Comprehensive comparison of Pacific Biosciences and Oxford Nanopore Technologies and their applications to transcriptome analysis.

Weirather JL, de Cesare M, Wang Y, Piazza P, Sebastiano V, Wang XJ, Buck D, Au KF. · 2017

Read Comprehensive comparison of Pacific Biosciences and Oxford Nanopore Technologies and their applications to transcriptome analysis. by Weirather JL, de Cesare M, Wang Y, Piazza P, Sebastiano V, Wang XJ, Buck D, Au KF. (2017) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc5553090.txt.

Introduction

Weirather and co-authors present a comparison study in F1000Research. They test two long-read DNA sequencing platforms head to head. Pacific Biosciences and Oxford Nanopore both read single molecules at great length. The team used RNA data from human embryonic stem cells.

The authors compared error patterns, read length, and mapping quality. PacBio gave better data quality overall. Nanopore gave a higher yield of reads. For finding and counting gene isoforms, PacBio also led by a small margin. Combining either long-read set with short Illumina reads beat long reads alone. Readers get a practical guide for choosing a platform for transcript studies.

Catalog record

CREATORWeirather JL, de Cesare M, Wang Y, Piazza P, Sebastiano V, Wang XJ, Buck D, Au KF.
YEAR2017
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE72 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC5553090

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Comprehensive comparison of Pacific Biosciences and Oxford Nanopore Technologies and their applications to transcriptome analysis By Jason L Weirather, Mariateresa de Cesare, Yunhao Wang, Paolo Piazza, Vittorio Sebastiano, Xiu-Jie Wang, David Buck, Kin Fai Au Published in: F1000Research DOI: 10.12688/f1000research.10571.2 ABSTRACT Background: Given the demonstrated utility of Third Generation Sequencing [Pacific Biosciences (PacBio) and Oxford Nanopore Technologies (ONT)] long reads in many studies, a comprehensive analysis and comparison of their data quality and applications is in high demand. Methods: Based on the transcriptome sequencing data from human embryonic stem cells, we analyzed multiple data features of PacBio and ONT, including error pattern, length, mappability and technical improvements over previous platforms. We also evaluated their application to transcriptome analyses, such as isoform identification and quantification and characterization of transcriptome complexity, by comparing the performance of size-selected PacBio, non-size-selected ONT and their corresponding Hybrid-Seq strategies (PacBio+Illumina and ONT+Illumina). Results: PacBio shows overall better data quality, while ONT provides a higher yield. As with data quality, PacBio performs marginally better than ONT in most aspects for both long reads only and Hybrid-Seq strategies in transcriptome analysis. In addition, Hybrid-Seq shows superior performance over long reads only in most transcriptome analyses. Conclusions: Both PacBio and ONT sequencing are suitable for full-length single-molecule transcriptome analysis. As this first use of ONT reads in a Hybrid-Seq analysis has shown, both PacBio and ONT can benefit from a combined Illumina strategy. The tools and analytical methods developed here provide a resource for future applications and evaluations of these rapidly-changing technologies. INTRODUCTION Third Generation Sequencing (TGS) emerged more than 5 years ago when Pacific Biosciences (PacBio) commercialized Single Molecule Real Time (SMRT) sequencing technologies in 2011 1. Although TGS platforms have significant technical differences, they all generate very long reads (1–100kb) 2– 5, which is distinct from Second Generation Sequencing (SGS). Considering the paired-end information, the main SGS platform Illumina provides 50–600bp information from each DNA fragment; no SGS platforms provide >1000bp, including 454 sequencing, which generates the longest SGS reads ( ~700bp) 6, 7. Therefore, the short sequencing length limits the applications of SGS to large or complex genomic events, such as gene isoform reconstruction. TGS overcomes these challenging problems via long read lengths. The most widely used TGS platforms [PacBio and Oxford Nanopore Technologies (ONT)] developed new biochemistry/biophysics methods to directly capture the very long nucleotide sequences from single DNA molecules. Other emerging TGS platforms (Moleculo 8 and 10X Genomics 9) are based on the assembly of short reads from the same DNA molecules to generate synthetic long reads (SLR). Herein, we focus on data features of PacBio and ONT and their applications to transcriptome analysis. PacBio adopts a similar sequencing-by-synthesis strategy as Illumina sequencing, except PacBio captures a single DNA molecule and Illumina detects augmented signals from a clonal population of amplified DNA fragments. The error rate of raw PacBio data is 13–15%, as the signal-to-noise ratio from single DNA molecules is not high 3. To increase accuracy, the PacBio platform uses a circular DNA template by ligating hairpin adaptors to both ends of target double-stranded DNA. As the polymerase repeatedly traverses and replicates the circular molecule, the DNA template is sequenced multiple times to generate a continuous long read (CLR). The CLR can be split into multiple reads ("subreads") by removing adapter sequences, and multiple subreads generate circular consensus sequence ("CCS") reads with higher accuracy. The average length of a CLR is >10kb and up to 60kb, which depends on the polymerase lifetime 3. Thus, the length and accuracy of CCS reads depends on the fragment sizes. PacBio sequencing has been utilized for genome (e.g., de novo assembly, detection of structural variants and haplotyping) 10 and transcriptome (e.g., gene isoform reconstruction and novel gene/isoform discovery) 11– 13 studies. ONT is a nanopore-based single molecule sequencing technology, and the first prototype MinION was released in 2014 14. As compared to other sequencing technologies utilizing nucleotide incorporation or hybridization, ONT directly sequences a native single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) molecule by measuring characteristic current changes as the bases are threaded through the nanopore by a molecular motor protein. ONT MinION uses a hairpin library structure similar to the PacBio circular DNA template: the DNA template and its complement are bound by a hairpin adaptor. Therefore, the DNA template passes through the nanopore, followed by a hairpin and finally the complement. The raw read can be split into two “1D” reads (“template” and “complement”) by removing the adaptor. The consensus sequence of two “1D” reads is a “2D” read with a higher accuracy 2. Due to similar data features with PacBio, many researchers have utilized or are testing ONT in applications where PacBio has been applied. PacBio and ONT platforms share the advantage of long read lengths, yet they also have the same drawback: higher sequencing error rate and lower throughput compared to SGS 3, 14– 16. High sequencing error rates pose challenges for single-nucleotide-resolution analyses, such as accurate sequencing of transcripts, identification of splice sites and SNP calling. Low throughput is an obstacle for quantitative analysis, such as gene/isoform abundance estimation. Although PacBio CCS and ONT 2D consensus strategies can reduce error rates, the corresponding read lengths become shorter and throughput becomes lower. Therefore, hybrid sequencing (“Hybrid-Seq”), which integrates TGS and SGS data, has emerged as an approach to address the limitations associated with analysis of TGS data with assistance of SGS data. For example, error correction of PacBio or ONT long reads by SGS short reads improves the accuracy and mappability of long reads 17– 19. Hybrid-Seq can be applied to genome assembly and transcriptome characterization and improve the overall performance and resolution 11– 13, 17. The long read length of PacBio and ONT is very informative for transcriptome research, especially for gene isoform identification. In addition to human transcriptomes 20– 22, the PacBio transcript sequencing protocol, Iso-Seq, has been widely used to characterize transcriptome complexity in non-model organisms and particular genes/gene families 23– 31. In contrast, ONT has no standard transcript sequencing protocol and only a few pilot studies are publically available. Using MinION, Bolisetty et al. discovered very high isoform diversity of four genes in Drosophila, which illustrates the utility of ONT in investigating complex transcriptional events 32. Oikonomopoulos et al. also demonstrated the stability of ONT sequencing in quantifying transcriptome by analyzing an artificial mixture of 92 transcripts with Spike-In RNA 33. Compared to these studies using PacBio or ONT alone, Hybrid-Seq can reduce the requirement of data size and improve the output, especially for transcriptome-wide studies. For example, a series of Hybrid-Seq methods (IDP, IDP-fusion, IDP-ASE) have been developed to improve the transcriptome studies to isoform levels (e.g., gene isoform reconstruction, fusion genes and allele phasing) with higher sensitivity and accuracy, and achieve a more accurate abundance estimation, which has been demonstrated in human embryonic stem cells (hESCs) and breast cancer 11– 13. Herein, we generated PacBio and ONT data from cDNA of hESCs. Using our tool AlignQC ( http://www.healthcare.uiowa.edu/labs/au/AlignQC/), we performed a comprehensive analysis and comparison of PacBio and ONT data, including the raw data (subreads and 1D “template” reads) and their consensus (CCS and 2D reads). PacBio sequencing was performed on size-selected libraries, as size selection is the manufacturer recommendation. ONT

Read the complete text