Schrödinger's microbes: Tools for distinguishing the living from the dead in microbial ecosystems.
Emerson JB, Adams RI, Román CMB, Brooks B, Coil DA, Dahlhausen K, Ganz HH, Hartmann EM, Hsu T, Justice NB, Paulino-Lima IG, Luongo JC, Lymperopoulou DS, Gomez-Silvan C, Rothschild-Mancinelli B, Balk M, Huttenhower C, Nocker A, Vaishampayan P, Rothschild LJ. · 2017
Read Schrödinger's microbes: Tools for distinguishing the living from the dead in microbial ecosystems. by Emerson JB, Adams RI, Román CMB, Brooks B, Coil DA, Dahlhausen K, Ganz HH, Hartmann EM, Hsu T, Justice NB, Paulino-Lima IG, Luongo JC, Lymperopoulou DS, Gomez-Silvan C, Rothschild-Mancinelli B, Balk M, Huttenhower C, Nocker A, Vaishampayan P, Rothschild LJ. (2017) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc5558654.txt.
Introduction
Emerson and co-authors present a review in Microbiome on a basic puzzle. For microbes, telling the living from the dead is hard. DNA sequencing shows which microbes are present in a sample. It cannot say which of them are still alive.
That gap matters in medicine, food safety, and ecology. Dead cells can leave DNA behind and distort the picture. The review covers tools from microscopy to molecular tests that check viability or activity. Some of them pair with modern sequencing and counting methods. Gaps remain for complex samples, spores, and viruses. Readers get a clear guide to what each tool can and cannot prove.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Emerson JB, Adams RI, Román CMB, Brooks B, Coil DA, Dahlhausen K, Ganz HH, Hartmann EM, Hsu T, Justice NB, Paulino-Lima IG, Luongo JC, Lymperopoulou DS, Gomez-Silvan C, Rothschild-Mancinelli B, Balk M, Huttenhower C, Nocker A, Vaishampayan P, Rothschild LJ. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2017 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 120 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Schrödinger’s microbes: Tools for distinguishing the living from the dead in microbial ecosystems By Joanne B. Emerson, Rachel I. Adams, Clarisse M. Betancourt Román, Brandon Brooks, David A. Coil, Katherine Dahlhausen, Holly H. Ganz, Erica M. Hartmann, Tiffany Hsu, Nicholas B. Justice, Ivan G. Paulino-Lima, Julia C. Luongo Published in: Microbiome DOI: 10.1186/s40168-017-0285-3 ABSTRACT While often obvious for macroscopic organisms, determining whether a microbe is dead or alive is fraught with complications. Fields such as microbial ecology, environmental health, and medical microbiology each determine how best to assess which members of the microbial community are alive, according to their respective scientific and/or regulatory needs. Many of these fields have gone from studying communities on a bulk level to the fine-scale resolution of microbial populations within consortia. For example, advances in nucleic acid sequencing technologies and downstream bioinformatic analyses have allowed for high-resolution insight into microbial community composition and metabolic potential, yet we know very little about whether such community DNA sequences represent viable microorganisms. In this review, we describe a number of techniques, from microscopy- to molecular-based, that have been used to test for viability (live/dead determination) and/or activity in various contexts, including newer techniques that are compatible with or complementary to downstream nucleic acid sequencing. We describe the compatibility of these viability assessments with high-throughput quantification techniques, including flow cytometry and quantitative PCR (qPCR). Although bacterial viability-linked community characterizations are now feasible in many environments and thus are the focus of this critical review, further methods development is needed for complex environmental samples and to more fully capture the diversity of microbes (e.g., eukaryotic microbes and viruses) and metabolic states (e.g., spores) of microbes in natural environments. BACKGROUND In the classic Monty Python “Dead Parrot” comedy sketch, John Cleese plays an irate pet store customer, who complains to the shopkeeper that he was sold a dead bird. While the shopkeeper insists that the bird is “only resting,” the customer bangs his wooden-stiff bird on the counter, screaming, “Hello, Polly” into its ear with no response. It is quite clear that the bird is dead. Distinguishing living from dead microbes is seldom so obvious, but it can have important and even lethal consequences if, for example, living pathogenic microbes are in pharmaceuticals, food, or swimming pools. There are huge environmental implications if a toxic algal bloom is alive, dead, or dying, and medical consequences may depend on the number and distribution of live or dead cells in microbial biofilms on heart valves or teeth. The structure and function of microbiomes depends on which members of the community are alive or dead. The possibility of finding life beyond Earth relies utterly on the sterility of spacecraft and their payloads. As with Erwin Schrödinger’s quantum mechanics thought experiment, in which a cat could appear to be simultaneously both alive and dead until a measurement is made, a dedicated assessment of living and/or dead microorganisms is usually a requirement to know whether members of microbial communities are alive or dead. The methods used for live/dead determinations and assessments of microbial activity can affect conclusions about both living and dead microorganisms in consortia. Here, we review and, in the process, identify gaps in currently available techniques to distinguish between living and dead microbes. The question of whether microbes are alive or dead began with the birth of the field of microbiology in 1683 when Anton van Leeuwenhoek recorded the first observation of bacteria. Nearly 200 years later, Robert Koch defined a pure culture and colony [1], allowing for quantitative estimates of the number of viable microorganisms in bacterial samples. Soon afterwards, agar was used in research and the Petri dish was developed, paving the way for standardized bacterial observations. These tools allowed for standards for the determination of microbiological viability: the ability to culture microbial cells. The cultivation-based viability assay shows an observable division of a single cell into colonies on agar plates or in liquid medium, thereby proving that the cells are alive (reviewed in [2]). This method is still the “gold standard” for a variety of applications today. For example, in an effort to check the sterility of their clean rooms and spacecraft, the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) incubates strips from each room on agar plates and assesses growth [3], although alternatives to agar have also been used on the Russian space station MIR to avoid contamination [4]. A similar method is used to detect bacteria when performing water quality testing by culturing water samples on agar plates [5], and these techniques are routinely used for testing and regulatory compliance in hospitals, the pharmaceutical industry, other medical fields, food protection, and the cosmetics industry [6–11]. While individuals from these fields may find some aspects of this review useful, microbial ecologists working with environmental samples from a variety of ecosystems are the intended audience. Since the beginning of microbiology, culture-based methods have been used to assess viability. However, culture-independent assessments of microbial consortia, particularly through DNA sequencing, have allowed for the resolution of microbial community structure and function with a level of detail unimaginable a decade or so ago. Unfortunately, culture-independent DNA sequencing methods cannot unequivocally differentiate between living and dead cells. DNA can persist in the environment, resulting in extracellular DNA and DNA from dead cells that is indistinguishable from DNA representing living cells [12–15]. DNA and/or cellular material from dead microorganisms may be important in certain contexts, for example as bioavailable nutrients, sources of genetic material, historical representations of past organisms or ecological conditions, and/or as agents of respiratory ailments [14, 16–19]. However, it is the live microorganisms that have the potential to grow in, adapt to, and actively change a given environment. Without the selective identification of the living microbes, counting techniques and DNA sequencing approaches are likely to overestimate the types and numbers of viable taxa and/or active metabolic processes in microbial communities [15]. This is problematic not only for comparative microbial ecology but also for pathogen detection, cleanliness estimations, bioburden analysis, and antibiotic susceptibility testing [20]. For example, should a public beach be closed strictly based on DNA sequencing-based determination of contamination without, for example, microscopy, growth, or toxin testing? The delineation between life and death is complex and debatable, and detailed considerations on the meaning of life and death in microbiology can be found elsewhere (e.g., [21]). In short, it is generally accepted (but not a universal rule) that a cell must be intact, capable of reproduction, and metabolically active, in order to be considered alive, and different viability assessments are designed to measure one or more of these properties, either directly or by proxy. These so-called live/dead protocols typically address one of the three aspects of microbial viability: (1) the existence of an intact, functional cell membrane, (2) the presence of cellular metabolism or energy, or (3) the possession of self-replicating DNA that can be transcribed into RNA, which, if applicable, can subsequently be translated into protein (adapted from [22]). Viruses, while not technically “alive” per these (and many) definitions, can be infectious or inactivated, and distinguishing between the two states can be more difficult than distinguishing living and dead forms of other microorganisms. While we provide background for a variety of techniques, we