Androgen receptor degradation by the proteolysis-targeting chimera ARCC-4 outperforms enzalutamide in cellular models of prostate cancer drug resistance.

Salami J, Alabi S, Willard RR, Vitale NJ, Wang J, Dong H, Jin M, McDonnell DP, Crew AP, Neklesa TK, Crews CM. · 2018

Read Androgen receptor degradation by the proteolysis-targeting chimera ARCC-4 outperforms enzalutamide in cellular models of prostate cancer drug resistance. by Salami J, Alabi S, Willard RR, Vitale NJ, Wang J, Dong H, Jin M, McDonnell DP, Crew AP, Neklesa TK, Crews CM. (2018) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc6123676.txt.

Introduction

Salami and co-authors present a research article in Communications Biology on a new way to attack prostate cancer. The androgen receptor drives this cancer. Drugs like enzalutamide block it, but most patients grow resistant in time. The team tested a degrader called ARCC-4 instead.

ARCC-4 tags the receptor for destruction by the cell. It wiped out about 95 percent of receptors in lab models. It also broke down mutant receptors seen in patients. Unlike enzalutamide, it kept working when androgen levels were high. The authors say degrading the receptor may beat merely blocking it.

Catalog record

CREATORSalami J, Alabi S, Willard RR, Vitale NJ, Wang J, Dong H, Jin M, McDonnell DP, Crew AP, Neklesa TK, Crews CM.
YEAR2018
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE44 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC6123676

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Androgen receptor degradation by the proteolysis-targeting chimera ARCC-4 outperforms enzalutamide in cellular models of prostate cancer drug resistance By Jemilat Salami, Shanique Alabi, Ryan R. Willard, Nick J. Vitale, Jing Wang, Hanqing Dong, Meizhong Jin, Donald P. McDonnell, Andrew P. Crew, Taavi K. Neklesa, Craig M. Crews Published in: Communications Biology DOI: 10.1038/s42003-018-0105-8 ABSTRACT The androgen receptor is a major driver of prostate cancer and inhibition of its transcriptional activity using competitive antagonists, such as enzalutamide remains a frontline therapy for prostate cancer management. However, the majority of patients eventually develop drug resistance. We propose that targeting the androgen receptor for degradation via Proteolysis Targeting Chimeras (PROTACs) will be a better therapeutic strategy for targeting androgen receptor signaling in prostate cancer cells. Here we perform a head-to-head comparison between a currently approved androgen receptor antagonist enzalutamide, and its PROTAC derivative, ARCC-4, across different cellular models of prostate cancer drug resistance. ARCC-4 is a low-nanomolar androgen receptor degrader able to degrade about 95% of cellular androgen receptors. ARCC-4 inhibits prostate tumor cell proliferation, degrades clinically relevant androgen receptor point mutants and unlike enzalutamide, retains antiproliferative effect in a high androgen environment. Thus, ARCC-4 exemplifies how protein degradation can address the drug resistance hurdles of enzalutamide. INTRODUCTION Androgen receptor (AR) signaling is crucial for normal prostate development, but also drives the growth and survival of prostate cancer cells. As such, AR signaling suppression is a common strategy for treating prostate cancer1. For example, androgen deprivation therapy (ADT), via either surgical or chemical castration, has been the standard of care for decades2,3. Nonetheless, a castration-resistant form of the disease eventually develops, whereby tumor cell proliferation resumes despite sub-castration levels of serum testosterone2. More recently, the addition of anti-androgen therapy to ADT, either in the form of AR inhibitors (e.g., enzalutamide)4 or CYP17 inhibitors, has improved overall survival5,6, although resistance ultimately still develops. As tumors progress, the majority of patients demonstrate AR gene amplifications or mutations, and these two events appear mutually exclusive7. Almost all patients also demonstrate a rise in serum prostate specific antigen (PSA) levels8, suggesting that AR remains the principal driver of metastatic disease. Like other occupancy-based inhibitors, the antiandrogen enzalutamide requires high saturating drug concentrations to achieve its clinical benefit9,10. Unfortunately, this need to achieve and maintain high systemic concentrations is one of the major challenges in drug development today. However, in recent years, an alternative potential therapeutic approach, i.e., induced protein degradation11–13, has emerged and is based on event-driven (as opposed to occupancy-driven) pharmacology. This therapeutic approach is best exemplified by Proteolysis Targeting Chimeras (PROTACs), which are heterobifunctional molecules that work by creating a trimeric complex between a target protein and an E3 ubiquitin ligase, thus facilitating target ubiquitination and subsequent degradation14–16. The fact that PROTAC engagement leads to target protein degradation offers a potential advantage over occupancy-based inhibitors. To explore the potential advantages of a degrader versus an inhibitor, we synthesized a variety of enzalutamide-based von Hippel-Lindau (VHL)-recruiting AR PROTACs and selected our most potent compound ARCC-4 to compare with its parent inhibitor enzalutamide. We demonstrate herein that compared to its parent inhibitor, ARCC-4 is better at overcoming resistance in cellular models of castration-resistant prostate cancer (CRPC). Specifically, ARCC-4 is better than enzalutamide at inducing apoptosis and inhibiting proliferation of AR-amplified prostate cancer cells. Furthermore, ARCC-4 effectively degrades clinically relevant AR mutants associated with antiandrogen therapy, and maintains its potency to degrade AR and inhibit cell proliferation in a high androgen environment in which enzalutamide has no activity. We expect that PROTAC-mediated AR degradation can potentially address a number of AR-dependent mechanisms of drug resistance that are characteristic of castration-resistant prostate cancer but currently not addressed by enzalutamide-mediated inhibition. RESULTS AR PROTAC potently degrades AR in multiple cancer cell lines We generated AR-targeting PROTACs (compounds 2a–c) by appending enzalutamide to our previously reported VHL E3 ligase ligand17 via different linkers (Supplementary Figure 1, Fig. 1). To control for the notable size and cell permeability differences between the PROTACs and enzalutamide, we also designed an epimeric PROTAC (compound 3) by appending enzalutamide to a VHL diastereomeric ligand that does not bind to or recruit VHL for target ubiquitination (Supplementary Figure 1), thereby creating a physicochemically-matched PROTAC analog capable of inhibiting AR but not inducing its degradation. We chose the VCaP cell line to assess the efficacy of our AR PROTACs since it exhibits wild-type AR amplification, splice variant AR-V7 expression, and TMPRSS2-Erg translocation and is a well-validated model of CRPC18–20. Although this cell line expresses markers that are predictive of enzalutamide resistance, they do in fact respond to the antiandrogenic actions of this drug at high concentrations21.Fig. 1Structures of AR-targeting PROTACs. a Chemical structures of enzalutamide. b–d Chemical structures of AR PROTACs 2a, 2b, and 2c. e Chemical structure of inactive epimer, which does not bind VHL. f Chemical structure of VHL component of AR PROTACs and epimer (R and R’, respectively), indicating the corresponding stereochemistry. g Chemical structure of selective androgen receptor degrader compound, SARD279 We first treated VCaP cells with increasing concentrations of different AR PROTACs (2a–c) for 20 h and assessed AR levels post-treatment (Fig. 2). We also tested our previously reported selective AR degrader SARD27922 in these experiments for comparison. All three AR PROTACs degraded AR, however to different extents; 2a was the least potent, 2b showed better potency, and 2c was the most potent, achieving 50% AR degradation (DC50) at 5 nM and a maximum degradation (Dmax) of over 95% (Table 1). We also observed the “hook effect” with 2b, in which loss of target degradation is seen at higher concentrations of some PROTACs due to the formation of separate binary complexes of PROTAC-E3 ligase and PROTAC-target protein instead of the productive ternary complex of E3 ligase-PROTAC-target protein23,24. We were not surprised at the lack of a hook effect with compound 2c as it is not our first potent PROTAC to not display a hook effect25. We suspect that the lack of hook effect with some of our potent PROTACs may be as a result of positive cooperativity, i.e., additional protein–protein interactions between the E3 ligase and target protein, upon ternary complex formation. We hypothesize that ARCC-4 might enhance protein–protein interactions between AR and VHL, thereby promoting the association of the trimeric complex. Given that 2c was the most potent PROTAC, we proceeded with this compound (subsequently denoted as ARCC-4) for further experiments.Fig. 2Activity of AR-targeting PROTACs. VCaP cells cultured in charcoal-stripped serum (CSS) were treated with enzalutamide (enza), AR PROTACs (2a, 2b, and 2c) and SARD279 for 20 h. AR levels were determined by western blots. The western blot shows biological replicates and is representative of two independent experiments (n = 2). See Supplementary Figure 7 for full blot imagesTable 1Degradation activity of AR-targeting PROTACs D max DC50 [nM]Enza--2a47%-2b76%152c98%5SARD27969%1099DC50 is the concentration of compound required to achieve 50% degradation. Dmax is the maximum degradation achieved by compound. DC50 and Dmax values were calculated using quantified band intensities from western blots shown in Fig. 2 Following our observations of AR degradation in VCaP cells after 20 h of PROTAC treatment, we sought to investigate the kinetics of this degradation. VCaP cells were treated with 100 nM ARCC-4 for different lengths of time and AR

Read the complete text