Governance and Capacity to Manage Resilience of Health Systems: Towards a New Conceptual Framework.
Blanchet K, Nam SL, Ramalingam B, Pozo-Martin F. · 2017
Read Governance and Capacity to Manage Resilience of Health Systems: Towards a New Conceptual Framework. by Blanchet K, Nam SL, Ramalingam B, Pozo-Martin F. (2017) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc5553211.txt.
Introduction
Blanchet and co-authors present a conceptual paper on health system resilience. The term gained force after the 2014 Ebola outbreak in West Africa. Experts agree systems must be more resilient. They do not all mean the same thing by the word, though.
The authors define resilience as a system's capacity to absorb, adapt, and transform under shock. Shocks can be pandemics, disasters, war, or money crises. Their framework rests on systems thinking and complexity theory. It focuses on governance: the rules and actors that steer a system. A scoping review of definitions informed the model. Readers get shared language and a path toward measures that can be tested.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Blanchet K, Nam SL, Ramalingam B, Pozo-Martin F. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2017 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 23 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Governance and Capacity to Manage Resilience of Health Systems: Towards a New Conceptual Framework By Karl Blanchet, Sara L. Nam, Ben Ramalingam, Francisco Pozo-Martin Published in: International Journal of Health Policy and Management DOI: 10.15171/ijhpm.2017.36 ABSTRACT The term resilience has dominated the discourse among health systems researchers since 2014 and the onset of the Ebola outbreak in West Africa. There is wide consensus that the global community has to help build more resilient health systems. But do we really know what resilience means, and do we all have the same vision of resilience? The present paper presents a new conceptual framework on governance of resilience based on systems thinking and complexity theories. In this paper, we see resilience of a health system as its capacity to absorb, adapt and transform when exposed to a shock such as a pandemic, natural disaster or armed conflict and still retain the same control over its structure and functions. INTRODUCTION The term resilience has dominated the discourse among health systems researchers since 2014 and the onset of the Ebola outbreak in West Africa.1,2 There is wide consensus that the global community has to help build more resilient health systems. But do we really know what resilience means, and do we all have the same vision of resilience? The emergence of the term ‘resilience’ for some echoes the 1990s experience with ‘sustainability’ in that it seems to have the function of accommodating various political and scientific paradigms.3 Resilience is seen as a ‘boundary term’4 that is at the crossroad between politics and science.5 As such, it may have the function of building political consensus and aligning and enabling the co-existence of several different agendas,6 which may explain why the term resilience may remain contested and ambiguous. However, it remains important for health systems researchers and practitioners to clarify the meaning of the concept and have common guidance as to its use. Strengthening the capacity of health systems to manage resilience is critical to effectively continue delivering essential preventative and curative healthcare services to populations. This requires adapting and transforming the structure and properties of the health system to move it away from undesirable risk situations.7 However, how do we recognize situations of risks? How do we know what properties of the system are better adapted to certain circumstances? What are the potential effects of alternative routes? Who makes decisions on the directions of the health system? These are critical questions on the management and governance of resilience on how to manage the capacities of health systems. Our objective through this paper is to value the various perspectives and maintain diversity of opinions while providing a common framework to help researchers dialog with each other and generate more studies in this field. The present paper presents a new conceptual framework for research based on systems thinking and complexity theories.8-10 TOWARDS A NEW CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK ON GOVERNANCE OF RESILIENCE Governance relates to the implicit and explicit rules and institutions that shape power, relationships between actors, and the actions of these actors. Managing resilience of health system resides in the capacity of managing actors, networks and institutions that have an influence on the health system.11 With the emergence of system thinking and complexity science, the world is now described as a network of systems interacting between each other and influencing different levels of society.12,13 Dynamic systems of different sizes interact across multiple scales14-17 and affect systems’ characteristics in relation to the nature, frequency and intensity of shocks experienced.18 Drawing on the resilience literature,19,20 it is important to define both what resilience is, in specific contexts, and explain how it can be managed in those contexts. In this paper, we see resilience of a health system as its capacity to absorb, adapt and transform when exposed to a shock such as a pandemic, natural disaster, armed conflict or a financial crisis and still retain the same control over its structure and functions (adapted from11,21,22). We propose a new conceptual framework adapted from environmental studies11 to help analyse the governance of health systems resilience. We developed this framework based on a scoping review of the latest definitions of resilience of systems in the health sector and elsewhere (eg, ecology and urban studies). Based on discussions with experts, a new conceptual framework needs to be operational (ie, to be able to be translated into measurable indicators to be tested) and comprehensive, defined by Sabatier23 as being able to take into account “conflicting values and interests, information flows, institutional arrangements and variation in the socioeconomic environment.” With a firm grounding in complex systems sciences, the management of resilience of health systems is characterised by four main dimensions interlinked with each other: (i) capacity to collect, integrate and analyse different forms of knowledge and information; (ii) ability to anticipate and cope with uncertainties and surprises; (iii) capacity to manage interdependence: to engage effectively with and handle multiple- and cross-scale dynamics and feedbacks; and finally (iv) capacity to build or develop legitimate institutions that are socially accepted and contextually adapted (see Figure 1). The potential value of this framework is that it integrates all the different approaches to resilience alluded to in health systems thinking – the building blocks, the systemic properties, and the enabling institutional environment – into one single approach for use by researchers, practitioners and policy-makers, and each dimension is described here. Based on frameworks used in ecology, three levels of resilience can be applied to health systems: absorptive capacity, adaptive capacity and transformative capacity (see Figure 2). Within health systems thinking, the absorptive capacity relates to the capacity of a health system to continue to deliver the same level (quantity, quality and equity) of basic healthcare services and protection to populations despite the shock using the same level of resources and capacities.25 Adaptive capacity is the capacity of the health system actors to deliver the same level of healthcare services with fewer and/or different resources, which requires making organisational adaptations.22,26-28 Finally, the transformative capacity describes the ability of health system actors to transform the functions and structure of the health system to respond to a changing environment.11,22,29,30 We propose a new conceptual framework to define the four dimensions that need to be taken into account in terms of governance of resilient health systems. CAPACITY TO COMBINE AND INTEGRATE DIFFERENT FORMS OF KNOWLEDGE Anticipating shocks and events such as public health outbreaks requires a functional disease surveillance system (in the case of outbreaks) to inform health services managers on the occurrence of pandemics and the state of transmission of the disease.31 However, the nature of the knowledge that needs to be collected and processed to ensure and measure resilience needs to extend beyond the sphere of the health system.32,33 For example, health systems planners need to understand the current resources available, where existing gaps in resources exist or where weaknesses in the health system lie as well as the current health status of the population and their health priorities. Furthermore, they need to be able to monitor risks and threats that may lie beyond the direct realm of the health system and may, for example, be related to the economic sphere or the political context.34,35 Having access to such different types