Partial-breast radiotherapy after breast conservation surgery for patients with early breast cancer (UK IMPORT LOW trial): 5-year results from a multicentre, randomised, controlled, phase 3, non-inferiority trial.
Coles CE, Griffin CL, Kirby AM, Titley J, Agrawal RK, Alhasso A, Bhattacharya IS, Brunt AM, Ciurlionis L, Chan C, Donovan EM, Emson MA, Harnett AN, Haviland JS, Hopwood P, Jefford ML, Kaggwa R, Sawyer EJ, Syndikus I, Tsang YM, Wheatley DA, Wilcox M, Yarnold JR, Bliss JM, IMPORT Trialists. · 2017
Read Partial-breast radiotherapy after breast conservation surgery for patients with early breast cancer (UK IMPORT LOW trial): 5-year results from a multicentre, randomised, controlled, phase 3, non-inferiority trial. by Coles CE, Griffin CL, Kirby AM, Titley J, Agrawal RK, Alhasso A, Bhattacharya IS, Brunt AM, Ciurlionis L, Chan C, Donovan EM, Emson MA, Harnett AN, Haviland JS, Hopwood P, Jefford ML, Kaggwa R, Sawyer EJ, Syndikus I, Tsang YM, Wheatley DA, Wilcox M, Yarnold JR, Bliss JM, IMPORT Trialists. (2017) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc5594247.txt.
Introduction
Coles and co-authors report five-year results from the IMPORT LOW trial in The Lancet. After breast-conserving surgery, standard care treats the whole breast with radiation. For women at lower risk of return, treating only the tumor's area may do as well. The trial ran in 30 UK centers.
A total of 2,018 women joined. One group got standard whole-breast treatment. A second got a lower whole-breast dose plus a partial boost. A third got partial-breast treatment only. Five-year local relapse rates stayed near one percent in every group. Both gentler options proved non-inferior. Some side effects, like breast firmness, were lower with partial treatment. The method is simple enough for centers worldwide. Readers get firm evidence for kinder radiation.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Coles CE, Griffin CL, Kirby AM, Titley J, Agrawal RK, Alhasso A, Bhattacharya IS, Brunt AM, Ciurlionis L, Chan C, Donovan EM, Emson MA, Harnett AN, Haviland JS, Hopwood P, Jefford ML, Kaggwa R, Sawyer EJ, Syndikus I, Tsang YM, Wheatley DA, Wilcox M, Yarnold JR, Bliss JM, IMPORT Trialists. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2017 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 65 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Partial-breast radiotherapy after breast conservation surgery for patients with early breast cancer (UK IMPORT LOW trial): 5-year results from a multicentre, randomised, controlled, phase 3, non-inferiority trial By Charlotte E Coles, Clare L Griffin, Anna M Kirby, Jenny Titley, Rajiv K Agrawal, Abdulla Alhasso, Indrani S Bhattacharya, Adrian M Brunt, Laura Ciurlionis, Charlie Chan, Ellen M Donovan, Marie A Emson Published in: Lancet (London, England) DOI: 10.1016/S0140-6736(17)31145-5 ABSTRACT Summary Background Local cancer relapse risk after breast conservation surgery followed by radiotherapy has fallen sharply in many countries, and is influenced by patient age and clinicopathological factors. We hypothesise that partial-breast radiotherapy restricted to the vicinity of the original tumour in women at lower than average risk of local relapse will improve the balance of beneficial versus adverse effects compared with whole-breast radiotherapy. Methods IMPORT LOW is a multicentre, randomised, controlled, phase 3, non-inferiority trial done in 30 radiotherapy centres in the UK. Women aged 50 years or older who had undergone breast-conserving surgery for unifocal invasive ductal adenocarcinoma of grade 1–3, with a tumour size of 3 cm or less (pT1–2), none to three positive axillary nodes (pN0–1), and minimum microscopic margins of non-cancerous tissue of 2 mm or more, were recruited. Patients were randomly assigned (1:1:1) to receive 40 Gy whole-breast radiotherapy (control), 36 Gy whole-breast radiotherapy and 40 Gy to the partial breast (reduced-dose group), or 40 Gy to the partial breast only (partial-breast group) in 15 daily treatment fractions. Computer-generated random permuted blocks (mixed sizes of six and nine) were used to assign patients to groups, stratifying patients by radiotherapy treatment centre. Patients and clinicians were not masked to treatment allocation. Field-in-field intensity-modulated radiotherapy was delivered using standard tangential beams that were simply reduced in length for the partial-breast group. The primary endpoint was ipsilateral local relapse (80% power to exclude a 2·5% increase [non-inferiority margin] at 5 years for each experimental group; non-inferiority was shown if the upper limit of the two-sided 95% CI for the local relapse hazard ratio [HR] was less than 2·03), analysed by intention to treat. Safety analyses were done in all patients for whom data was available (ie, a modified intention-to-treat population). This study is registered in the ISRCTN registry, number ISRCTN12852634. Findings Between May 3, 2007, and Oct 5, 2010, 2018 women were recruited. Two women withdrew consent for use of their data in the analysis. 674 patients were analysed in the whole-breast radiotherapy (control) group, 673 in the reduced-dose group, and 669 in the partial-breast group. Median follow-up was 72·2 months (IQR 61·7–83·2), and 5-year estimates of local relapse cumulative incidence were 1·1% (95% CI 0·5–2·3) of patients in the control group, 0·2% (0·02–1·2) in the reduced-dose group, and 0·5% (0·2–1·4) in the partial-breast group. Estimated 5-year absolute differences in local relapse compared with the control group were −0·73% (−0·99 to 0·22) for the reduced-dose and −0·38% (−0·84 to 0·90) for the partial-breast groups. Non-inferiority can be claimed for both reduced-dose and partial-breast radiotherapy, and was confirmed by the test against the critical HR being more than 2·03 (p=0·003 for the reduced-dose group and p=0·016 for the partial-breast group, compared with the whole-breast radiotherapy group). Photographic, patient, and clinical assessments recorded similar adverse effects after reduced-dose or partial-breast radiotherapy, including two patient domains achieving statistically significantly lower adverse effects (change in breast appearance [p=0·007 for partial-breast] and breast harder or firmer [p=0·002 for reduced-dose and p<0·0001 for partial-breast]) compared with whole-breast radiotherapy. Interpretation We showed non-inferiority of partial-breast and reduced-dose radiotherapy compared with the standard whole-breast radiotherapy in terms of local relapse in a cohort of patients with early breast cancer, and equivalent or fewer late normal-tissue adverse effects were seen. This simple radiotherapy technique is implementable in radiotherapy centres worldwide. Funding Cancer Research UK. Research in contextEvidence before this studyA comprehensive literature search using PubMed and MEDLINE was done before the trial opened to identify all previous pathological and clinical breast radiotherapy studies investigating patterns of recurrence within the ipsilateral breast, and also to identify results of previous partial-breast radiotherapy studies. Search terms included “early breast cancer”, “partial irradiation”, and “partial breast radiotherapy”. Existing research suggests that most local relapses occur in the vicinity of the original tumour bed and that older trials testing partial-breast radiotherapy were uninformative because of suboptimal patient selection, poor localisation of the tumour, and hence, inaccurate radiotherapy. We hypothesised that partial-breast radiotherapy using modern methods of radiotherapy planning and treatment would be non-inferior in terms of local relapse incidence and might have reduced normal-tissue toxicity in a low-risk of relapse population. This formed part of our peer-reviewed funding application for the trial.Added value of this studyIMPORT LOW is the first phase 3 trial reporting 5-year outcome data for local relapses and adverse effects after partial-breast radiotherapy delivered using standard external beam radiotherapy techniques, and is the only trial, to the best of our knowledge, testing the importance of treatment volume unconfounded by radiotherapy dose-time factors. Additionally, the study is unique because it includes very comprehensive patient-reported outcome measures.At 5 years, partial-breast radiotherapy delivered using a simple and standard technique, showed no increase in local relapse rates compared with whole-breast radiotherapy, and produced equivalent or reduced late adverse effects. Follow-up is continuing and 10-year local relapse incidence and toxicity will be reported in future.Implications of all the available evidenceIMPORT LOW has similar local relapse incidence to the recently reported GEC-ESTRO brachytherapy partial-breast radiotherapy trial that also confirmed non-inferiority of partial-breast versus whole-breast radiotherapy. Our method of partial-breast radiotherapy seems to be safe and effective and has a key advantage of being relatively simple compared with conformal or inverse-planned intensity-modulated radiotherapy or brachytherapy. The use of standard medial and lateral tangential beams also minimises the mean heart dose without the need for breath hold in most patients with left-sided breast cancer, given that most patients have tumours in the upper half of the breast and above the level of the heart. Implementation of this technique will not require additional resources or training in most countries worldwide. INTRODUCTION Breast radiotherapy after breast-conserving surgery has been shown to reduce the risk of any recurrence of breast cancer by a half and breast cancer-related mortality by a sixth in patients with early breast cancer.1 Whole-breast radiotherapy is the standard of care in the UK and internationally.2, 3, 4, 5 Current treatment guidelines discuss partial-breast radiotherapy for selected patients at low risk of recurrence because of age, small tumour size, and early stage, the evidence for which comes mainly from retrospective and prospective cohort studies in patients who received treatment using the MammoSite system and long-term results of a single, small, well conducted randomised trial of interstitial brachytherapy.6, 7, 8, 9, 10 One challenge in treating patients with early breast cancer is to reduce the morbidity of radiotherapy without compromising its ability to cure the cancer. The rationale for investigating partial-breast radiotherapy is based on international reports of reductions in local relapse incidence, and the recognition that the majority of ipsilateral local relapses occur close to the region of the index tumour (the so-called tumour bed).11, 12 Rapid technical advances in radiotherapy combined with accurate localisation of the tumour bed using titanium surgical clips enable more precise matching of