Halfway between 2D and Animal Models: Are 3D Cultures the Ideal Tool to Study Cancer-Microenvironment Interactions?
Hoarau-Véchot J, Rafii A, Touboul C, Pasquier J. · 2018
Read Halfway between 2D and Animal Models: Are 3D Cultures the Ideal Tool to Study Cancer-Microenvironment Interactions? by Hoarau-Véchot J, Rafii A, Touboul C, Pasquier J. (2018) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc5796130.txt.
Introduction
Hoarau-Véchot and co-authors review 3D cultures for studying how tumors interact with their surroundings. The tumor microenvironment shapes growth, spread, and drug resistance. Flat 2D cultures miss much of that dialogue. Animal models capture more, at higher cost and distance from human tissue.
Many 3D methods have appeared in recent years. The review sorts them and weighs each one's strengths and limits. It compares 3D work with classic flat cultures on set questions. The authors ask whether 3D tools can truly bridge bench and body. Their answer guides labs picking a model.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Hoarau-Véchot J, Rafii A, Touboul C, Pasquier J. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2018 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 88 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Halfway between 2D and Animal Models: Are 3D Cultures the Ideal Tool to Study Cancer-Microenvironment Interactions? By Jessica Hoarau-Véchot, Arash Rafii, Cyril Touboul, Jennifer Pasquier Published in: International Journal of Molecular Sciences DOI: 10.3390/ijms19010181 ABSTRACT An area that has come to be of tremendous interest in tumor research in the last decade is the role of the microenvironment in the biology of neoplastic diseases. The tumor microenvironment (TME) comprises various cells that are collectively important for normal tissue homeostasis as well as tumor progression or regression. Seminal studies have demonstrated the role of the dialogue between cancer cells (at many sites) and the cellular component of the microenvironment in tumor progression, metastasis, and resistance to treatment. Using an appropriate system of microenvironment and tumor culture is the first step towards a better understanding of the complex interaction between cancer cells and their surroundings. Three-dimensional (3D) models have been widely described recently. However, while it is claimed that they can bridge the gap between in vitro and in vivo, it is sometimes hard to decipher their advantage or limitation compared to classical two-dimensional (2D) cultures, especially given the broad number of techniques used. We present here a comprehensive review of the different 3D methods developed recently, and, secondly, we discuss the pros and cons of 3D culture compared to 2D when studying interactions between cancer cells and their microenvironment. 1. INTRODUCTION Despite the advances in treatment over the last decades, cancer remains a leading cause of death worldwide. Treating cancer has been challenging due to the complexity and heterogeneity of tumors, leading to resistance to chemotherapy. This complexity is partly due to the interaction between the tumor and its microenvironment [1,2]. The tumor microenvironment (TME) consists of different non-cancer cell types and their stroma, such as fibroblasts, immune cells (lymphocytes and macrophages), mesenchymal cells, and endothelial cells (EC), which all have a specific role in the physiology, structure, and function of the tumor [3]. The tumor and its microenvironment induce reciprocal changes in their phenotypes and functions that sustain the ongoing process of tumor development and spreading [4,5,6,7]. Studying interactions between cancer and the TME involves developing optimal surrogate platforms where the complex features of cancer cells, such as migration, proliferation, and chemoresistance, can be investigated. This has been proved to be quite challenging both in vitro and in vivo due to the difficult task to reproduce all the complex tumoral and non-tumoral cell interactions. Most of the published data regarding known cell-based processes is derived from experiments performed in two-dimensional (2D) conditions where cells are grown on rigid materials such as polystyrene and glass. These conventional cell monolayer cultures, grown under simplified and unrealistic conditions, do not fully reflect the essential physiology of real tissues. They modify the tissue-specific architecture (forced polarity, flattened cell shape), mechanical/biochemical signals, and subsequent cell-to-cell communication [8]. Despite these drawbacks, 2D cultures remain very attractive for laboratory purposes because of their simplicity and low cost. When one wants to confirm a phenomenon or mechanism observed in vitro, the usual and common approach is to use standard animal testing, usually referred to as animal models. However, there are many concerns regarding the discomfort or the pain of animals under certain experimental conditions. Many experimental animals have compromised immune systems and do not offer the same stroma-tumor interaction as humans, which prevents the efficient translation of novel research to clinical settings [9]. Obtaining concordance between animal models and clinical trials still remains challenging, with an average rate of concordant results that barely reaches 8% [10,11]. Therefore, switching from 2D cultures to three-dimensional (3D) cultures is motivated by the need to create cellular models that better captures the complexities of tumor biology. The ideal 3D model would eliminate the differences related to species that are usually encountered, allowing drug testing directly on human models. Defining optimal 3D models that best mimic the specificity of the tumor microenvironment seems to be of growing interest for the scientific community. When the number of publications on 3D models in the 90s barely reached 10 per year, during the last ten years, the increase has been exponential, reaching almost 1000 publications in 2016 alone. This is due to the emergence of many different new techniques that are potentially of great value in the context of tumor-TME interaction studies. Here, we provide an overview of different culture methods in 3D, and discuss their use, challenges, and differences compared to 2D cell cultures. The topics covered in this review include cancer proliferation and migration, as well as resistance to chemotherapy. Our goal is to provide a comprehensive review of the benefits and drawbacks of both 2D and 3D cultures in the expanding field of tumor-TME interactions. 2. DIFFERENT MODELS OF 3D CULTURE Working in 3D involves formation of spheroids. Spheroids are aggregates that can either be grown in suspension, encapsulated, or grown on the top of a 3D matrix using different 3D methods; each one has its specific advantages and disadvantages [12]. 3D methods can be divided into the following categories: (i) hanging drop methods; (ii) non-adherent surface methods; (iii) suspension culture; (iv) scaffolds-based: hydrogel; (v) magnetic levitation and bio-printing; (vi) microfluidic methods. 2.1. Hanging Drop Methods The hanging drop method was originally a microbiology method used to study bacteria in a confined and controlled environment. In this technique, drops of cell suspensions are placed onto the underside of a petri dish lid (Figure 1A). The lid, where the cells hang due to surface tension, is then placed onto a petri dish, which contains PBS (phosphate buffer saline) to prevent dehydration of the droplets. The cells accumulate at the tip of the drop at the air-liquid interface, spontaneously aggregate, and finally form spheroids [13,14]. The hanging drop method does not require the use of any substance that can negatively affect the spheroids, as cells naturally adhere to each other and do not have to rely on matrices or scaffolds. However, drops with liquid volumes of more than 50 μL do not adhere to the petri dish (since the liquid surface tension is overcome by gravity) [15]. It can also be a challenge to change the medium without disturbing the spheroid. Recently, hanging drop plates (HDP) have been used instead of petri dish plates, allowing the production of larger numbers of 3D spheroids per plate [16,17,18]. HDP have a bottom tray filled with a liquid that will keep a humid atmosphere inside the plate to prevent any evaporation/drying out. On the top of the tray sits a hanging drop plate with access holes where cell suspension samples can be placed to form hanging drops. Overall, the hanging drop method is quite simple and consistent. It can produce one spheroid per drop for different cell lines [19]. Using HDPs is simpler compared to the original hanging drop method, as it can be manipulated by liquid handling robots nevertheless it remains quite expensive. HDP is compatible with high throughput screening and offers a new approach to testing a greater number of drugs on different cell lines while replicating a 3D in vivo biological context [16]. Indeed, the natural direct cell-cell and cell-ECM (Extra Cellular Matrix) interaction that takes place in-vivo is preserved. The main interest of this