Interpretation of P53 Immunohistochemistry in Endometrial Carcinomas: Toward Increased Reproducibility.
Köbel M, Ronnett BM, Singh N, Soslow RA, Gilks CB, McCluggage WG. · 2019
Read Interpretation of P53 Immunohistochemistry in Endometrial Carcinomas: Toward Increased Reproducibility. by Köbel M, Ronnett BM, Singh N, Soslow RA, Gilks CB, McCluggage WG. (2019) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc6127005.txt.
Introduction
Köbel and co-authors wrote a review in International Journal of Gynecological Pathology on reading p53 stains in endometrial cancer. Staining for the p53 protein mirrors the mutation status of the TP53 gene in a tumor. That makes it a useful test in working up these cancers. Labs have not always read the stains the same way.
The review describes four main staining patterns. One looks normal, while three abnormal patterns strongly predict a TP53 mutation. The authors give practical advice on lab methods to improve staining. They also warn about pitfalls that can mislead the reader. The goal is results that different pathologists reproduce in the same way.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Köbel M, Ronnett BM, Singh N, Soslow RA, Gilks CB, McCluggage WG. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2019 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 30 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Interpretation of P53 Immunohistochemistry in Endometrial Carcinomas: Toward Increased Reproducibility By Martin Köbel, Brigitte M. Ronnett, Naveena Singh, Robert A. Soslow, C. Blake Gilks, W. Glenn McCluggage Published in: International Journal of Gynecological Pathology DOI: 10.1097/PGP.0000000000000488 ABSTRACT P53 immunohistochemistry has evolved into an accurate surrogate reflecting the underlying TP53 mutation status of a tumor, and has utility in the diagnostic workup of endometrial carcinomas. Recent work predominantly carried out in tubo-ovarian high-grade serous carcinoma has revealed 4 main patterns of p53 staining (normal/wild-type, complete absence, overexpression, and cytoplasmic); the latter 3 patterns are variably termed abnormal/aberrant/mutation-type and are strongly predictive of an underlying TP53 mutation. The aim of this review is to provide practical advice to pathologists regarding various aspects of p53 immunohistochemical staining. These include laboratory methods to optimize staining, a description of the different patterns of staining, advice regarding the interpretation, and reporting of p53 staining and practical uses of p53 staining in endometrial carcinoma diagnosis. Illustrations are provided to aid in the interpretational problems. The mutational status of TP53 is the single most important molecular factor, which predicts prognosis in endometrial carcinomas, with the presence of a TP53 mutation being associated with an unfavorable outcome 1,2. The TP53 mutation status may be used clinically in different ways such as aiding in the distinction between serous and endometrioid histotype 3,4, predicting outcome within a given histotype 1,5 or predicting outcome across several histotypes 2. The value of p53 in these scenarios is discussed in several other papers in this issue. As most pathologists do not have access to TP53 sequencing, they use p53 immunohistochemistry, which is quick, easy to perform, and inexpensive, as a surrogate for TP53 mutational analysis. Hence, p53 immunohistochemistry is very commonly utilized on endometrial carcinoma samples. The aim of this review is to provide practical advice to pathologists regarding various aspects of p53 immunohistochemical staining. These include laboratory methods to optimize staining, a description of the different patterns of staining, advice regarding the interpretation, and reporting of p53 staining and practical uses of p53 staining in endometrial carcinomas. DIFFERENT PATTERNS OF P53 STAINING It has long been recognized that nonsynonymous TP53 missense mutations result in nuclear accumulation of p53 protein that can be detected as overexpression by immunohistochemistry. This is in the form of diffuse strong nuclear positivity involving at least 80% of the tumor cells but usually almost 100%. With increased refinement of immunohistochemistry, we, and others, observed other abnormal p53 expression patterns that correlate with the presence of a TP53 mutation. Although most of this work has been performed in tubo-ovarian high-grade serous carcinomas, these patterns are also found in other tumor types 6,7 and we believe that identical staining protocols and interpretational cut points apply for endometrial carcinomas. However, validation studies in endometrial carcinomas are necessary. A 3-tier system has been recommended for p53 immunohistochemistry interpretation with overexpression and complete absence (which requires the presence of a positive internal control with staining of non-neoplastic cells such as lymphocytes, fibroblasts, or endothelial cells) both interpreted as abnormal/aberrant/mutation-type, in contrast to the normal/wild-type pattern with p53 expression levels in between these extremes 6,7. Wild-type staining is characterized by an admixture of negative cells, weakly and strongly positive cells. Subsequent studies using ovarian carcinomas validated that optimized immunohistochemistry agrees extremely well (specificity up to 100%) with the underlying TP53 mutation status 8–10. In other words, if the p53 staining pattern is abnormal (aberrant/mutation-type) there is almost certainly an underlying TP53 mutation. Notably, some splice site mutations or truncating mutations (the latter characterized by c-terminal stopgain) can result in detectable (but nonfunctional) p53 protein yielding a normal wild-type staining pattern. This occurs in ∼5% of tubo-ovarian high-grade serous carcinomas. With optimized immunohistochemistry, a fourth uncommon p53 staining pattern was observed. This cytoplasmic pattern is characterized by an unequivocal cytoplasmic staining, which is accompanied by a variable nuclear staining. Strong diffuse nuclear overexpression with low-intensity cytoplasmic background should interpreted as overexpression and not cytoplasmic. In tubo-ovarian high-grade serous carcinomas, the cytoplasmic pattern is associated with mutations disrupting the nuclear localization domain of the p53 protein 9. Thus, there are currently 4 patterns of p53 staining (Fig. 1), which correlate with the TP53 mutational status, resulting in 2 main corresponding interpretational categories (Table 1). Table 1 shows the percentages of the different staining patterns seen in tubo-ovarian high-grade serous carcinomas, where TP53 mutations are ubiquitous. [Figure: Different patterns of p53 expression. (A) Endometrial endometrioid carcinoma showing normal wild-type pattern of p53 expression with variable proportion of tumor cell nuclei staining with variable intensity. Note, this wild-type pattern should not be reported as “positive,” because this is ambiguous reporting language. (B) Endometrial endometrioid carcinoma, grade 3, with overexpression, showing strong staining in virtually all tumor cell nuclei, much stronger compared with the internal control of fibroblasts in the center. Note, there is some cytoplasmic background indicating that this staining is quite strong but this should not be interpreted as abnormal cytoplasmic pattern. (C) Endometrial serous carcinoma showing complete absence of p53 expression with internal control showing moderate to strong but variable staining. Note, wild-type pattern in normal atrophic glands at 12 and 6 o’clock. (D) Endometrial endometrioid carcinoma showing cytoplasmic p53 expression with internal control (stroma and normal endometrial glands) showing nuclear wild-type pattern. The cytoplasmic pattern is accompanied by nuclear staining of similar intensity.] [Table: p53 immunohistochemical staining patterns observed in tubo-ovarian high-grade serous carcinoma] While immunohistochemistry can accurately predict the TP53 mutation status and high interobserver agreement can be achieved with training 11, significant variation regarding the interpretation of p53 immunohistochemistry is still observed in practice. In the following sections, we review difficult areas in the interpretation of p53 immunohistochemistry, including interpretational difficulties between the normal wild-type staining versus the 3 abnormal staining patterns. We also discuss problems with heterogenous staining (defined as subclonally abnormal staining within wild type staining) that can sometimes be seen in endometrial carcinomas. We recommend that p53 staining should not be reported as positive or negative as this is confusing and ambiguous terminology; rather the pattern of staining should be reported as wild-type or abnormal/aberrant/mutation-type and the pattern of the latter described. INTERPRETATIONAL DIFFICULTIES: NORMAL WILD-TYPE VERSUS ABNORMAL OVEREXPRESSION Currently the main use of p53 immunohistochemistry is to predict the presence or absence of TP53 mutation rather than a specific group of mutation, which may become of interest in the future when certain TP53 mutations may become targetable 12. The normal wild-type pattern can show a significant range of staining from only very few tumor cell nuclei positive to the majority of nuclei being positive. The level of wild-type p53 expression is dependent on the cellular state of differentiation and related to the proliferative activity. Tumors with a higher proliferation index often show more p53 staining and tumors with so-called “high” wild-type staining may be confused with overexpression. Figures 2A and B show examples of tumors that were stained with a high p53 antibody concentration (see below). To guide interpretation, the p53 expression levels should be compared with the internal control (these cases show clear p53 staining in normal stromal fibroblasts, endothelial cells, and lymphocytes), and also to the expected overexpression pattern for this protocol (these cases, eg, stain weaker compared