Book Reviews

1913

Read Book Reviews (1913) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc5273038.txt.

Introduction

A book review section headed New Books appeared in the Edinburgh Medical Journal in 1913, surveying recent surgical publications. Pride of place goes to the latest Collected Papers by the staff of St. Mary's Hospital, Rochester, Minnesota, the Mayo Clinic's volume of 603 pages issued by W. B. Saunders in 1912. The reviewer calls it indispensable for teachers and investigators alike, and notes how abdominal and genito-urinary surgery dominate, showing surgeons advancing into ground once held by physicians.

A companion notice praises the two-volume collection of the Mayo brothers' papers published before 1909, edited by Mrs. M. H. Mellish, as a reference record every operating surgeon should own, with a tribute to the brothers' father, William Morrell Mayo. A further review takes up Oskar Vulpius's Treatment of Infantile Paralysis, translated by Allan H. Todd, a leading authority's account focused on orthopaedic care of the disease's after-effects.

Catalog record

YEAR1913
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE16 KB
LICENSEPublic Domain
RIGHTSPUBLIC DOMAIN
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC5273038

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Book Reviews Published in: Edinburgh Medical Journal 182 New Books NEW BOOKS. Collected Papers by the Staff of St. Mary's Hospital, Rochester, Minnesota. Pp. 603. Philadelphia: W. B. Saunders Co. 1912. A Collection of Papers Published Previous to 1909. By William J. Mayo and Charles H. Mayo. Two Vols. Philadelphia: W. B. Saunders Co. 1912. The most recent issue of the papers emanating from the Mayo Clinic at Rochester fully maintains the high standard set by its predecessors. This publication reflects all that is most advanced in present-day surgery, and it has now come to be an indispensable source of informa- tion alike for the teacher and investigator. The preponderance of ?contributions relating to the surgery of the abdomen, including the genito-urinary system, indicates the present general trend of surgical advance, and the wide range of subjects dealt with shows how far the surgeon has encroached upon domains hitherto claimed by the physician. It is impossible in a short notice even to refer to the individual ?contributions, and where each is of the highest quality it would be invidious to select any for special mention. We cannot, however, leave this volume without paying our mead of respect to the memory of that really remarkable man William Morrell Mayo, the father of the two distinguished surgeons who have made the town of Rochester famous, who died full of years and respected and loved by all who came under his influence. Mrs. M. H. Mellish, who edits with such conspicuous ability the work just noticed, has placed the surgical reader under a further debt of gratitude to her by publishing, in two volumes uniform with the " Collected Papers" series, the numerous contributions to surgical literature made by the Mayo brothers previous to 1909. We have thus in a convenient form for reference a record of all the important work done at Rochester by these surgeons. These volumes should be on the shelves of every medical library and of every operating surgeon. The Treatment of Infantile Paralysis. By Oskar Vulpius, Professor Extraordinary at the University of Heidelberg. Translated by Allan H. Todd, M.B., B.S.(Lond.). London: Bailliere, Tindall & Cox. 1912. This important work, written by one of the first authorities on the subject, deals almost exclusively with the orthopaedic treatment of the sequela) of epidemic myelitis; a few introductory chapters have been added, however, dealing with the symptomatology, etiology, and pathological anatomy of the disease. The rest of the book is divided into two parts, of which the first deals with the therapeutic methods in use at the present time, the second comprising a description of New Books 183 the paralyses of the various parts of the body and of their treatment. The introductory chapters, although limited in scope, give an excellent account of the disease. Authorities are quoted who maintain that the cerebral and spinal palsies of children are really one and the same affection, differing only in the anatomical structure which they chance to affect. The author makes the important comment that cerebial paralysis differs from spinal, not only in the treatment that is required, but also in the success which is obtained. He rec'oids interesting examples in which the leg affected by paralysis has actually under- gone elongation; in the majority of cases, however, it would appear to be only an apparent lengthening. In discussing the bacteriology of acute poliomyelitis suitable reference is made to recent investigations, and particularly those by Flexner of New York. As already mentioned, the greater part of the work is taken up with the treatment. The various therapeutic measures employed in the prevention and correction of deformities are described in clear language, and the number of excellent illustrations makes it easy of comprehension by the reader. We venture to hope that this excellent and practical manual will receive the attention it deserves. The treatment of infantile paralysis in this country leaves a great deal to be desired. A Treatise on Tumours. By Arthur E. IIertzler, M.D., Associate Professor of Surgery in the University of Kansas. London : J. & A. Churchill. 1912.... _ Price 30s, net. This large and pretentious work is dedicated by the author to his w ife, " who through many years has kept together the data that have gone to make up the book." The aim of the work is " to give students an practitioners a guide to the proper recognition of tumours; avail- a e )oo \s dealing with this subject are either broadly clinical or entirely scientific. A proper comprehension of any tumour demands the application of both the scientific view-point and clinical observation. Abe aim has been to supply this need." After a conscientious perusal ot the book we are unable to say that the author has entirely succeeded. He quotes the high authority of Yirchow in grouping together all tumours both true and false, as " from the clinical point of view this is the only possible method of approaching a proper grasp of the subject;" for example, with tumours of the cranium are included wens, dermoids, gummata, and hernia cerebri. The well-known and useful classification of Ribbert is closely followed, and a good description is given of the theories regarding the etiology of tumours. Part I., which deals with the general pathology of tumours, is clearly and concisely written. No reference is made to the spread of cancer by permeation that is made so much of by Sampson Handley. We think the use of the term "expansile" as the reverse of "infiltrating" ISA New Books unfortunate. It is stated, for example, that " osteomas are expansile and benign." Part II., which deals with the special pathology of tumours, is on the whole a very readable and instructive account of this important subject. It may be said that the author shows a more intimate acquaintance with German literature than with French or English. The amount of attention given to different groups of tumours is unequal; endotheliomata, 'for example, are dealt with at considerable length, while osteomata, neuromata, and odontomata are very curtly dealt with. There is a chapter on multiple myelomata, but 110 mention of the solitary variety except under giant-celled sarcoma. Part III. deals with tumours of the different regions and organs. There is here again a want of uniformity in scope which is often difficult to explain, as when, for example, a whole page is devoted to secondary cancer of the liver and only a few lines to retroperitoneal growths. Epithelial tumours of the jaws, except those which arise from teeth germs, are not even mentioned. The sections on the mamma and on the stomach are, on the other hand, all that could be desired. We have ventured to criticise this work somewhat closely, but not in any captious sense. It is undoubtedly an educational work of great value, and the illustrations, which are both very numerous (538) and of a very high standard of excellence, convey a great deal of useful information. Primary Malignant Growth* of the Lungs and Bronchi: A pathological and Clinical Study. By I. Adler, A.M., M.D. Pp. 235. London: Longmans, Green & Co. 1912. Price 16s. In this volume Dr. Adler presents the results of his own experience

Read the complete text