The Medical Profession and the Army.

1916

Read The Medical Profession and the Army. (1916) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc5227338.txt.

Introduction

An unsigned editorial in The Hospital dated April 1, 1916 pressed the case for more doctors to join the Army during the First World War. Medical men of military age faced a hard choice. Army pay would cover little of the family and practice costs they had taken on, and a long absence meant losing patients and income. The editorial shows sympathy for that position, then sets it against the Army's need.

The Director-General had stated plainly that replacing losses in France alone required at least 150 new medical officers every month. The losses covered deaths, wounds, sickness, and men whose year of service had ended. Growing forces in training camps needed medical cover too. The piece argues the duty is beyond dispute and that the profession, despite great sacrifices already made, must meet the standard of enough rather than much.

Catalog record

YEAR1916
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE7 KB
LICENSEPublic Domain
RIGHTSPUBLIC DOMAIN
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC5227338

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Medical Profession and the Army

Published in: The Hospital

The
Workers' Newspaper of Administrative Medicine and Institutional
Life, Administration, National Insurance and Health.
No. 1555, Vol. LX. SATURDAY, APRIL 1, 1916. PRICE ONE PENNY
/) O xS /--> t~~/
THE MEDICAL PROFESSION AND THE ARMY.
It is impossible to avoid a feeling of sincere
sympathy for members of the medical profession
who fall within the military age and who are there-
fore called upon to say whether they are or are not,
willing to take service in the Army should their
services be required. The great majority of these
are men who have been in independent practice for
a longer or shorter period. They have incurred
obligations, both domestic and financial. Toward
these obligations the Army pay will be but an in-
adequate contribution. And a prolonged absence
from practice must mean necessarily the loss of
patients and a depreciated income. Such, in bald
terms, is the position which a large number of
medical practitioners are at this moment called
upon to face. On the other hand is the certainty
that the Army which stands between the country
and national disaster is in clamant need of more
doctors. This necessity, it is true, has been chal-
lenged, but hardly by any responsible authority..
It now stands without possibility of contradiction,
for we have the plain announcement of the
Director-General that even to meet the wastage of
war in France he needs every month at least 150
new medical officers. There are losses by death,
b wounds, and by sickness, and some officers who
h. e fulfilled their engagement of a year's service,
ai compelled by the exigencies of practice to
return to their homes. In addition, it has to be'
remembered that by the summoning to the Colours
of the " Groups" and the " Classes," the Army
is constantly being increased in size, and soldiers in
training camps, like to those in the trenches, must
needs have medical help and oversight. It is not
necessary to say to the medical profession that as
a matter of imperative patriotic responsibility the
situation so depicted must be fully met. The pro-
fession has indeed already done great things and
made great sacrifices. But the measure of the
moment is fixed solely by the standard of suffi-
ciency. Everywhere in the national emergency the
demand is not for "much" but for "enough."
And there is now written in plain characters the
message that whatever personal sacrifices may be
involved more doctors must be recruited for the
Army.
The necessity being 'beyond dispute, there
remains only the question?How can it be met?
Manifestly, one method would be the issue of an
appeal for volunteers comparable to those to which
recent months have made us accustomed. In sub-
stance this method has been in operation since the
commencement of the war, and the response to it
is seen in the multitudes of civil practitioners now
serving as officers in the R.A.M.C. Doubtless a
further call direct from the War Office to the pro-
fession would bring even yet a number of
volunteers. But it is necessary to observe that the
situation to-day is very different from that which,
existed in the early, months of the war. Then
there were engaged in various forms of hospital and
civil practice large numbers of young men who had
few responsibilities and to whom new experiences
and adventurous undertakings made a ready appeal.
Now these, and many others who couid no k
claim the advantages of youth, are already serviut
their King arid country. The''appeal for'further
help therefore comes to ineh whose plan of life is
settled, who have given hostages to fortune, and
who cannot answer the call* except at the risk of
interests which both to themselves and to their
families are of the first importance. When they
answer, as they will answer, it will be not with
light hearts keen for enterprise, but under the
sense of a deep patriotic obligation and with the
anxious consciousness of personal risk and sacrifice.
Is it in these circumstances a reasonable and fair
thing to leave the choice, aye or no, purely to the
judgment of the individual practitioner? If this
is done it is obvious there can be no common and
impartial standard, and inevitably there will be great
inequality of sacrifice. The more sensitive will
suffer out of proportion to their fellows, and there
is even the risk that in the absence of direction
and guidance, there may be so much delay in deci-
sion that the response will not be equal to the
demand. But if the issue ought not to be left
entirely to personal debate there is only one other
possible course?namely, to substitute for the indi-
vidual judgment a corporate or professional deci-
sion. The more clearly it is recognised that the
practitioners concerned are under the pressure of
THE HOSPITAL April 1, 1916.
conflicting claims as these are defined respectively
by personal obligations and by patriotic motives,
the more obvious does it appear that the only
method of relief is the interposition of a competent,
a sympathetic, and an impartial tribunal. In a
word, the profession must take action as a whole
and must not leave the painful and anxious decision
to the judgment of its perplexed and unguided
members.
The plan for organisation and for corporate
action in this matter presents a claim for sacrifice
from many individuals who -will, as a matter of
fact, never be called upon to leave home for active
service. The sacrifice is a willingness to leave the
definition of their personal duty in the hands of
others. Undoubtedly this to men acutely conscious
of many personal claims and obligations is a hard
thing to yield. But what is the alternative? It
is that there shall be no organisation at all, and
that to every man it shall be left to do what seems
right in his own eyes. Between the two courses
there is no middle way. The Army needs more
doctors. More doctors, therefore, must certainly
be found. Who shall go and who stay are
tions of great difficulty and stress to the
constituency as it at present exists. Urn
choice with all its embarrassments is to be
the individual, the decision must be refe
some authoritative voice. The Central Wu
mittee, whatever its demerits, is at least an organi-
sation which is trying to arrange a decision based
upon an appreciation of the whole of the facts.
Still more, it is in active existence. In the absence
of competitors it holds the field, and this in the
existing situation is no small virtue. Hence,
though we have criticised some of its arrangements,
we hold that it deserves the support of the profes-
sion, and that in the present circumstances it is
the only available medium through which can be
secured, with some measure of justice and of
equality of sacrifice, the professional assistance of
which, now admittedly, the Army stands in need.
Not less essential is the Committee in order to
maintain such a distribution of the profession that
the needs of the civil population may be reasonably

Read the complete text