Observations on Endemic Cretinism in the Chitral and Gilgit Valleys.

McCarrison R. · 1908

Read Observations on Endemic Cretinism in the Chitral and Gilgit Valleys. by McCarrison R. (1908) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc5183164.txt.

Introduction

R. McCarrison reported on endemic cretinism in the Chitral and Gilgit valleys in The Indian Medical Gazette in December 1908, in a paper read to the Royal Society of Medicine. McCarrison, agency surgeon in Gilgit, based the study on 203 cases. They made up the whole cretinous population of the Gilgit and Mastuj districts. He gathered them by house-to-house checks of nearly every goitrous village, across some 500 miles of Himalayan country.

He organizes the study around the link between cretinism and goitre, in the child, in the mother, and in the district at large. Where goitre is only beginning, he notes, no cretinism appears. He could not trace a single case where a child's own goitre gave rise to cretinism. That points suspicion toward the mother's condition. He warns that his conclusions apply to these races and conditions and must be adjusted elsewhere.

Catalog record

CREATORMcCarrison R.
YEAR1908
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE39 KB
LICENSEPublic Domain
RIGHTSPUBLIC DOMAIN
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC5183164

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Observations on Endemic Cretinism in the Chitral and Gilgit Valleys *Read at Royal Society of Medicine, London. By R. McCarrison Published in: The Indian Medical Gazette Dec., 1908.] GOITRE AND CRETINISM IN CRITRAL. 441 ?riginal ^riicles. OBSERVATIONS ON ENDEMIC CRETINISM IN THE CHITRAL AND GILGIT* VALLEYS. By R. McOARItlSON, m.b., b ch., CAPTAIN, I.M.S., Agency Surgeon in Gilgit. The present study of Endemic Cretinism is based on an analysis of 203 cases of the disease, comprising the total cretinous population of the Gilgit and Mastuj districts. These districts extend over an area of about 500 miles of Hima- layan countrj7. The cases have been collected by a house to house examination of almost every goitrous village in the district, so that few examples of the disease have escaped my observation. -At the outset I should, perhaps, direct atten- tion to the fact that the observations to be detailed, and the conclusions to be drawn, refer O'dy to cietinism as prevailing among the Chitrali and Gilgiti races. It will be found necessary when applying these results else- where, to take into consideration such factors racial differences, habits of life, climatic conditions, etc., which are of importance in determining the prevalence of the disease. (1) For convenience of discussion I propose to divide mv subiect into the following six sections :? I- The incidence of cretinism and its relationship to the incidence of goitre. II. Goitre in the individual and its relation- ship to cretinism. III. Goitre in the mother and its relation- ship to cretinism. IV. Debilitating factors and their influence on the mother in producing cretinism. V. Types of the disease with associated symptoms. VI. Conclusions. 9 I. The Incidence of Ciietinism and its RELATIONSHIP TO THE INCIDENCE OF GOITRE. As is well known, endemic goitre, cretinism ftnd deaf-mutism, are associated conditions. In this respect Gilgit and Chitral provide no ex- ception to the rule. There are certain facts, however, with regard to the association, which are deserving of com- ment,? (a) Where goitre is commencing in epidemic form, as for example in Nagar, or among troops introduced into infected areas, the younger members of the community are the first to suffer. Such an epidemic, however, produces no cases of cretinism. (b) In Chifcral, on the other hand, where a | relatively high percentage of children are goit- i rous, cretinism does occur, but is not common. I have been unable to trace a single instance, in which goitre in the child has given rise to cretinism. Cretinism does not make its appearance in a goitrous family until the second or even the third generation. (c) Now, in Gilgit, children suffer much less from goitre than do the children of Chifcral, but they suffer much more from cretinism. Goitre is said to be of comparatively recent introduction into Chifcral. In Gilgit, it has prevailed for centuries, and in districts where goitre is more prevalant among the adult population, cretinism is more common and of a graver type. (d) Cretinism shows a marked tendency to occur in certain families. It is common to find several children in the same family, cretinous. I have met with instances where every child in the family has been a cretin. While, therefore, cretinism is found to be intimately associated with goitre, the degree of this association is determined by the age of the endemic of goitre and by the extent to which the disease prevails among the adult population, II. Goitris in this Individual and its KELATIONSHIP TO CRETINISM. Just as endemic goitre is rarely found to produce myxcedema in the adult, so this con- dition is rarely a cause of cretinism in the child. Indeed, I have never met with such a case. This fact is opposed to the present day view that 75% of cretinism in goitrous localities is due to goitre in the individual.(3) Facts bearing on this point have already been dealt with in the preceding section; the follow- ing further observations remain to be recorded:? (1) There are in the present series of 203 cases, 88, or 44% in which there is an accom- panying goitre. With the exception of two cases, in which the goitre was congenital, the history shows that the thyroid enlargement was subsequent and not prior to the appearance of the cretinic symptoms. It is possible that in some instances these histories may be incorrect, the accompanying Chart, however, should establish this general truth. The black line shows the number of cretins, the red line the number of goitrous cretins in the district at each )rear of age up to and over twenty years. From the chart it will be observed that the older a cretin is, the more likely he is to have a goitre. While only 17% of all cretins under the age of ten years are goitrous, no less than 70% over that age have an accompanying goitre. (2) I can find little support for the view that goitrous cretins are, as a rule, less swollen and their condition relatively less grave than that of those without a goitre. Of the 88 goitrous cretins 20% are noted as being much swollen while in the non-goitrous cases 25% are similarly a Read at Royal Society of Medicine, London. 442 THE INDIAN MEDICAL GAZETTE. [Dec., 1908. much swollen. So far as my experience goes, I find that the presence or absence of a goitre is a matter of very little importance to the child's myxoedematous condition. The mental defect is, however, frequently greater, and nervous symptoms are more commonly present in these without a goitre. It is to be remembered that the so-called "goitre" is in reality made up, in the vast majority, of one or more adenomata in a functionally inactive or imperfectly active organ. The presence of such a goitre would not be beneficial to the child. There are, however, some few cases, in which the development of a goitre would appear to have been beneficial. Mr. James Berry, in his work on the tigroid gland, has instanced a case where the general body swellingdiminished as the goitre enlarged. I have met with two similar cases (Nos. 5 and 159). I have noted the presence of "fatty tumours" in 24y/ of my cases. (3) Cretins are much more commonly goitrous than are healthy children. III. Goitre in the Mother and its Relationship to Cretinism. Our conception of endemic goitre lias under- gone some change of late 3'ears. The disease has hitherto been regarded as non-infectious. My investigations, however, have convinced me of its infectious nature. This view, although perhaps not yet sufficiently proven to demonstra- tion, nevertheless provides the better explanation of its general phenomena, and of its sequel endemic cretinism. There are, as is well known, certain infectious diseases of the mother such as tuberculosis, erysipelas, acute rheumatism, malaria, and influenza, which are capable of producing patho- logical effects on the child's tigroid gland. It is believed that the toxins produced by the organisms of these diseases circulate in the foetus and give rise to the morbid condition. It is to these toxins that cases of sporadic cretinism, in which there is no associated goitre, are attributed. Although infectious agencies have an

Read the complete text