The Pandemic of Influenza in India in the Year 1918.

Phipson ES. · 1923

Read The Pandemic of Influenza in India in the Year 1918. by Phipson ES. (1923) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc5178767.txt.

Introduction

E. S. Phipson wrote a thesis on the 1918 influenza pandemic in India, published in The Indian Medical Gazette in November 1923. Phipson, lately assistant health officer for Bombay, examines a catastrophe he helped investigate: within two months the epidemic killed, at the latest computation, no fewer than eight million people in India.

He argues the disaster was overshadowed by the war and its aftermath, though for sheer virulence it had no parallel in India's history and probably none in any other country. The thesis traces earlier influenza epidemics since Hippocrates, then studies the 1918 visitation in detail, above all in Bombay City, where he was responsible for much of the inquiry. He closes by asking what lessons the epidemic teaches for handling future outbreaks.

Catalog record

CREATORPhipson ES.
YEAR1923
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE63 KB
LICENSEPublic Domain
RIGHTSPUBLIC DOMAIN
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC5178767

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Pandemic of Influenza in India in the Year 1918 *Note.—Thesis approved of for the degree of M.D. (London University). Received for publication, 28th August, 1923.—Ed., I.M.G. By E. S. Phipson Published in: The Indian Medical Gazette THE PANDEMIC OF INFLUENZA IN INDIA IN THE YEAR 1918 * (With Special Reference to the City of Bombay.) By E. S. PHIPSON, d.s.o., m.d. (Lond.), D.P.H., D.T.M. & H., MAJOR, I.M.S., Health Officer, Simla, and lately Assistant Health Officer, Bombay Municipality. Introduction.?The preoccupations ot a world war, the engrossing problems which have fol- lowed in its wake, and the epidemic pre- valence of influenza on a considerable scale within British shores have so fully occupied our attention that the calamitous happenings in India during 1918 may well have been some- what obscured. Our minds, inured as it were, to the gigantic events of the past ten years, may have failed to appreciate fully the magnitude of the scourge which in 1918 swept over the length and breadth of India and, within * Note.?Thesis approved of for the degree -of m.d. (London University). Received for publication, 28th August, 1923.?Ed., I.M.G. 510 THE INDIAN MEDICAL GAZETTE. [Nov., 1923. the space of two months, slew at the latest computation, no fewer than eight million of her people, which for virulence was without parallel even in India's chequered history, and which is probably unequalled in any other country in the world. It is the purpose of this thesis to examine in detail the features of this visitation, parti- cularly as it appeared in Bombay City, where in his capacity as Assistant Health Officer the writer was intimately associated with, and to some extent responsible for the investigation and conduct of the epidemic within the city and island of Bombay, to discuss some of the difficulties and problems encountered in that investigation and to consider how far the les- sons of the epidemic may help us in deter- mining the best methods of dealing with any outbreak in the future. 2. Influenza in the past.?It may not be in- appropriate to consider briefly what little informa- tion is available as to previous epidemics of influenza. According to Hirsch,1 epidemics of influenza have periodically visited every quar- ter of the globe since the time of Hippocrates, and the disease may be followed into the re- motest periods from which we have any epide- miological records. Apart from the outbreaks of catarrhal fever in ancient times, the nature of which must necessarily be a matter of sur- mise, an extensive pandemic of influenza seems to have occurred in the reign of Queen Elizabeth, and it is probable that India, China and Asiatic Russia shared in the visitation. Since then epidemics have occurred from time to time, notably in 1803, 1833 and 1837, in- volving Eastern as well as Western countries. In the year 1850, India was certainly visited by an epidemic of influenza, but there does not appear to be any evidence of serious mortality in connection with it. The older generation will recall the last great pandemic of 1889-1890. In the spring- of 1889 a catarrhal fever which had been pre- valent in Asiatic Russia suddenly assumed pandemic proportions and, following the ordinary lines of communication, swept west- wards, reaching Petrograd in October, Paris in November, and London in December. Thence the wave spread further westward across the Atlantic, and south-east, following the mail route, to India where it appeared in Bombay in February, spreading later all over India. The origin of this epidemic is believed to have been in Bokhara, a semi-independent state of Russian Turkestan. When it is re- membered that Bokhara is in trading com- munication with India, and within a few hundred miles of the Indian frontier, it is strange that the infection only reached India after an enormous detour of many thousands of miles over land and sea. The difficulties of direct communication between Bokhara and India, particularly when the trade routes are rendered almost impassable by snow, probably account for this. It is known, however, that in 1890, the re- mote Gilgit district of India was infected from Chitral, a still more remote outpost, and not from India,2 and it is quite conceivable that a party of traders from Bokhara brought the infection to Chitral. The infection does not seem to have spread further into British India from this direction. A contemporary view of the origin of the 1890 epidemic is given by Ellis.s "Appearing first in Bombay at the latter end of February or early in Mar'ch, it seems to have been very closely connected with the movements of European troops; its almost simultaneous appearance at Delhi, Lucknow, and other large military stations in Northern India being probably attributable to the arrival of drafts from England, which at that season of the year are constantly pressing up-country to join the various regiments." The writer has been at some pains to col- lect the scattered contemporary records of the beginnings of the epidemic of 1890 as it affected India in order to assist in elucidating, by analogy, the problem of the genesis of the 1918 epidemic, which, although apparently obvious, reveals on detailed examination some peculiar features which are discussed hereafter. 3. The Genesis of the Epidemic.?The lat- ter half of 1918 in India was in some respects a healthy period; apart from influenza it was abnormally free from epidemic disease; the incidence of plague was the mildest ex- perienced for twenty years, and the failure of the monsoon had determined a malarial in- cidence below normal. The subnormal rain- fall was, however, most unfortunate, for in the latter half of 1918 the stocks of food grains in India were relatively low, prices everywhere were abnormally high, and the scarcity of fodder was responsible for a great shortage of milk, which in many places was almost unprocurable. War demands had greatly depleted the medical personnel of India, which at the best is inadequate when compared with the size of her population, and when the epidemic struck India she was ill-prepared to cope with a calamity of such magnitude.10 By whatever route it arrived, influenza became apparent in Bombay about the be- ginning of June 1918. It found there un- limited opportunity for development. In Dr. Turner's graphic words, " Bombay during the month of June may be compared to a huge incubator, with suitable media already pre- pared for the insemination of germs of dis- ease ; the temperature, moisture and material in suitable condition; an overcrowded city with a large working class population living in Nov., 1923.] PANDEMIC OF INFLUENZA IN INDIA IN 1918 : PHIPSON. $11 conditions which lend themselves to the rapid spread of disease, either insect-borne or from personal contact, should it be introduced." It is axiomatic that an epidemic is either imported into a community from outside or that it arises from a previously existing en- demic focus, assuming an epidemic character as a result of increased activity on the part of the virus or diminished resistance on the part of the population in which the focus persists. That the epidemic in Bombay was what may be termed endogenous is by no means an im - possible

Read the complete text