On the Treatment of Inoperable Cases of Carcinoma of the Mamma: Suggestions for a New Method of Treatment, with Illustrative Cases.

Beatson GT. · 1896

Read On the Treatment of Inoperable Cases of Carcinoma of the Mamma: Suggestions for a New Method of Treatment, with Illustrative Cases. by Beatson GT. (1896) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc5518378.txt.

Introduction

Beatson presents a clinical paper in the Transactions of the Medico-Chirurgical Society of Edinburgh. It addresses breast cancer cases too advanced for surgery. At the time, such patients had no curative options at all. Beatson, surgeon to the Glasgow Cancer Hospital, proposed a new line of attack. His approach rejected the view of cancer as a local parasite.

Three cases illustrate the method in detail. The core step was removal of the ovaries, sometimes with thyroid extract added. Beatson reasoned that ovarian influence could drive the tumor's growth. Cutting that influence off, he argued, might shrink inoperable disease. The paper became a founding document of hormone therapy for cancer.

Catalog record

CREATORBeatson GT.
YEAR1896
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE78 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC5518378

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

On the Treatment of Inoperable Cases of Carcinoma of the Mamma: Suggestions for a New Method of Treatment, with Illustrative Cases By George T. Beatson Published in: Transactions. Medico-Chirurgical Society of Edinburgh TREATMENT OF INOPERABLE CASES OF CARCINOMA OF MAMMA. 153 III. Original Communication. V ON THE TREATMENT OF INOPERABLE CASES OF CAR- CINOMA OF THE MAMMA : SUGGESTIONS FOR A NEW METHOD OF TREATMENT. WITH ILLUSTRATIVE CASES. By George T. Beatson, B.A. (Cantab.), M.D. (Edinburgh), Surgeon to the Glasgow Cancer Hospital; Assistant Surgeon, Glasgow Western Infirmary ; and Examiner in Surgery to the University of Edinburgh. Mr President and Gentlemen,?I have no doubt it has fallen to the lot of nearly every one here present to have been consulted from time to time by patients suffering from carcinoma so widely spread or so situated that it has been quite apparent that nothing in the way of operative measures could be recommended. Such cases naturally excite our sympathy, but they also bring home to us the fact that once a case of cancer has passed beyond the reach of the surgeon's knife, our curative measures are practically nil, and " that, whether the case advance with giant strides or with slow and measured steps, the result is equally sure and fatal." Of late, owing to my taking up the work of surgeon to the Glasgow Cancer Hospital, I have seen a considerable number of such cases, and an opportunity has been furnished me of working out a line of treatment which I am not aware has been as yet tried by others, and which is founded on a view of the etiology and nature of cancer which is entirely opposed to the local parasitic theory of the disease, and which seems to me to offer a more reasonable explanation of it. As these inoperable cases of cancer may be arranged into two groups?first, those which have been operated on, but in which, sooner or later, there has been a recurrence, or, as it should perhaps be better expressed, a reappearance of the disease ; and, secondly, those in which no operation has been attempted, but in which, when they first present themselves, the disease has progressed so far that no local removal could be attempted?I shall bring for- ward three cases, one of which is illustrative of the first group, and the other two of the second. The first case, then, that I wish to bring under your notice is that of Elizabeth B., who consulted me on 11th May 1895, at the Glasgow Cancer Hospital, bringing me the following letter:? " 37 Apsley Place, 6th May 1895. " Dear Dr Beatson,?The bearer, Mrs B., is, and has been suffering, I fear, from a malignant breast. She has been in the Royal Infirmary before she came to me. My own opinion is that nothing can be done for her; but as she is a woman of great courage, you might have a look at it for my sake, and per- haps you can order her something in the way of dressing. Even this little will be accepted by her as a great deal.?With kindest regards, yours very truly, "James W. Wallace." The history she gave me was that she was 33 years of age, married, and the mother of two children, the oldest 3 years of age u 154 ON THE TREATMENT OF INOPERABLE CASES OF and the youngest 15 months. She nursed both of her children for ten to twelve months, chiefly on the left breast, the first child entirely so, as the right breast suppurated for two or three weeks. While nursing her first baby she observed a small hard lump at the outside of her left breast, and as it was painless and did not increase in size she took no further notice of it. It was only when her second baby was born twenty months later that she became aware it was increasing. She nursed the child on both breasts notwithstanding, and it was not for ten months, by which time the tumour had grown a good deal, that she weaned the child and sought advice at the Glasgow Royal Infirmary. In January of 1895 she was admitted to that Institution, and the journal report states that an examination shows the left mammary gland to be a little more swollen than the right one, and to present a hard and nodular appearance. In its centre is felt a large mass, measuring 5 in. across and in. in vertical diameter, while small nodules from this infiltrate the skin around. About 2 in. upwards and to the left of the nipple is seen an ulcer 1 in. in size, two nodules about the size of beans bordering on the extreme left of this ulcer. Patient appears to be strong, healthy, active, and robust. On 25th January 1895 she was operated on. The Hospital journal says that the left breast was excised, a large area of skin free of tumour being taken away. The axillary glands were removed, also a considerable part of the pectoral muscle which appeared to be implicated. A plastic incision was made parallel to the trunk to allow of the edges of the wound being approxi- mated. Patient seems to have made a good recovery, and to have left the Infirmary towards the beginning of March with the wound almost healed. About a month after she had gone home, that is, within three months of the operation, she noticed that the wound had opened, that a little discharge was coming away, and that pain of a shooting character had developed. She observed, also, that a hardness was growing at the side of the scar, and so she returned to the Infirmary for advice. She was there told that she should come into the Hospital again. She was readmitted for a few days and then discharged, as it was thought that an operation would be useless. The journal report is as follows:? " 28th April 1895.?Dismissed. General involvement of whole scar by large tumours, cancerous in nature, to remove which entirely was thought impossible. Adherent axilla and chest walls. One of the wounds from the recurring secondary tumours has given way, and there is now an ulcerated surface." Such, briefly, was the outline of her personal history as detailed to me. On questioning her, nothing could be elicited in her family history that showed any hereditary tendency to cancerous disease. On 11th May, at the time she presented herself to me, the local condition for which she sought advice was as follows:? On the left side of the thorax there is seen a very extensive C AllC I NOMA OF THE MAMMA, BY DR G. T. BEATSON. 155 cicatrix in the situation of the left mamma, which has apparently been entirely removed. The scar extends from the middle of the axilla to within 1|- in. of the xiphi-sternum. It is irregularly curved in aspect. Above the centre of scar is a cicatrizing area, which had broken out after the operation in January last. This is now granulating and seems healthy, but immediately below, and arching over centre of the long scar, is a mass of recurrent

Read the complete text