On the Fracture of the Carpal Extremity of the Radius.
Colles A. · 1814
Read On the Fracture of the Carpal Extremity of the Radius. by Colles A. (1814) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc5743240.txt.
Introduction
Colles describes a wrist fracture that had not been set down in print before. Writing in 1814, he was a professor of anatomy and surgery in Ireland. The injury breaks the radius near its wrist end. It lacks the grating feel and clear signs of most fractures, so it is easy to mistake for a dislocation.
He places the break about an inch and a half above the wrist end of the bone. A dip shows in the back of the forearm at that spot. Swelling fills the wrist, and the hand bones seem thrown backward. He walks surgeons through touch and sight checks that settle the true nature of the case.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Colles A. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 1814 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 10 KB |
| LICENSE | Public Domain |
| RIGHTS | PUBLIC DOMAIN |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
On the Fracture of the Carpal Extremity of the Radius By A. Colles Published in: Edinburgh Medical and Surgical Journal V. On the Fracture of the Carpal extremity of the Radius. By A. Colles, M. D. one of the Professors of Anatomy and Sur- gery in the Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland. rpHE injury to which I wish to direct the attention of sur- J- geons, has not, as far as I know, been described by any author ; indeed the form of the carpal extremity of the radius would rather incline us to question its being liable to fracture. The absence of crepitus, and of the other common symptoms of fracture, together with the swelling which instantly arises in this, as in other injuries of the wrist, render the difficulty of as- certaining the real nature of the case very considerable. This 1814. Dr Colles on the Fracture of the Radius. 133 This fracture takes place at about an inch and a half above the carpal extremity of the radius, and exhibits the following appearances. The posterior surface of the limb presents a considerable de- formity *, for a depression is seen in the fore-arm, about an inch and a half above the end of this bone, while a considerable swel- ling occupies the wrist and metacarpus. Indeed, the carpus and base of metacarpus appear to be thrown backward so much, as on first view to excite a suspicion that the carpus has been dislocated forward. On viewing the anterior surface of the limb, we observe a considerable fulness, as if caused by the flexor tendons being thrown forwards. This fulness extends upwards to about one- third of the length of the fore-arm, and terminates below at the upper edge of the annular ligament of the wrist. The extremi- ty of the ulna is seen projecting towards the palm and inner edge of the limb ; the degree, however, in which this projection takes place, is different in different instances. If the surgeon proceed to investigate the nature of this injury, he will find that the end of the ulna admits of being readily mo- ved backwards and forwards. On the posterior surface, he will discover by the touch that the swelling on the wrist, and metacarpus, is not caused entirely by an effusion among the softer parts ; he will perceive that the ends of the metacarpal, and second row of carpal bones, form no small part of it. This, strengthening the suspicion which the first view of the case had excited, leads him to examine, in a more particular manner, the anterior part of the joint; but the want of that solid resistance, which a dislocation of the carpus forward must occassion, forces him to abandon this notion, and leaves him in a state of perplexing uncertainty as to the real na- ture of the injury. He will, therefore, endeavour to gain some information, by examining the bones of the fore-arm. The faci- lity with which, (as was before noticed,) the ulna can be moved backward and forward, does not furnish him with any useful hint. When he moves his fingers along the anterior surface of the radius, he finds it more full and prominent than is natural; a similar examination of the posterior surface of this bone, indu- ces him to think that a depression is felt about an inch and half above its carpal extremity. He now expects to find satisfactory proofs of a fracture of the radius at this spot. For this purpose, he attempts to move the broken pieces of the bone in opposite directions ; but, although the patient is by this examination sub- jected to considerable pain, yet, neither crepitus nor a yielding of the bone at the seat of fracture, nor any other positive evi- / dence 1 S4< Dr Colles on the Fracture of the Radius. Aptil dence of the existence of such an injury is thereby obtained. The patient complains of severe pain as often as an attempt is made to give to the limb the motions of pronation and supina- tion. If the surgeon lock his hand in that of the patient's, and make extension, even with a moderate force, he restores the limb to its natural form, but the distortion of the limb instantly returns on the extension being removed. Should the facility with which a moderate extension restores the limb to its form, induce the prac- titioner to treat this as a case of sprain, he will find, alter a lapse of time sufficient for the removal of similar swellings, the deformity undiminished. Or, should he mistake the case for a dislocation of the wrist, and attempt to retain the parts in situ by tight bandages and splints, the pain caused by the pressure on the back of the wrist will force him to unbind them in a few hours ; and if they be applied more loosely, he will find, at the expiration of a few weeks, that the deformity still exists in its fullest extent, and that it is now no longer to be removed by making extension of the limb. By such mistakes the patient is doomed to endure for many months considerable lameness and stiffness of the limb, accompanied by severe pains on attempting to bend the hand and fingers. One consolation only remains, that the limb will at some remote period again enjoy perfect free- dom in all its motions, and be completely exempt from pain : the deformity, however, will remain undiminished through life. The unfavourable result of some of the first cases of this de- scription which came under my care, forced me to investigate with peculiar anxiety the nature of the injury. But while the absence of crepitus and of the other usual symptoms of fracture rendered the diagnosis extremely difficult; a recollection of the superior strength and thickness of this part of the radius, joined to the mobility of its articulation with the carpus and ulna, ra- ther inclined me to question the possibility of a fracture taking place at this part of the bone. At last, after many unsuccessful trials, I hit upon the following simple method of examination, by which I was enabled to ascertain, that the symptoms above enumerated actually arose from a fracture, seated about an inch and a half above the carpal extremity of the radius. Let the surgeon apply the fingers of one hand to the seat of the suspected fracture, and, locking the other hand in that of the patient, make a moderate extension, until he observes the limb restored to its natural form. As soon as this is effected, let him move the patient's hand backward and forward ; and he will, at every such attempt, be sensible of a yielding of the factured ends of 1814?. Dr Colles on the Fracture of the Radius. 185 of the bone, and this to such a degree as must remove all doubt from his mind. The nature of this injury once ascertained, it will be a very easy matter to explain the different phenomena attendant on it, and to point out a method of treatment? which will prove com-