The Variation of Animals and Plants under Domestication.
1868
Read The Variation of Animals and Plants under Domestication. (1868) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc5165317.txt.
Introduction
A review in The British and Foreign Medico-Chirurgical Review, dated 1868 in the hosted text, examines a two-volume work by Charles Darwin. Its title is The Variation of Animals and Plants under Domestication. Darwin's 1859 book on the origin of species had promised a mass of supporting evidence, and this 843-page work delivers the first half of it, on domesticated life.
The reviewer explains that ill health delayed Darwin and that the facts which first convinced him are still withheld for a later work on variation in nature. What is present covers how animals and plants change under human care, with large and flourishing genera showing the most varying species. The reviewer urges readers to pause before any final hostile judgment on natural selection until the promised evidence on wild species appears.
Catalog record
| YEAR | 1868 |
|---|---|
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 68 KB |
| LICENSE | Public Domain |
| RIGHTS | PUBLIC DOMAIN |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Variation of Animals and Plants under Domestication Published in: The British and Foreign Medico-Chirurgical Review Review VIII. The Variation of Animals and Plants under Domestication. By Charles Darwin, M.A., F.H.S., &c. Two volumes. With illustrations. 1868. Pp. 843. When the excitement caused by the publication in 1859 of the celebrated book on " The Origin of Species" had, to some extent, had time to subside, and the true character of Mr.Darwin's 11 liant tlieory was beginning to be more clearly recognised, it ?v as s?on perceived that no final decision could be expressed on its merits, until the promised evidence on which the theory was based had been fairly and attentively examined. An interval or ^iree years was at first supposed, by the author, to be sufficient to enable him to complete the work, of which he had been urged to publish this now well-known Abstract; but owing, as we notice with regret, to continued ill-health, only half ot the anxiously expected and long delayed evidence has been 144 litvicivs. [July placed before us, and it is further to be regretted that the most important facts are those which are still unavoidably withheld, for " it was the consideration of these facts," writes Mr. Darwin, " which first led me to take up the present subjectand " I hope," he subsequently adds, " that the reader will pause before coming to any final and hostile conclusion on the theory of natural selection. It is the facts and yiews to be hereafter given which have convinced me of the truth of the theory." Consequently, the all-important question of the origin of species by means of natural selection, which, strictly speaking, requires for its answer a complete biography of the organic world, can at present be considered only with reference to the variation of animals and plants under domestication. No date has been, nor perhaps can, consistently with the unfavorable state of Mr. Darwin's health, be fixed for the pub- lication of the remaining portion of this grandly planned work, on which so much of the success of the theory has been admitted to depend. We have for the present been briefly informed that the author proposes in a second work to discuss the variability of organic beings in a state of nature, and it will be shown that variations occurring under these circumstances are greatly de- pendent on geographical distribution. An attempt will be made also to show that whilst it is the large and flourishing genera which include the greatest number of varying species, those species which are the most variable are also the most widely distributed. But the main subject of this promised work will be the conver- sion of varieties into species consequent on an ever-recurring struggle for existence. For as the author has already stated in his introductory work, the normal condition of the organic world is war; and as the strongest in the battle of life must, as a rule, ultimately prevail, and the weakest fail, it will, conse- quently, be found that the establishment of distinctly defined species has been due to the preservation of favored individuals by the gradual extinction of those intermediate varieties which do not possess corresponding advantages in structure and in- stinct. In a third and concluding work, this principle of natural selection is to be tested by examining how far it will give a fair explanation of the facts adduced. The evidence of geology will be cited to prove that new species have come in gradually one by one, and that " the succession of many dis- tinct species of the same genus throughout the long series of geological formations seems to have been unbroken or con- tinuous." The development of the present from the past and extinct inhabitants of the world will be shown to be in accord- ance with the theory of descent with modification by means of natural selection ; and it will be urged that the facts 011 which J 868.] D ah win on Variation under Domestication. 1 45 this theory is based " have as yet received no explanation on the theory of independent creations." Whilst the great prin- ciple of inheritance at corresponding periods of life ; the reten- tion of rudimentary and useless parts; and the remarkable fact revealed in embryonic growth of the similarity of members of the same great class in the earlier stages of development?in consequence of which the embryo, for instance, of a mammal, bird, reptile, and fish, is barely distinguishable?can admit of being satisfactorily explained, according to Mr. Darwin, only by the theory of natural selection. The first of the two volumes before us is almost exclusively occupied with illustrations of the extent to which variation under domestication has been observed; and not only has Mr. Darwin exhibited rare power and indefatigable zeal in observing and recording facts, but, moreover, the vast accumulation of evidence which he has gathered from almost every available source is much in favour of his assertion that varieties should be regarded as incipient species. It would be impossible within the limits of our proposed review of this valuable work, to notice the successive variations which have been observed in the different races of animals and plants since they were first do- mesticated by man. Their history is for the most part very defective, and. as regards many of those animals which are known to have been domesticated from a very early period, such as horses, dogs, cattle, sheep, and some other quadrupeds, there are no records of the date at which their subjection began, even in those cases in which the genealogy can be traced, with some degree of probability, to animals at present existing in the wild state; whilst in other cases there is evidence which would lead us to infer that the ancestral type, from which the domesticated varieties have been derived, has become extinct. The history of the horse, for example, is lost in antiquity; and the evidence of its domestication, from remains found in the Swiss lake-dwellings, has been traced with that of the sheep, the pig, and some other animals, as far back as the latter part of the stone period; to which it would, perhaps, be difficult at present to assign a correct date. The observations 011 the domestic varieties of the dog display an extensive acquaintance with the literature of the subject, and are rich in interesting facts, many of which will probably be new to some of his readers. Although fully persuaded that there has been a large amount of variation under domestication, Mr. Darwin is strongly in favour ot the multiple origin of domestic dogs, and he suggests that the larger dogs may be descended from the larger wolves; the smaller and lighter dogs from jackals; and that the slim Abyssinian canis simensis, with H3?xlii. 10 146 Reviews. [July, its elongated muzzle, may be regarded as the origin of the grey- hound. It has been very generally observed that the wolf and the dog in some countries are so closely allied, that it is not unfrequently difficult to distinguish between them; and,although climate and the various external conditions of life, which con-