Shifting the optimal stiffness for cell migration.

Bangasser BL, Shamsan GA, Chan CE, Opoku KN, Tüzel E, Schlichtmann BW, Kasim JA, Fuller BJ, McCullough BR, Rosenfeld SS, Odde DJ. · 2017

Read Shifting the optimal stiffness for cell migration. by Bangasser BL, Shamsan GA, Chan CE, Opoku KN, Tüzel E, Schlichtmann BW, Kasim JA, Fuller BJ, McCullough BR, Rosenfeld SS, Odde DJ. (2017) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc5458120.txt.

Introduction

Bangasser and co-authors show that each cell type has a favorite stiffness for migration, and that the favorite can be shifted. Their study appeared in Nature Communications. Migrating cells move fastest at an optimum stiffness. Too soft or too stiff slows them. The team built a whole-cell migration simulator. It rests on the motor-clutch model. Motors pull actin bundles inside the cell. Clutches link that pull to the surface outside. The model predicted a tunable optimum.

Two cell types tested the prediction. Chick forebrain neurons peaked near 1 kilopascal. U251 glioma cells peaked near 100 kilopascals. The glioma cells carry more motors and clutches. Traction and actin flow matched model output. Drugs then shifted the glioma optimum downward. Blocking myosin II motors and integrin clutches together did it. Morphology and flow shifted as predicted. Stiffness sensing is thus adjustable machinery.

Catalog record

CREATORBangasser BL, Shamsan GA, Chan CE, Opoku KN, Tüzel E, Schlichtmann BW, Kasim JA, Fuller BJ, McCullough BR, Rosenfeld SS, Odde DJ.
YEAR2017
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE48 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC5458120

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Shifting the optimal stiffness for cell migration By Benjamin L. Bangasser, Ghaidan A. Shamsan, Clarence E. Chan, Kwaku N. Opoku, Erkan Tüzel, Benjamin W. Schlichtmann, Jesse A. Kasim, Benjamin J. Fuller, Brannon R. McCullough, Steven S. Rosenfeld, David J. Odde Published in: Nature Communications DOI: 10.1038/ncomms15313 ABSTRACT Cell migration, which is central to many biological processes including wound healing and cancer progression, is sensitive to environmental stiffness, and many cell types exhibit a stiffness optimum, at which migration is maximal. Here we present a cell migration simulator that predicts a stiffness optimum that can be shifted by altering the number of active molecular motors and clutches. This prediction is verified experimentally by comparing cell traction and F-actin retrograde flow for two cell types with differing amounts of active motors and clutches: embryonic chick forebrain neurons (ECFNs; optimum ∼1 kPa) and U251 glioma cells (optimum ∼100 kPa). In addition, the model predicts, and experiments confirm, that the stiffness optimum of U251 glioma cell migration, morphology and F-actin retrograde flow rate can be shifted to lower stiffness by simultaneous drug inhibition of myosin II motors and integrin-mediated adhesions. Several models have been proposed to describe optimality in cell migration, beginning with the adhesion strength model of cell migration of DiMilla et al.1. This model provided a theoretical framework for understanding the experimental observation that cells migrate fastest at intermediate adhesion strength2. However, it did not consider migration in compliant environments that is presumably the norm for migration in vivo. In addition, cell migration in vitro is highly sensitive to the mechanical stiffness of the environment, but the theoretical basis for these effects remains to be established. Since the observation of stiffness-sensitive cell migration by Lo et al.3, other cell migration models have provided some basis for stiffness sensitive cell migration by incorporating stiffness-dependent functions for force transmission45. However, such approaches introduce stiffness dependence as an assumption a priori, as opposed to having it naturally emerge as an output of the model. Therefore, we currently lack a theoretical explanation for how cell migration depends on the mechanochemical environment and how cells determine the optimal stiffness of their environment. We and others have previously presented a model of cellular force transmission based on the motor–clutch hypothesis6 that naturally predicts biphasic stiffness dependence as an outcome of the model789. In this model, intracellular molecular motors, such as myosin II, transmit force to the external environment through rigid actin filament bundles and compliant transmembrane molecular ‘clutches', such as integrins (Fig. 1a). In addition, the motor–clutch-based modelling was used to study the effect of substrate stress relaxation on cell spreading, collective cell durotaxis and ex vivo cell migration as a function of adhesion molecule expression101112. Our messenger RNA (mRNA) analysis of U251 human glioma cells has identified the most likely candidates for components of the motor–clutch model based on a previously published list13 of cell migration genes (Supplementary Table 1). We previously performed a detailed sensitivity analysis on this model and determined that dual parameter changes were needed to account for the broad range of stiffness optima seen experimentally14. Specifically, coordinately increasing the expression of molecular motors and clutches shifted the stiffness optimum for maximal force transmission to higher stiffness1415. However, our previous study only modelled a single F-actin-based protrusion, and therefore it is not clear whether the optimum shifting predicted by the motor–clutch model would occur in a simulation of an entire cell. Also, the motor–clutch model does not directly predict cellular level features, including cell area, shape and migration, the last being functionally important in nervous system development, immune response and cancer progression. To address these issues, we developed a stochastic whole cell migration simulator built from the motor–clutch model to simulate cell migration in compliant microenvironments while enforcing force and mass balances. The model predicts a stiffness optimum that can be shifted by altering the number of active molecular motors and clutches. We then experimentally tested the model predictions under conditions of varying mechanical stiffness and coordinate shifts in the activity of motors and clutches. Our results confirmed the model predictions and illustrated the ability to shift the optimal stiffness by altering the number of motors and clutches. RESULTS Cell migration simulator While the motor–clutch model set a foundation for migration sensitivity to stiffness, it did not describe the direct link between force transmission sensitivity and cell migration sensitivity. To investigate this link, we developed a cell migration simulator based on our earlier motor–clutch model. In this simulator, we linked together multiple motor–clutch systems, termed ‘modules', such that the modules each exert a force on a central cell body (Fig. 1a,b, see cell migration simulator parameters values in Supplementary Table 2). The resulting cell migration arises due to a force balance among the motor–clutch modules and the cell body as motors build load and clutch bonds to the substrate break stochastically, thus releasing load. Our previous theoretical analysis of a single motor–clutch predicted that the optimal stiffness can be readily shifted by coordinately changing the numbers of motors and clutches1415. To test whether simulated cells exhibit an optimal stiffness for cell migration, and whether such a shift in the optimal stiffness occurs in our whole cell migration simulator, we simulated cell migration at high and low motor and clutch numbers. The cell migration simulator predicted a stiffness optimum for F-actin retrograde flow rate that was shifted by altering the numbers of motors and clutches (Fig. 1c), consistent with the results for the simpler motor–clutch model that only modelled one protrusion14. The simulator also predicted a stiffness optimum for cell traction force that was reduced by altering the numbers of motors and clutches (Fig. 1d). However, the maximum of the simulated cell aspect ratio did not show an obvious shift when changing the number of motors and clutches (Fig. 1e). Finally, the cell migration simulations exhibited a stiffness optimum that was shifted to a higher stiffness by increasing the numbers of motors and clutches (Fig. 1f)—again consistent with our previous motor–clutch analysis14 (simulation movies depicting cell shape and migration are provided for 0.1, 10 and 1,000 pN nm−1 substrates for low number of motors and clutches; Supplementary Movie 1). A composite metric was created to mathematically combine all four metrics that also shows an increase in the stiffness optimum caused by coordinately increasing the number of motors and clutches in the cell migration simulator (Fig. 1g). U251 glioma cell migration and morphology To experimentally test the predictions of the cell migration simulator, U251 glioma cells were cultured on polyacrylamide hydrogel (PAG) substrates of varying Young's modulus and surface-immobilized collagen type I (formulations in Supplementary Fig. 1). Based on our cell migration simulator, cell migration rate and morphology are predicted to be substrate stiffness sensitive. As shown in the representative images in Fig. 2a, cell morphology depended on the substrate stiffness, such that on a 4.6 kPa gels the cells were small and round, while on a 100 kPa gel they were larger and more elongated. To quantify cell migration and morphology, an image segmentation algorithm was used to estimate cell position, spread area and aspect ratio (Supplementary Fig. 2). Figure 2b shows representative wind-rose plots of cell trajectories on 4.6, 100 and 200 kPa, demonstrating

Read the complete text