An Account of the Appearances Observed in the Dissection of Two of Three Individuals Presumed to Have Perished in the Storm of the 3d, and Whose Bodies Were Discovered in the Vicinity of Leith on the Morning of the 4th, November 1821; with Some Reflections on the Pathology of the Brain: Part I.
Kellie G. · 1824
Read An Account of the Appearances Observed in the Dissection of Two of Three Individuals Presumed to Have Perished in the Storm of the 3d, and Whose Bodies Were Discovered in the Vicinity of Leith on the Morning of the 4th, November 1821; with Some Reflections on the Pathology of the Brain: Part I. by Kellie G. (1824) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc5405298.txt.
Introduction
George Kellie, a physician in Leith, Scotland, wrote an account of two post-mortem examinations, read to the Medico-Chirurgical Society of Edinburgh in February 1822 and printed in its Transactions. Three bodies had been found near Leith on the morning after a fierce storm in November 1821. One was claimed by friends. Kellie and a colleague were asked by the town magistrates to inspect the other two and judge the cause of death.
One body was a middle-aged man and the other an elderly woman. Kellie records that neither showed marks of injury or violence, and he describes each body's look in close detail, from face to limbs. His account, the first part of a longer piece, turns from the findings to what death from cold does to the brain. It shows early forensic method at work.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Kellie G. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 1824 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 57 KB |
| LICENSE | Public Domain |
| RIGHTS | PUBLIC DOMAIN |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
An Account of the Appearances Observed in the Dissection of Two of Three Individuals Presumed to Have Perished in the Storm of the 3d, and Whose Bodies Were Discovered in the Vicinity of Leith on the Morning of the 4th, November 1821; with Some Reflections on the Pathology of the Brain By George Kellie Published in: Transactions. Medico-Chirurgical Society of Edinburgh 0 84 DR KELLIE ON DEATH FROM COLD, AN ACCOUNT OF THE APPEARANCES OBSERVED IN THE DISSECTION OF TWO OF THREE INDIVIDUALS PRESUMED TO HAVE PERISHED IN THE STORM OF THE 3Dr AND WHOSE BODIES WERE DISCOVERED IN THE VICINITY OF LEITH ON THE MORN- ING OF THE 4th, NOVEMBER 1821 ; WITH SOME REFLECTIONS ON THE PATHOLOGY OF THE BRAIN. By George Kellie, M. D. &c. PART I. (Read 6lh February 1822.) On Sunday morning, the 4th November 1821, three dead bodies were discovered in the immediate vicinity of Leith:?the body of one man was found a little to the east of the Links, not far from Seafield Baths,?that of another near to Hermitage Place, also in the links,?and the body of an elderly fe- male was discovered in the neighbourhood of Crown Street. The preceding night had been remarkably AND ON CONGESTIONS OF THE BEAIN. 85 tempestuous, cold, and dark; and as the discovery of three dead bodies extended on the ground, was an occurrence as singular as it was shocking, there seemed, from the first, little reason to doubt that these unfortunate individuals had fallen victims to the severity of the weather. One of the bodies was immediately recognised as that of a well known pauper of the parish, and re- moved by his friends. The other two bodies were exposed in the portal of the church; and remain- ing still unclaimed on Monday, Mr Cheyne and I were requested by the Magistrates to inspect these, and report to them our opinion respecting the cause of death. The one body was that of a middle-aged man, perhaps about forty years ; the other that of an elder- ly female. The countenance of the man was alike free from turgescence and collapse ; the complexion was pal- lid, and somewhat sallow; his features were calm, and without distortion. No mark of external in- jury or violence could be discovered on any part of his body; even the neck, shoulders, back, and hips, were quite free from that redness, livor or ecchymo- sis^so commonly observed in the bodies of the dead. There was no discharge of blood or other fluid from his mouth or nostrils. The body, generally, might be described as presenting the appearance of more than usual freshness and soundness. The abdomen was flat, and not at all tympanised. The trunk and limbs had the usual rigidity of death. On di- 86 DR KELLIE ON DEATH FROM COLD, viding the scalp, it was remarked by Mr Clieyne, that very little blood flowed from the integuments of the head. On exposing the dura mater, its sur- face, where torn from the cranium, was observed to be studded with numerous bleeding points; the whole membrane was somewhat congested, suffused, and heightened in colour; and its sinuses were loaded with dark blood. The veins of the pia ma- ter were very turgid, and extensively injected, so that the whole membrane had a more than usual vascular appearance, and somewhat heightened co- lour. Following the convolutions of the brain, there was a milky or oedematous appearance, ari- sing from effusion of serum, between the arachnoid coat and pia mater. The cerebrum itself, in tex- ture and colour, seemed perfectly sound. The cho- roid plexus presented no appearance of turgescence. In the ventricles of the brain, and at the basis cra- nii, were found between three and four ounces of serous fluid; perhaps rather more than one half of this quantity at the basis cranii, the remainder within the ventricles. On opening the abdomen, our attention was ar- rested by the very deep colouring of the small in- testines. The ileum in particular, through, its whole extent, was very red, and presented a very beautiful example of vascular congestion. A fine net-work of injected vessels spread under the peri- toneal coat, over the whole extent and periphery of the ileum and jejunum. The stomach and colon had nothing of this congestion or colouring; and AND ON CONGESTIONS OF THE BRAIN. 87 the contrast between the appearances of these and of the small intestines was very striking. The sto- mach indeed was remarkably contracted and pale, nearly empty, or containing only about two ounces of a grey-coloured pultaceous fluid, having a faint animal odour. Its peritoneal and muscular coats were natural. On its internal or mucous membrane were observed a few spots, of a coffee-ground colour, and ecchymosed appearance. The liver was con- gested with blood, but had, in all other respects, the natural and healthy appearance. The spleen was rather empty and flaccid. There was no deviation from the usual appearances in the other abdominal viscera. The woman appeared to have passed her sixtieth year. Her complexion was more sanguine than that of the man. The corpse was equally free from blemish or injury. Here, too, Mr Cheyne remarked i;hat very little blood flowed from the integuments of the head, when divided. The dura mater was not so highly coloured as in the man; its veins, however, were injected, and its sinuses were load- ed with blood. The pia mater, and the veins be- tween the convolutions of the brain, were fully in- jected, and very turgid. About three ounces of serous fluid were found in the ventricles of the brain, and at the basis cranii. In the abdomen, the omentum was found large, and very much loaded with fat: the colon was also buried in fat. On raising the omentum, it was a very striking coincidence to observe, that here also 88 DIt KELLIE 0N DEATH FROM COLD, the small intestines exhibited precisely the same ap- pearance as in the man ; the same redness, not in patches, but over the whole extent of the bowel; and occasioned by the same general and minute in- jection of the vessels, profusely ramified beneath the peritoneal coat. The stomach and colon, too, were in this case of the usual pale colour, having no vestige of the same vascular congestion. The bowels were not tympanised. The stomach was not so con- tracted and empty as in the man: it contained about four or five ounces of viscous fluid, and . a few pieces of indigested beef. There were 011 the mu- cous membrane of the stomach a few congested spots, of a florid purple colour. The pancreas was of an unusually dark flesh colour. The liver, spleen, and other viscera presented 110 uncommon appear- ance. In our report, therefore, to the Magistrates, we con- sidered ourselves justified in stating our conviction, that these unfortunate victims had not fallen in conse- quence of any violence or injury inflicted by them- selves or others ; and our belief that they had pe- rished from the severity of the weather, to which they had, in some way or other, been exposed du- ring the whole of