Systematic analysis of protein turnover in primary cells.
Mathieson T, Franken H, Kosinski J, Kurzawa N, Zinn N, Sweetman G, Poeckel D, Ratnu VS, Schramm M, Becher I, Steidel M, Noh KM, Bergamini G, Beck M, Bantscheff M, Savitski MM. · 2018
Read Systematic analysis of protein turnover in primary cells. by Mathieson T, Franken H, Kosinski J, Kurzawa N, Zinn N, Sweetman G, Poeckel D, Ratnu VS, Schramm M, Becher I, Steidel M, Noh KM, Bergamini G, Beck M, Bantscheff M, Savitski MM. (2018) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc5814408.txt.
Introduction
Mathieson and co-authors refine how protein lifetimes are measured. Each protein in a cell is built and broken down in turn. Knowing those lifetimes aids health and disease research. Older methods lacked precision in cells that do not divide.
The team improved a labeling method called dynamic SILAC. Sharper peptide measures yield exact half-lives from 10 to over 1,000 hours. They profiled 4,000 to 6,000 proteins per cell type. B cells, killer cells, and monocytes looked alike. Liver cells and mouse neurons differed a lot. Parts of one protein complex tended to share a lifetime. Readers get a validated atlas of protein turnover.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Mathieson T, Franken H, Kosinski J, Kurzawa N, Zinn N, Sweetman G, Poeckel D, Ratnu VS, Schramm M, Becher I, Steidel M, Noh KM, Bergamini G, Beck M, Bantscheff M, Savitski MM. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2018 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 58 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Systematic analysis of protein turnover in primary cells By Toby Mathieson, Holger Franken, Jan Kosinski, Nils Kurzawa, Nico Zinn, Gavain Sweetman, Daniel Poeckel, Vikram S Ratnu, Maike Schramm, Isabelle Becher, Michael Steidel, Kyung-Min Noh Published in: Nature Communications DOI: 10.1038/s41467-018-03106-1 ABSTRACT Abstract A better understanding of proteostasis in health and disease requires robust methods to determine protein half-lives. Here we improve the precision and accuracy of peptide ion intensity-based quantification, enabling more accurate protein turnover determination in non-dividing cells by dynamic SILAC-based proteomics. This approach allows exact determination of protein half-lives ranging from 10 to >1000 h. We identified 4000–6000 proteins in several non-dividing cell types, corresponding to 9699 unique protein identifications over the entire data set. We observed similar protein half-lives in B-cells, natural killer cells and monocytes, whereas hepatocytes and mouse embryonic neurons show substantial differences. Our data set extends and statistically validates the previous observation that subunits of protein complexes tend to have coherent turnover. Moreover, analysis of different proteasome and nuclear pore complex assemblies suggests that their turnover rate is architecture dependent. These results illustrate that our approach allows investigating protein turnover and its implications in various cell types. INTRODUCTION Recent years have seen unprecedented progress in mass spectrometry-based proteomics1. This has enabled development of various new methodologies for interrogating the proteome. These include assessment of relative protein expression2, detection of protein ligand interactions3,4, monitoring changes in the abundance of post-translational modifications5, protein half-life determinations6–9, and many others. In order to continue improving proteome-wide characterization of proteostasis6,7,10,11, a further development of experimental and computational12,13 quantitative mass spectrometry14 work flows is required. For instance, when using dynamic SILAC (stable isotope labeling by amino acids in cell culture) to measure global protein turnover6,15, precise and accurate peptide ion intensity quantification is needed, since even small deviations in the accuracy of measured fold changes can have a pronounced effect on the half-life measurement. In particular, when measuring protein turnover in non-dividing cells16, many proteins will exhibit very-slow turnover because the continuous replication of the entire proteome, which occurs in exponentially growing cells is not required. As primary cells can only be kept in culture for a limited amount of time before adapting to the cell culture conditions or going into senescence, protein turnover determinations have to be based on relatively short-term treatments with stable isotope-encoded amino acids. Consequently, accurate and precise quantification is required in order to allow accurate determination of protein half-lives. We, therefore, developed procedures based on a better utilization of the isotopic distributions of ionized peptides to improve the accuracy and precision of peptide ion intensity-based quantification. We applied this peptide ion intensity quantification strategy to analyze mass spectrometry data from dynamic SILAC experiments17 performed in five different, non-dividing cell types: B-cells, monocytes, natural killer (NK) cells, hepatocytes, and mouse embryonic neurons to calculate protein half-lives as previously described6. We used this data set to validate and extend the previous observation18 of coherent subunit turnover of protein complexes, but also observed complex architecture-dependent protein half-life distributions. To demonstrate the usefulness of our data as a resource, we examined some exemplifying protein complexes in more detail. In agreement with previous literature19,20, we found that histone proteins, aside from some notable exceptions in hepatocytes, have extremely slow turnover. Both, proteasomes and nuclear pore complexes (NPCs), show a clear subcomplex-dependent turnover of their subunits. The extreme longevity of the NPC previously reported in vivo for brain tissue16, is not observed for any of the cell types investigated in vitro in this study. These results emphasize that slow NPC turnover is not a general phenomenon occurring in all non-dividing cells, but that specific NPC turnover mechanisms might exist. We conclude that our data set is a useful resource for the scientific community and our method can be broadly applied in the future. RESULTS Improvement of peptide ion-based protein quantification Protein half-life determination in non-dividing cells requires precise and accurate measurement of protein fold changes. In non-dividing cells the incorporation of heavy isotope labels will be very slow for some proteins, resulting in very-low new-to-old protein ratios because only a very-small portion of the isotope has yet been incorporated. As a consequence, the ratio determination is error prone, particularly at the early time points. Such data might be stringently filtered to select for high-confidence measurements, but at the cost of coverage, specifically affecting long-lived proteins. To achieve accurate protein half-life measurements with good coverage for long-lived proteins in primary cell systems, we investigated and optimized the parameters, which are relevant for determining very reproducible and accurate protein fold changes for the greatest possible number of proteins. We introduced two innovations into the data analysis workflow. First, we use the exact elemental composition of the identified peptides for calculating the theoretical isotopic envelope (see methods). We established that this method yields a more accurate representation of peptide ion intensities as compared to the previously used averagine model21 (Supplementary Figure 1) that relies on a scaled version of the average amino acid (Averagine), but does not take into account that the composition of an individual peptide might well differ from the average. Second, we used a measure to detect overlapping isotopic distributions of different peptides22,23 (see methods), to improve the quality of quantification (Supplementary Figures 1–3). Comparison of this quantification strategy with the widely used MaxQuant software shows that our methodology performs significantly better for cases when very-low protein ratios need to be quantified, and more accurately determines the protein fold changes (Supplementary Figure 4). For proteins where the fold changes are less pronounced both softwares perform equally well. This quantification strategy is, thus, well suited for determining protein half-lives of long-lived proteins in non-dividing cells. Protein half-life determination Five different non-dividing cell types, human B-cells, monocytes, NK cells, hepatocytes, as well as mouse embryonic neurons were each labeled with medium containing 13C615N4 K and 13C615N4 R (heavy SILAC) for four different time intervals ranging between 6 and 72 h (Fig. 1; Supplementary Data 1). Taken together across all five cell types, protein half-lives were determined for a total of 9699 unique protein groups (Supplementary Data 2). The coverage in individual cell types ranged from 4667 protein groups identified in NK cells to 6534 protein groups identified in mouse neurons. To specifically query and cross-compare the high-quality subset of the data, we selected protein half-lives where the regression line (the rate constant of the protein degradation) fitted to fold changes at different time points had a Pearson correlation coefficient R2 of >0.85,6,9. This criterion was fulfilled by 8804 proteins taken together across the five cell types. The mean half-life was calculated for proteins present in both biological replicates for each cell type. The comparison of protein half-lives between biological replicates (Fig. 2) reveals excellent reproducibility with many proteins showing half-lives of greater than 500 h. The R2 of the log10-transformed half-lives between replicates was 0.94, 0.92, 0.91, 0.93, and 0.93 for B-cells, monocytes, NK cells, hepatocytes, and mouse embryonic neurons, respectively. For 98% of all protein half-lives from the high-quality data set, the replicates differed by less than two-fold. The acquired data set, thus, represents the most extensive, high-quality catalog of protein half-lives in primary cells. [Figure: Experimental workflow for protein half-life determination