Bringing cultured meat to market: Technical, socio-political, and regulatory challenges in cellular agriculture.
Stephens N, Di Silvio L, Dunsford I, Ellis M, Glencross A, Sexton A. · 2018
Read Bringing cultured meat to market: Technical, socio-political, and regulatory challenges in cellular agriculture. by Stephens N, Di Silvio L, Dunsford I, Ellis M, Glencross A, Sexton A. (2018) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc6078906.txt.
Introduction
Stephens and co-authors map the hurdles facing cultured meat on its way to market. Their article appeared in Trends in Food Science and Technology. Cultured meat grows muscle cells without raising livestock. It belongs to the wider field of cellular agriculture. The team drew on lab work and over seventy expert interviews.
Technical problems come first. Cell sources, growth media, and scale-up all need work. The social debate often shrinks to ethics and shoppers. The authors push it wider, toward politics and industry shape. Rules for approval remain unsettled and fuzzy. United Kingdom policy supplies the detailed case. Readers get a full agenda for a young food industry.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Stephens N, Di Silvio L, Dunsford I, Ellis M, Glencross A, Sexton A. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2018 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 97 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Bringing cultured meat to market: Technical, socio-political, and regulatory challenges in cellular agriculture By Neil Stephens, Lucy Di Silvio, Illtud Dunsford, Marianne Ellis, Abigail Glencross, Alexandra Sexton Published in: Trends in Food Science & Technology DOI: 10.1016/j.tifs.2018.04.010 ABSTRACT Abstract Background Cultured meat forms part of the emerging field of cellular agriculture. Still an early stage field it seeks to deliver products traditionally made through livestock rearing in novel forms that require no, or significantly reduced, animal involvement. Key examples include cultured meat, milk, egg white and leather. Here, we focus upon cultured meat and its technical, socio-political and regulatory challenges and opportunities. Scope and approach The paper reports the thinking of an interdisciplinary team, all of whom have been active in the field for a number of years. It draws heavily upon the published literature, as well as our own professional experience. This includes ongoing laboratory work to produce cultured meat and over seventy interviews with experts in the area conducted in the social science work. Key findings and conclusions Cultured meat is a promising, but early stage, technology with key technical challenges including cell source, culture media, mimicking the in-vivo myogenesis environment, animal-derived and synthetic materials, and bioprocessing for commercial-scale production. Analysis of the social context has too readily been reduced to ethics and consumer acceptance, and whilst these are key issues, the importance of the political and institutional forms a cultured meat industry might take must also be recognised, and how ambiguities shape any emergent regulatory system. Keywords: Cellular agriculture, Cultured meat, Clean meat, In vitro meat, Society, Regulation INTRODUCTION Cultured meat involves applying the practices of tissue engineering to the production of muscle for consumption as food. Sometimes also known as clean meat or in vitro meat, it is an emergent technology that operates as part of the wider field of cellular agriculture and in a relation of competition and collaboration with innovation in plant-based proteins. This paper contributes to a growing number of review papers about cultured meat (Arshad et al., 2017; Datar & Betti, 2010; Kadim, Mahgoub, Baqir, Faye, & Purchas, 2015; Post, 2012). What is distinct about this paper is a willingness to engage in articulating the practical challenges facing the field and the call for extending the socio-political debate on cultured meat beyond ‘ethics’ and ‘consumer acceptance’ to include complex policy issues like food transitions and practical regulatory mechanisms. Subsequently this paper focuses upon a detailed account of cultured meat. While we recognise the value of conducting a direct comparison between cultured and traditional meat systems or other innovative approaches, such comparative work is beyond the scope of this paper and we direct readers to other contributions for this work (Alexander et al., 2017; Bonny et al., 2015). While the paper is of international relevance, as the issues described are applicable in all territories, we base our more grounded and detailed discussion on the policy context of pre-Brexit UK as this is the locality we understand best. Our analysis derives from a diverse set of collective experiences as participants and analysts of the cultured meat and livestock meat contexts, and is supported by over seventy expert interviews with participants active in cellular agriculture and other alternative protein developments over a five-year period. Interviewees include professionals engaged in producing cultured meat and other cellular agriculture products within both universities and in companies, funders of this work, and complimentary interviews with professionals working in plant-based meat substitutes and edible insects. The global livestock industry has come under increasing scrutiny in recent years due to the scale of its environmental, ethical, and human health impacts (Scollan et al., 2011). These concerns, coupled with projections that demand for protein products will continue to rise over the coming decades (Gerber et al., 2013), means there is an urgent need for methods of protein production that are more sustainable, nutritious and animal welfare-conscious. Protein analogues (non-animal proteins) already go some way towards achieving this; however, the desire to eat meat and animal-derived foods has led to the emergence of cellular agriculture, which aims to produce animal proteins using fewer animals and less animal-derived material than the current livestock industry, by utilising culturing techniques. This approach aims to marry a consumer desire to eat meat with the drive to ensure global food security, a nutritious diet, and reduce the environmental burden of food production. Research has shown a rise in UK consumers incorporating more vegetarian and vegan choices into their diets (Caldwell, 2015). Informa Agribusiness Intelligence estimates that by 2021 UK sales of meat analogues will grow by 25% and milk alternatives by 43%; such growth will take the total UK sales of milk alternatives from £149 million (US$208 million) to £299 million (US$400 million) (FoodBevMedia, 2017). Significant growth is also expected at the global scale, with a recent estimate predicting the global protein analogue market to be worth $46 billion (GBP£33 billion) by 2020 (Business Wire, 2018). Globally, it is projected that the protein analogue market will generate £5.2 billion in revenue by 2020 (Allied Market Research, 2014). Yet despite projections of market and cultural shifts appearing to favour protein innovation, there is a critical need to examine cultured meat within the contexts of existing food policy and the existing material landscape of food production. If the associated technical and consumer-perception challenges that have been identified in other literature, and to which this document speaks to in later sections, can be overcome there is real potential for these technologies to instigate considerable material and regulatory changes to local, national and international food systems. Understanding what these changes are and what consequences – both positive and negative – they may bring is, we argue, an important task to conduct while these technologies remain relatively nascent in their development. In seeking to address these issues, this article (i) provides an overview of the state-of-the-art of cultured meat technology, (ii) situates it among broader innovations in cellular agriculture, (iii) discusses the potential benefits of cultured meat, (iv) details the technical challenges faced, and (v) identifies key consumer, political and regulatory aspects of cultured meat. These last two sections on technical and social issues also articulate some of the challenges, weaknesses, and concerns about cultured meat technology. CULTURED MEAT AND CELLULAR AGRICULTURE Cultured meat 2.1. In the early 2000s, two projects were conducted to produce cultured tissue for food purposes: one by a NASA-funded college-based group (Benjaminson, Gilchriest, & Lorenz, 2002), and another by a team of bio-artists in the Tissue Culture and Art Project (Catts & Zurr, 2010). Both projects produced small quantities of tissue, with the NASA group performing sniff-tests to assess palatability, and the bio-arts team conducting taste-tests as part of an arts performance piece. In 2005 the Dutch government funded the first of two three-year research projects in the area based upon PhD studentships that sought to culture porcine adult and embryonic stem cells (du Puy, 2010; Wilschut, Jaksani, Van Den Dolder, Haagsman, & Roelen, 2008), develop an algae-based culturing medium (Tuomisto & de Mattos, 2011), and use electronic and chemical stimuli to induce mouse muscle cell growth (Langelaan et al., 2011). From this Dutch work came the field's most high-profile moment when Professor Mark Post of Maastricht University