The impact of patient, intervention, comparison, outcome (PICO) as a search strategy tool on literature search quality: a systematic review.

Eriksen MB, Frandsen TF. · 2018

Read The impact of patient, intervention, comparison, outcome (PICO) as a search strategy tool on literature search quality: a systematic review. by Eriksen MB, Frandsen TF. (2018) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc6148624.txt.

Introduction

Eriksen and Frandsen offer a systematic review in Journal of the Medical Library Association on the PICO search model. PICO breaks a question into patient, intervention, comparison, and outcome. Many searchers use it to plan literature searches. Whether it lifts search quality was not clear.

The team searched nine databases and catalogs. Of 2,163 records found, just three studies qualified. Those studies compared PICO with rival models or with unguided searching. The models differed too much for pooled analysis. The authors say too few studies exist to judge PICO's effect. Well-designed trials are needed before practice advice can be given.

Catalog record

CREATOREriksen MB, Frandsen TF.
YEAR2018
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE31 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC6148624

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The impact of patient, intervention, comparison, outcome (PICO) as a search strategy tool on literature search quality: a systematic review By Mette Brandt Eriksen, Tove Faber Frandsen Published in: Journal of the Medical Library Association : JMLA DOI: 10.5195/jmla.2018.345 ABSTRACT Objective This review aimed to determine if the use of the patient, intervention, comparison, outcome (PICO) model as a search strategy tool affects the quality of a literature search. Methods A comprehensive literature search was conducted in PubMed, Embase, CINAHL, PsycINFO, Cochrane Library, Web of Science, Library and Information Science Abstracts (LISA), Scopus, and the National Library of Medicine (NLM) catalog up until January 9, 2017. Reference lists were scrutinized, and citation searches were performed on the included studies. The primary outcome was the quality of literature searches and the secondary outcome was time spent on the literature search when the PICO model was used as a search strategy tool, compared to the use of another conceptualizing tool or unguided searching. Results A total of 2,163 records were identified, and after removal of duplicates and initial screening, 22 full-text articles were assessed. Of these, 19 studies were excluded and 3 studies were included, data were extracted, risk of bias was assessed, and a qualitative analysis was conducted. The included studies compared PICO to the PIC truncation or links to related articles in PubMed, PICOS, and sample, phenomenon of interest, design, evaluation, research type (SPIDER). One study compared PICO to unguided searching. Due to differences in intervention, no quantitative analysis was performed. Conclusions Only few studies exist that assess the effect of the PICO model vis-a-vis other available models or even vis-a-vis the use of no model. Before implications for current practice can be drawn, well-designed studies are needed to evaluate the role of the tool used to devise a search strategy. INTRODUCTION The development of systematic reviews is considered a means of enabling clinicians to use evidence-based medicine (EBM) [1], and the number of systematic reviews is growing quickly [2]. As literature searching forms the underlying basis of systematic reviews, the quality of the literature search is crucially important to the overall quality of the systematic review [3]. Although new techniques can automate the process of systematic reviews, such as using text mining to develop search strategies [4], the task of devising the search strategy still requires intellectual contributions from reviewers. In particular, as the search strategy builds upon the review question, formulating the review question is critical to developing the search strategy. In their 1992 publication in the Journal of the American Medical Association, the Evidence-Based Medicine Working Group emphasized the precise definition of the patient problem, the required information needed to resolve the problem, and the ability to conduct an efficient search as the skills required for practicing EBM [5]. In addition to these skills, the use of conceptualizing models to structure a clinical question was introduced in 1995, when Richardson et al. proposed the use of a four-part model to facilitate searching for a precise answer [6]. They stated that a clinical question must be focused and well articulated for all four parts of its “anatomy”: the patient or problem (P); the intervention or exposure (I); the comparison intervention or exposure (C), if relevant; and the clinical outcome of interest (O). Despite the existence of other models—such as sample, phenomenon of interest, design, evaluation, research type (SPIDER) [7] and setting, perspective, intervention, comparison, evaluation (SPICE) [8]—the PICO model is by far the most widely used model for formulating clinical questions. The purpose of using PICO is considered to be three-fold [9]. First, it forces the questioner to focus on what the patient or client believes to be the single most important issue and outcome. Second, it facilitates the next step in the process—the computerized search—by prompting the questioner to select language or key terms to be used in the search. Third, it directs the questioner to clearly identify the problem, intervention, and outcomes related to specific care provided to a patient. The PICO model is also frequently used as a tool for structuring clinical research questions in connection with evidence syntheses (e.g., systematic reviews). The Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions specifies using PICO as a model for developing a review question, thus ensuring that the relevant components of the question are well defined [10]. The PICO framework is primarily centered on therapy questions, and although it can be adapted to formulate research questions related to prognosis or diagnosis, it is less suitable for other types of clinical information needs [11]. In addition to acting as a conceptualizing tool for asking clinical and research questions, the PICO model can be used as a tool for developing search strategies. According to Considine et al., “the PICO Framework should also be used to develop the search terms that are informed by the PICO question, Medical Subject Headings (MeSH) and any other terms deemed to be relevant” [12]. For a default search, the Cochrane Handbook suggests employing only search terms for patients, the intervention, and the study type [13], thus reducing the PICO model to P, I, and S/T (i.e., study type or types of study). Alternatively, instead of study type or types of study, the truncated PIC approach emphasizes the comparison intervention or exposure. Although conceptualizing models are widely used by information specialists, little is known about the impact of using them as tools for developing search strategies. Therefore, the aim of this systematic review was to determine whether the use of the PICO model as a search strategy tool improves the quality of literature searches. METHODS This systematic review was conducted and reported according to quality standards described in the AMSTAR measurement tool [14] and the PRISMA 2009 checklist [15]. Two reviewers independently carried out study selection, evaluation, and data extraction. We resolved discrepancies in our reviews by consensus. Covidence systematic review software (Veritas Health Innovation, Melbourne, Australia) was used to screen, select, and extract data from included studies. The review protocol was registered in the PROSPERO database (CRD42017055217). Search strategy We searched PubMed (Table 1), Embase, CINAHL, PsycINFO, the Cochrane Library, Web of Science, Library and Information Science Abstracts (LISA), Scopus, and the National Library of Medicine catalog on January 9, 2017. After testing and validating our PubMed search strategy using the capture-recapture technique as well as evaluating retrieval of known items [16], we translated the search strategy for use in other databases, adjusting the controlled vocabulary as applicable (supplementary Appendix A). We also examined reference lists and performed citation searching (Web of Science, v.5.23.2, up to February 1, 2017) of included studies to identify other potentially relevant studies. [Table: PubMed search strategy] Inclusion and exclusion criteria We considered all primary studies, regardless of design, as eligible for inclusion if they examined PICO as a tool for developing a search strategy (distinct from other methods for developing a search strategy) for identifying potentially relevant studies in any topic area. We excluded review articles but examined their reference lists to identify other potentially relevant studies. We applied no other restrictions, such as those related to languages or publication years, in this review. Outcome measures Our primary outcome measure was the quality of literature searches using two measures:

Read the complete text