On the Reflex Function of the Brain.
Laycock T. · 1845
Read On the Reflex Function of the Brain. by Laycock T. (1845) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc5612167.txt.
Introduction
Thomas Laycock argues that the brain works by reflex action, in a paper read at York in September 1844 and printed in The British and Foreign Medical Review. Reflex action was already accepted for the spinal cord. A pinched frog, even with its brain removed, still tries to escape. Laycock extends the same law upward.
His logic starts from anatomy. The ganglia inside the skull continue the spinal cord. So they should answer outside stimuli under like rules. He backs this with cases from lower animals. Cut centipede segments still move when touched. An isolated stretch of frog spinal cord still pulls back a stimulated limb. Four years earlier he had printed this view; now he lays out the proofs in full. The stakes, he says, lie in grasping insanity and its treatment. Readers meet an early claim that the mind's organ is not exempt from reflex law.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Laycock T. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 1845 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 63 KB |
| LICENSE | Public Domain |
| RIGHTS | PUBLIC DOMAIN |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
On the Reflex Function of the Brain By T. Laycock Published in: The British and Foreign Medical Review ON THE REFLEX FUNCTION OF THE BRAIN. By T. Laycock, m.d., Physician to the York Dispensary, &c. [Read at York, before the Medical Section of the British Association for the Advancement of Science, on 28th Sept. 1844.] Since it has been generally acknowledged that the brain is the organ of mind, the study of its physiology or laws of action, has acquired a surpassing in- terest, for whatever men do, in the most comprehensive sense, is connected with its functions. It is, however, as elucidating the nature and treatment of insanity, that its physiology is most interesting to the physician. A knowledge of the laws and mode of action of this important organ can only be acquired by scientific observation and induction, and it is encouraging and pleasing to know that the multitude and variety of facts from which inductions may be made are proportionate to the difficulties to be overcome. I am not alluding to mental philosophy, but to the advances already accomplished in com- parative physiology, which show us that the structure and functions of the nervous system in all animals are subject to the same laws of development and action; that a continuous and harmonious whole is formed out of the multitudinous and disjected parts; and that varied and dissimilar as they appear, each may be made to illustrate the other. Four years have elapsed since I published my opinion, supported by such ar- guments as I could then state, that the brain, although the organ of consciousness, was subject to the laws of reflex action, and that in this respect it did not differ from the other ganglia of the nervous system. I was led to this opinion by the general principle, that the ganglia within the cranium being a continuation of the spinal cord, must necessarily be regulated as to their reaction on external agencies by laws identical with those governing the functions of the spinal gan- glia and their analogues in the lower animals. And I was confirmed in this opinion by finding, after the investigation and collocation of known facts, that observations and arguments like those satisfactorily adduced in proof of the exis- tence of the reflex function of the spinal ganglia, may be brought forward in proof that the cerebral ganglia have similar endowments. In the present paper I pur- pose to give these proofs connectedly. I must premise, however, that I entered upon my undertaking with considerable hesitation. I felt deeply the magnitude of the subject, and the important results to which an inquiry of this kind might lead. I felt too, that in advocating the doctrine of cerebral reflex function, I was opposing the opinions of a physiologist to whom deference is eminently due. That gentleman, however, is so devoted to all questions of neurology, and so anxious, I really believe, to arrive at truth, that he, 1 hope, will willingly permit me to differ from him in doctrine, and give a favorable consideration to my opinions, although opposed to his own. To render my subsequent arguments clearer, I will first give a short summary 1845. J Rejlex Function of the Brain. 299 of the doctrine of reflex action, as at present received. I need scarcely state that the spinal cord in the vertebrata, is a series of ganglia analogous to those of the articulata. If a centipede be divided into several parts, each segment will move on an external stimulus being applied; if it be decapitated, and the respiratory orifices on one side of the body be irritated by an acrid vapour, it will immediately flex the trunk to the opposite side; if the Greophilus electricus be cut into two pieces, each segment will live and appear vigorous for a fortnight, the caudal portion surviving the cephalic for two or three days. Cold-blooded vertebrates display these involuntary motions very strikingly ; thousands of unfortunate frogs have fallen victims to the zeal of physiologists in researches of this kind. If the brain, the organ of consciousness, be removed from a frog by decapitation, it will still attempt to escape when pinched or otherwise in- jured, and will perform motions, which, if the brain had not been removed, could only have been supposed to be the result of sensation and volition. Indeed it has been inferred from these facts, that the spinal cord, as well as the brain, is endowed with consciousness. It is found, however, that segments of the spinal cord possess a similar function. It' that portion of the spinal axis of a frog which gives origin to the brachial nerves be separated both anteriorly and poste- riorly from the whole cord, so as to be completely isolated, on stimulating the skin covering the forelegs, retraction of the limb irritated and similar reflex movements take place. There can be no doubt, in fact, that each ganglion constitutes the centre of a nervous arc, of which the motor and sensitive nerves, in connexion with it are the two limbs An impression is made on the peripheral termination of a sensitive nerve; this impression is transmitted to the ganglion as the central axis; there some change, the nature of which is unknown, takes place, but such, that the mus- cles in connexion with the motor nerves arising from the ganglion are moved. Dr. Hall has termed the sensitive, or afferent, or impression-bearing nerve, inci- dent excitor nerve ; and the central axes form collectively the true spinal system, extending from the corpora quadrigeminato the cauda equina. It is not necessary to reflex action that the irritation be applied exclusively to the peripheral termination of the sensitive or incident excitor nerve, although phe- nomena so induced, are the most strikingly and mest perfectly reflex. The irri- tation may be applied in any portion of its course, or to the posterior gray matter of the cord (the sensory track) in which the nerve terminates, or to the anterior motor track, or to the cut end of that portion of the motor nerve still in connexion with the muscle. The track of the irritation is from the surface to the muscular fibre through the ganglia ; if the continuity of nervous connexion be broken, the irritation cannot reach the muscle. Irritations may in their origin, therefore, be either peripheral, or derived from the surface ; fibrillar, or seated in the trunk of the nerve; and central, or in the axis itself. These variations as to the point from which the irritation commences are connected with variations in the phenomena, and enabled Dr. Hall to arrange excito-motory actions into classes. In hydrophobia, the irritation is a poison cir- culating with the blood through the central axis; the disease is therefore termed centric, and the excito-motory phenomena are of centric origin; so also the con- vulsions (the excito-motory phenomena) of asphyxia are centric, because they depend on the circulation of venous blood, instead of arterial, through the spinal cord. The action of the respiratory muscles in sneezing induced by irritation of the schneiderian membrane is reflex, and so with a multitude of vital acts, all ad- mirably elucidated