Rickets: A Historical Note.

Findlay L. · 1919

Read Rickets: A Historical Note. by Findlay L. (1919) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc5924024.txt.

Introduction

Findlay wrote a historical note on rickets and its presence in ancient times. The note appeared in the Glasgow Medical Journal in 1919. Findlay was a physician at Glasgow's children's hospital. Rickets is fostered by poor housing, crowding, and lack of air. Many authors placed its first appearance in fairly modern times. He asked whether it existed far earlier.

He searched ancient Egyptian medical papyri for any trace. He found no reference that suggested the disease. Excavated bones from Egypt and Nubia also lacked clear signs. Experts he cites doubt claims made for ancient remains. Captive apes in temples may have shown it, though. The note weighs sparse proof with care.

Catalog record

CREATORFindlay L.
YEAR1919
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE19 KB
LICENSEPublic Domain
RIGHTSPUBLIC DOMAIN
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC5924024

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Rickets: A Historical Note By Leonard Findlay Published in: Glasgow Medical Journal Dr. Leonard Findlay?Rickets: An Historical Note. 147 RICKETS: A HISTORICAL NOTE. By LEONARD FINDLAY, M.D., D.Sc., Visiting Physician, Royal Hospital for Sick Children, Glasgow. Although in the words of Barlow,1 " rickets was probably coeval with civilisation," it is credited by most authors with having made its appearance within comparatively modern times. Whatever be the nature of the specific etiological factor, we appreciate to-day that this disease is engendered and fostered by bad social conditions, comprising bad housing, overcrowding, and deficient air and exercise, and consequently we would not be surprised to learn that it had existed in ancient times, if not when the older civilisations were at their zenith, at least when they were decadent. The conditions of living were certainly not of the best, e.g., in ancient Egypt, but there is no evidence that the disease was extant either in the heyday of this civilisation or later on during the Christian era. I have searched the translations of the avail- able medical papyri (Eber's Papyrus, Brugsch Papyrus, and the London Papyrus),and can find no reference to anything suggesting the condition. The bulk of these works is devoted to prescrip- tions of remedies, though the symptoms of several maladies are described. One striking feature of the literature of the ancient Egyptians is the reticence regarding child life. In these times there was great specialisation of the practice of medicine, yet the branch of obstetrics was given over to women, and it is not improbable that child welfare was also neglected by the physician as, unfortunately, has been the case in our own time. Elliot Smith,2 in his work on the Nubian Survey, states that among the excavated skeletons of ancient Egypt "it is not uncommon to find peculiar though slight bending of all the long bones. The reason for hesitation in adopting such a view is that clear unmistakable evidence of rachitic changes has not been found in human bones in any ancient cemetery in Egypt or 148 Dr. Leonard Findlay?Rickets: An Historical Note. Nubia." In a personal communication Professor Elliot Smith writes that he is "extremely doubtful whether rickets ever really occurred in ancient Egypt," and he considers " that RufFer, not being aware of the extent to which the perfectly normal femur can be curved, imagined he had found rickets in ancient remains from the Soudan." Elliot Smith at the same time drew my attention to the fact that Lortet,3 of Lyons, described rickets in the remains of apes which had been kept captive in one of the Theban temples. Should such, indeed, be the case, it would cause us no surprise, as in modern times young monkeys kept in captivity are liable to develop rickets. Hansemann4 some years ago recorded that monkeys kept captive in Japan, where rickets at the time was unknown, developed the disease. A further confirmation of the absence of rickets in the human subject in ancient Egypt is found in the work of Soranus Ephesius to be mentioned below. This physician studied at Alexandria, and though he had apparently observed the disease in Rome, he makes no mention of ever having seen it in Egypt, and specifically states that it did not affect Greek children. Certain authors, nevertheless, have construed passages in Greek writings?medical and lay?as descriptions of the disease. Zesas in an article on the history of rickets draws attention to the following passage from Hippocrates' work, De Articulis :? " Et quibus supra septem gibbositas est, his et costse in ampli- tudinem augeri non solent, sed in anteriorem partem et pectus acutum fit sed non latum, ipsique ei difficulter spirant," &c. [With regard to those who are hunchbacked after the age of seven, their ribs do not, as a rule, increase proportionately, but bend towards the back; their chest becomes sharp instead of broad and they themselves have difficulty in breathing.] To my mind this passage can hardly be taken as describing rickets?the whole description is more in keeping with tuber- cular disease of the spine. Homer5 in the "Iliad," which was written about 900 B.C., describes a court jester, Thersites, as " bandy-legged, lame of one foot, the shoulders rounded, arched down upon his chest and over them his head was warped and a scanty stubble sprouted on it," which Delpeuch considers a picture typical of rickets. Delpeuch,6 Marfan,7 and Bouchard all refer to the possibility of Dr. Leonard Findlay?Rickets: An Historical Note. 149 the court jester of the ancients, and also of the middle ages, being rachitic, and draw attention to descriptions and bas-reliefs of deformed dwarfs, such as we find depicted above in Homer. I consider it doubtful, however, if these individuals were really rachitic. Mental deficiency, or at least mental aberration, was characteristic of the court jester, and they were adults, whereas rachitic individuals are not mentally deficient, and it is during childhood that the severe deformities are present, the majority being of fairly normal appearance by the time they reach adult life. It is more probable that these deformed court jesters were more akin to our " village naturals" and deformed from paralysis, osteogenesis imperfecta, and achondroplasia. The first undoubted reference to a condition simulating rickets that I have been able to obtain dates from the first century of our era, and is to be found in the work on "Diseases of Women" by Soranus Ephesius, who lived between 98 and 138 a.d. According to Suidas, " Soranus Ephesius, the son of Menander and Phoebe, lived some time in Alexandria, practised as a physician at Rome in the reigns of Trojan and Hadrian and composed many beautiful works."8 A German translation of Ephesius' "Diseases of Women" entitled "Die Gynaekologie" was published in 1894 at Munich by H. Luneburg and J. Ch. Huber as the first of a series of a Bibliothek medicinischer Klassiker. That this author was referring to rickets would seem undoubted. His description of the condition is so perfect and his remarks regarding the distribution and probable cause of the disease so interesting that I will quote his words in full:? 7tgi. n<w9 Sei KaOl^eiv kcil TrepnraTrjcriv doiceiv. Ka0/?eiy Se kcu aiAcrTacOai tov f3pe(/)ov$ 7reipd?ovTO$, fiorjQeiv avrov to/? Kivrjfiacri Sei. Td\iov fiev yap irpoOvfiovfievov KaOi^eiv kcll iueXP1 elcoOe KvprovarOai, KafurTOfievrj? rrjs pdx^m Sia to iir]7rco Ta crcofiaTa tovov eyeiv. JlpoireTeGTepov Se dvicrTafievov kcu TrepLirareiv OeXovra, crrpecpeo-Oai Kara tov$ firjpovs ret (TKeXrj. 7r/3' Aid tl Ta 7r\eL<TTa toov ev Pdofit] iraiSwv SiacrTp?(peTai. Tovto Se kui fidXXov eir] ?Pco/iiis yivd/ievov OeoopeiTai. KaOw? fiev Tiveg inroXafi/3dvovcriv, otl ^Jsv^pdis vSaariv r] 7rdXi$ KaTwOev 150 Dr. Leonard Findlay?Rickets: An Historical Note. Siaipeirai, icai ra (JMfxara ivepL^v^erai paSico$. Ka0a)? Se Tive? Xeyov&i /cat Sia ra? <Tv\va$ tov yvvaiKcov crovovvlas, rj Sia to /ulera /j.eOrjv tolls <TV/i7r\oicdis xpijcrQai. To S' aXrjQes, Sia iraiSoTpoty'ia? aireipiav ov yap ey/ceiTai Toaravrrj (TTopyfj toll9 ev rrj iroXei yvvai^iv a)? to tcaff efcacTOv eTrifiXeireiv, ov Tpoirov TrpaTTOvviv ai KaOapcog 'l&WrjvlSes. M rjSevo? e7ri6ecop6vvTO$ ra /cmi/iara tcov (3pe<pa)v, SiacrTp6(f)?TaL ra KcoXa tcov irXeicrTcov. oXov yap to /3apo$ tov orcu/uLaTOs ?7TLK?LTai Toi$ (r/ceXecri, (JTepeov Se koli airoKpoTOV to eSa<j)0s w? av /cara to 7rXgmttop XlOois ecrTpcomevov. OTav ovv aVTLTVTTOV /UL?V rj, KGlff OV kX[p?L, fiapV

Read the complete text