Hypertelorism * The fourth Sir John Struthers' lecture delivered in the Hall of the Royal College of Surgeons of Edinburgh, 1st February 1924. : A Hitherto Undifferentiated Congenital Cranio-Facial Deformity
1924
Read Hypertelorism * The fourth Sir John Struthers' lecture delivered in the Hall of the Royal College of Surgeons of Edinburgh, 1st February 1924. : A Hitherto Undifferentiated Congenital Cranio-Facial Deformity (1924) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc5294069.txt.
Introduction
David M. Greig delivered the fourth Sir John Struthers lecture in Edinburgh on 1 February 1924, proposing the name hypertelorism, published in the Edinburgh Medical Journal. The deformity he describes, a congenital cranio-facial condition not previously set apart, has one constant feature: great breadth between the eyes. Greig builds the word from Greek parts meaning too much, apart, and to separate, and adds 'ocular' to fix the point.
He is careful to separate the condition from look-alikes: a broad nasal bridge alone is not it, nor are eyes pushed apart by a frontal meningocele or a facial cleft. Closing the lecture, he reasons about origins along the lines where face, skull, and brain develop and meet. The soft parts he clears of blame, finding no scars, no failed unions, and normal muscle action; the cause must lie deeper, in bone or in the contents of the skull.
Catalog record
| YEAR | 1924 |
|---|---|
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 78 KB |
| LICENSE | Public Domain |
| RIGHTS | PUBLIC DOMAIN |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Hypertelorism *The fourth Sir John Struthers' lecture delivered in the Hall of the Royal College of Surgeons of Edinburgh, 1st February 1924. By David M. Greig Published in: Edinburgh Medical Journal HYPERTELORISM.* A hitherto imdifferentiated congenital cranio-facial deformity. By DAVID M. GREIG, C.M., F.R.C.S.E., Conservator of the Museum.f Any event in this world?a7iy human being for that matter?that seems to wear even the faintest cast or warp of strangeness, is apt to leave a disproportionately sharp impression on one's senses.?Walter de la Mare. I DEEPLY appreciate the honour that has been conferred upon me in asking me to deliver the Struthers' lecture. Sir John Struthers was a life-long friend of my father, and as Professor Struthers he formed one of the earliest recollections of my childhood and remained thereafter a paradigm and an incen- tive. It was an admirable characteristic of Sir John Struthers' anatomical studies, a characteristic thoroughly appreciated by surgeons, that they so frequently presented a clinical vein. No one knew better than he that the study of anatomy necessarily entails the study of abnormalities, that an understanding of growth is interwoven with appreciation of congenital defects, that the so-called normal is but the average among variations, and that the abnormal is merely a departure from a somewhat arbitrarily chosen type. I am not able to follow Professor Struthers' example by making the anatomical aspect the primary one, but I hope to present a clinical study in which I believe anatomical considera- tions do not form the least important feature. The outstanding peculiarity of the cranial deformity for which I propose the name ocular hypertelorism, or briefly, hypertelorism, is the great breadth between the eyes. Hypertelorism (v7rep = too much, rrjAe = apart, oplgw = to separate) preceded by the adjective ocular, accurately, con- cisely, and suggestively describes the salient and constant feature observable during life. Great breadth of nasal bridge sometimes with hypertrophy of bones, interocular hyper-rhinoplaty, to coin another name, may exist without an undue distance between the eyes. The eyes may be far apart in cases of frontal meningocele or encephalocele, or in cases of congenital facial or nasal cleft, * The fourth Sir John Struthers' lecture delivered in the Hall of the Royal College of Surgeons of Edinburgh, ist February 1924. f I desire to thank the Carnegie Universities Trust for a grant towards the cost of reproducing the illustrations of this paper. 56? . \ Figs, i and 2.?Hypertelorism ; Case I., ast. 7 years. Figs. 3 and 4.?Hypertelorism ; Case I., aet. 18 years. Hypertelorism but the ocular far-apartness is then subsidiary to the tumour or to the still more hideous defect. Case. I.?Mary Macdougal, who is the main subject of this lecture, was a native of Edinburgh, the only and illegitimate child of a feeble- minded mother. Her alleged father?a cabman?was addicted to occasional intemperance. Her maternal grandmother was not known to present any abnormality. When about 7 years of age photographs of her (Figs. 1 and 2) were shown by Dr John Thomson at a meeting of the Edinburgh Medico-Chirurgical Society (1) as those of an imbecile girl with a peculiar congenital malformation of the face. Dr Thomson considered that " the general look of the child's face recalled so strongly that of an early foetus that it appeared likely that the whole thing was a mere arrest of normal development of some kind," while Dr J. W. Ballantyne "was inclined to regard it as a slight one of 'rhinodyme,' i.e., an attempt at doubling of the parts at and above the level of the nose." (Cf 39, 40.) I was much struck by the photographs, and very interested in the opinions then expressed, and a few years later when the child was transferred to my own care I received her with a re-awakened interest. When she was 16 years of age she was undersized but not excessively so. Her skin, though soft and smooth, was of a dusky grey colour and her extremities presented an acrocyanosis of a pinky- blue tint. Her fingers and toes were short in comparison with their breadth and were unusually soft and fat. She had large hands and a fairly powerful grip. The subcutaneous tissue was well developed especially about the neck and chin. The distance between the eyes, and the great breadth of the lower part of her nasal bridge (Fig. 3) have been already referred to as the outstanding features of hyper- telorism. The nasal bridge was flat and the nose in consequence retrousse. The vertical groove which Dr Thomson had noted as being so much in evidence nine years previously, and on which Dr Ballantyne, perhaps too greatly, had based his diagnosis of "rhinodyme" was not nearly so distinct. The forehead formed a regular anterior curve with slight prominence of the frontal eminences (Fig. 4). The eyelids were somewhat full and fatty and gave the impression that the eyeballs were overloaded by them. She had a bilateral external strabismus, the eyes being apparently equally affected 5)- Her eyes did not converge on near objects. Like a hare, she could not see objects directly in front of her so readily or so well as when they were placed laterally or when she turned her head away from them. The movement of the eyeballs did not always co-ordinate. I was never successful in getting a view of the fundus oculi, but believe there may have been some optic atrophy, as towards the end of her vol. xxxi. no. x. 561 2 p 2 David M. Greig life her eyesight failed considerably. Her tongue was large and slightly fissured as in tongue-sucking children. Though Dr Thomson had noted her teeth as good and normal, they were very bad, carious, and defective when she came under my observation. She never complained of toothache but the teeth loosened and many disappeared. Puberty came on about 15 years of age and her breasts became loose, pendulous, and flabby. Menstruation gave her no trouble. She was twice operated on for tuberculous cervical adenitis. She died at the age of 22 years from pulmonary tuberculosis. To many casual observers her countenance was repellent, but to those in daily contact with her her gentle and affectionate nature made her an acceptable child. Always even-tempered, she could be trusted with even some of the most restless children in the Institution, and these she used to exercise in the grounds and she seemed quietly alive to her responsibilities when her charge thought fit from time to time to break away. She had cleanly and tidy habits, was fond of a pretty dress or coloured ribbon, and was modest and of a retiring disposition. She used to help to dress and undress the helpless children, and could nurse and feed them until her eyesight became too deficient. A little knitting was the only handiwork in which she could take an interest, and of this she accomplished very little. Her hearing was good and she enjoyed music of any kind. Her vocabulary was limited and her articulation very defective, at best being little more than a mutter. Her voice was rather low-pitched. Her memory was fair. She could give the names of some of