantitative results Of the approximately 5000 medical students in Florida, 1137 students responded to the study survey. Because students were invited by student leaders at their school, it is unknown exactly how many students actually received the initial invitation and/or any reminders. A total of 987 students (87% of the study sample) completed the quantitative survey items related to stress during medical school and are included in the current analyses. The respondents (49.7% female, 37.4% male, 12.9% did not report gender) self-reported as 29.8% first year students, 25.7% second year students, 16.8% third year students, 14.8% fourth year students, 0.4% fifth year or higher students, and 12.5% did not report their class year). Medical student respondents described their current stress as ‘severe and debilitating’ (11.2%), ‘significant but manageable’ (68.6%), ‘moderate’ (15.4%), ‘mild’ (3.8%), or ‘none’ (0.3%). They described the level of competitiveness among students in their medical school as ‘severe [hypercompetitive]’ (3.4%), ‘significant’ (23.4%), ‘moderate’ (37.0%), ‘mild’ (25.7%), or ‘none [very cooperative]’ (10.7%). Students rated the degree to which various factors contribute to their stress. Table 1 shows these results, separated by class year in