P2Rank: machine learning based tool for rapid and accurate prediction of ligand binding sites from protein structure.
Krivák R, Hoksza D. · 2018
Read P2Rank: machine learning based tool for rapid and accurate prediction of ligand binding sites from protein structure. by Krivák R, Hoksza D. (2018) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc6091426.txt.
Introduction
Krivák and Hoksza present P2Rank, a fast tool for finding ligand binding sites on proteins. Their article appeared in the Journal of Cheminformatics. Binding pockets guide drug design and reveal protein function. Many prior tools are slow or web-only. Pipelines need stand-alone speed instead.
P2Rank scores points on a protein's surface. Machine learning judges each local chemical neighborhood. The tool beat four rivals in their tests. Those rivals included a deep learning method. Predictions finish in under one second per protein. It runs multi-threaded with a light install. No outside databases are required. Readers get a pocket finder built for large data sets.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Krivák R, Hoksza D. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2018 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 64 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
P2Rank: machine learning based tool for rapid and accurate prediction of ligand binding sites from protein structure By Radoslav Krivák, David Hoksza Published in: Journal of Cheminformatics DOI: 10.1186/s13321-018-0285-8 ABSTRACT Background Ligand binding site prediction from protein structure has many applications related to elucidation of protein function and structure based drug discovery. It often represents only one step of many in complex computational drug design efforts. Although many methods have been published to date, only few of them are suitable for use in automated pipelines or for processing large datasets. These use cases require stability and speed, which disqualifies many of the recently introduced tools that are either template based or available only as web servers. Results We present P2Rank, a stand-alone template-free tool for prediction of ligand binding sites based on machine learning. It is based on prediction of ligandability of local chemical neighbourhoods that are centered on points placed on the solvent accessible surface of a protein. We show that P2Rank outperforms several existing tools, which include two widely used stand-alone tools (Fpocket, SiteHound), a comprehensive consensus based tool (MetaPocket 2.0), and a recent deep learning based method (DeepSite). P2Rank belongs to the fastest available tools (requires under 1 s for prediction on one protein), with additional advantage of multi-threaded implementation. Conclusions P2Rank is a new open source software package for ligand binding site prediction from protein structure. It is available as a user-friendly stand-alone command line program and a Java library. P2Rank has a lightweight installation and does not depend on other bioinformatics tools or large structural or sequence databases. Thanks to its speed and ability to make fully automated predictions, it is particularly well suited for processing large datasets or as a component of scalable structural bioinformatics pipelines. Electronic supplementary material The online version of this article (10.1186/s13321-018-0285-8) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users. BACKGROUND Motivation Prediction of ligand binding sites (LBS, or simply pockets1) from protein structure has many applications in elucidation of protein function [1] and rational drug design [2–4]. It has been employed in drug side-effects prediction [5], fragment-based drug discovery [6], docking prioritization [7, 8], structure based virtual screening [9] and structure-based target prediction (or so called inverse virtual screening) [10]. Increasingly, LBS prediction is being used in large-scale structural studies that try to analyze and compare all known and putative binding sites on a genome-wide level [11–15]. In practice, it is often the case that predicting ligand binding sites is not an end in itself but it represents only a step in larger automated solution or pipeline. For example, druggability prediction server PockDrug-Server [16] relies on LBS prediction internally. Similarly, allosteric site prediction tools Allosite [17] and AlloPred [17] both employ pocket prediction tool Fpocket [18] as the first step of their algorithms. In the rest of this section we will summarize existing methods and available tools. We will introduce categorization along several lines:web servers/stand-alone tools,template based/template-free methods,residue-centric/pocket-centric prediction,and we will discuss strengths and weaknesses of tools in these categories. We will also discuss an overlooked aspect of the speed of available tools. We will try to convey that there is a strong case for new fast stand-alone user-friendly tool that is not based on search in a large template library of known protein-ligand complexes. Existing approaches Existing methods for LBS prediction are based on variety of algorithmic approaches. Traditionally, methods have been categorized based on their main algorithmic strategy into geometric, energetic, conservation based, template based (the last two also sometimes referred to as evolutionary) and machine learning/knowledge based. In reality, many of the state-of-the-art tools are based on some combination of the mentioned approaches. Methods based on consensus of results of other algorithms have also emerged. Table 1 lists available tools for LBS prediction from protein structure introduced since 2009 (to cover most recent and still widely used methods). In the following paragraphs we will introduce the tools that we have used to comparatively evaluate the performance of P2Rank. More details on existing approaches, including older ones, can be found in numerous reviews and surveys [3, 7, 19–25]. Fpocket is a fast geometric stand-alone tool based on filtering and clustering of alpha spheres found by way of Voronoi tessellation [18]. It has been one of the most widely used methods in recent years, especially in large scale applications. Fpocket typically produces relatively high number of predicted pockets for one protein. Among them, Fpocket finds most of the known binding sites, but they are not always ranked at the top. To address this problem, we have previously developed a method called PRANK [26] that is able to re-score binding site predicted by Fpocket and thus improve relevance of its results (i.e. improve identification success rate among Top-n pockets). Usage simplicity of Fpocket together with its computational efficiency contribute to the fact that it remains a popular choice for LBS prediction, as can be illustrated by its employment in recent large-scale structural studies [11–15]. Overall good user experience with Fpocket in contrast with other available methods has been an inspiration for designing our tool. MetaPocket 2.0 is a prominent example of a consensus based method [27]. It aggregates results produced by 8 different previously published algorithms by taking top 3 sites predicted by each method. It was shown to perform better that any single one of those individual methods. MetaPocket 2.0 is only available as a web server. SiteHound is one of the latest energetic methods, and the latest one with stand-alone version [28]. It works by placing a probe on a grid points around a protein surface and calculating interaction energies with the help of underlying force field software. It is available as a web server and as a fully automated stand-alone tool. Fpocket, SiteHound and MetaPocket 2.0 belong to the most cited and widely used template-free methods introduced in the last decade. The tool presented in this article is based on machine learning from examples. As a main approach, machine learning has been under-utilized among published methods. Although some studies that applied machine learning to the problem have been published, their focus was mainly on classification of binding residues rather than on predicting binding sites as such [29–31]. Machine learning has been also employed to solve partial tasks in complex eFindSite and COACH methods. Tools based primarily on machine learning have been introduced only very recently [32, 33] (with notable earlier exception [34]). The latest one of them is DeepSite, a method based on multi-layer (for different atom types) voxelized representation of 3D space and deep convolutional neural networks. It is available only as a web server, but it is reasonably fast and has usable, although undocumented web API. Studies that introduced existing methods reported relatively high identification success rates, usually on traditional small datasets. However, the results of the only independent benchmark [21] suggest that existing methods may not be as accurate as previously believed when applied to new datasets. It showed that there is still a need for more accurate methods, and that nominally high results reported by the authors of respective methods may not be always indicative of their true performance on unseen proteins.Table 1Availability of existing tools for ligand binding site prediction