The Binet-Simon Scale for Measuring Intelligence : Impressions Gained by Its Application upon Four Hundred Non-Selected Children.

Terman LM. · 1911

Read The Binet-Simon Scale for Measuring Intelligence : Impressions Gained by Its Application upon Four Hundred Non-Selected Children. by Terman LM. (1911) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc5147542.txt.

Introduction

Lewis M. Terman reported early impressions of the Binet-Simon intelligence scale in The Psychological Clinic in December 1911. Terman, of Stanford University, with graduate student H. G. Childs, had given the scale to about four hundred unselected children near the university during the previous year.

The trial's chief result, he writes, was conviction: measuring scales of this type are feasible, and once corrected, extended, and multiplied they will carry great practical and theoretical value. That surprised him, after nearly two years with older intelligence tests that had yielded little. He wonders why the scale method, with its age standards, took so long to catch on. Twenty years of single tests had mostly proved fruitless. He also adds criticisms of the scale itself, ahead of a fuller report.

Catalog record

CREATORTerman LM.
YEAR1911
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE18 KB
LICENSEPublic Domain
RIGHTSPUBLIC DOMAIN
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC5147542

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Binet-Simon Scale for Measuring Intelligence 1See also Ayres, Leonard P. The Binet-Simon Measuring Scale for Intelligence: Some Criticisms and Suggestions. The Psychological Clinic, Oct. 15, 1911. By Lewis M. Terman Published in: The Psychological Clinic The Psychological Clinic Copyright, 1911, by Lightner Witmer, Editor. Vol. V, No. 7. December 15, 1911. THE BINET-SIMON SCALE FOR MEASURING INTELLIGENCE.1 Impressions Gained by its Application upon Four Hundred Non-selected Children. By Lewis M. Terman, Ph.D. |/ Stanford University, California. Through the assistance of Mr. H. G. Childs, a graduate student in the Department of Education, Stanford University, the Binet-Simon scale was tried last year upon about four hun- dred children in the vicinity of Stanford University. The com- plete account of this work will not appear until a little later (a series of articles by Terman and Childs) but on invitation of the editor of The Clinic I am glad to contribute to this symposium a few impressions gained from the work, and to add some criticisms of the scale. For the authors of the study by far the most important result was a decided conviction that measuring scales of this general type are feasible, and that when corrected, extended and multi- plied, they will prove of great practical and theoretical value. This outcome was not fully anticipated. I had myself previously spent nearly two years in the use of various "tests of intelligence," from which work, in spite of many items of interest, I could hardly count value received. My present belief is that the field is one that will richly repay any careful and well-directed effort. It is something of a mystery why the scale method in the application of mental tests should not have come into general use long ago. For twenty years numerous experimenters applied tests covering almost every type of mental function. Certain correlations were crudely attempted. Interesting suggestions were made. A few age and grade tendencies were roughly ascertained. But all will admit that, for the most part, the tests were fruitless. ififee also Avres Leonard P. The Blnet-Slmon Measuring Seale fQr lntelllgcHC0; Some Criticisms and Suggestions. The Psychological Clinic, Oct. 15, 1911. (199 ) 200 THE PSYCHOLOGICAL CLINIC. They were either too limited in scope, or failed to utilize non- selected subjects, or else were made under conditions impossible to duplicate. Most fatal of all, the experimentation, instead of being guided by some directing idea like that of definitely establishing age or grade standards, was usually of haphazard nature. Then came Binet with his simple device of arranging the tests in a series of groups, according to their difficulty as determined by age differences in performance. His data were of very limited extent, and rather carelessly elaborated, but the advantages of this procedure are every day becoming more apparent, and are rapidly making possible a clinical child psychology. At the same time it must be admitted that the scale is far too limited in extent, that it is very far from accurate* (at least for average American chil- dren), and that it is improvable at many points. The children tested in our experiment ranged from four to thirteen years of age. The tests were uniformly given, and with careful attention to thoroughness. Without entering here into details, it may be said that the results warrant a far more radical revision of the scale than any one else has hitherto recommended. The scale originally offered by Binet is in general far too easy at the lower end, while in the upper range it is too difficult. In fact, the range of nine years in the actual ages of our subjects was con- densed into a range of only five years of test ages. Besides the frequent displacement up or down the scale, some of the tests are objectionable or unsatisfactory for other reasons. This is par- ticularly true of the thirteen-year group. On the other hand, such tests as the "description of pictures," "omissions from pic- tures," "aesthetic judgment," drawing, "questions of comprehen- sion," memory, reasoning ability, vocabulary and association gave specially satisfactory results. In addition to the trial given to Binet's tests, an attempt was made to extend the scale by securing age standards of perform- ance in four other lines. The latter included, first, a "generaliza- tion test" (interpretation of fables) ; second, a graded "comple- tion test"; third, a vocabulary test of 100 words; and fourth, a tost of "practical judgment" (involving the hunting of a lost ball in a circular field). The authors devised new methods of grading performance for the fable and completion tests which they believe will add much to the serviceableness of both. The vocab- ulary test is based upon Laird and Lee's "Vest Pocket Dictionary," and is, therefore, designed to test the child's acquaintance with the most common concepts of everyday usage, and thus to display THE BINET-SIMON SCALE. 201 grade of intelligence rather than accidents of technical education. It is believed that all of the above four tests will prove usable additions to the scale. The authors have also devised a method for calculating "test age" which they believe is a decided improvement over that used by Binet, a method which gives exactly equal value to all the tests of any year group. The tests of a year group are given a combined value of 1, and the "unit value" of each question in a group is determined by dividing 1 by the number of tests in that group. It is thus possible to retain an unequal number of tests in the different groups without giving undue weight to any one test in the estimation of test age. The following arrangement of the tests shows the main features of the revision which we have tentatively made, and indi- cates the basis upon which the present year's work is being con- ducted. Besides the four additional tests above mentioned we have added to the scale also a test of arithmetical reasoning, a test of "wit," and Goddard's "code" test. It is expected that the work of the present year will make possible some further improve- ments.1 Space is lacking to present in this discussion the rather elaborate directions which we are carefully following in the appli- cation of the scale. Name of Pupil -Name of School Name of Examiner Age of Pupil (years and months) Grade Date of this examination: year month time of day Comments: N.B. Examiner should check all items separately. Yeae III (unit value .1G66). 1. a. "What's the thing to do when you feel sleepy?" b. "What's the thing to do when you feel cold?" 2. Weights:?3-12 6-15 3-12. 3. Naming ob- jects: key closed knife penny 4. Knows sex. 5. Repeats three digits: 641 352 783 6. Pictures (enumerates) 1 2 3 Year IV (unit value .2). 1. Copies square. 2. Counts four pennies. 3. Divided rectangle. 4. Chooses prettier. 1 However, any reader who would like to try this edition of the scale on as many as fifty children may secure a complete set of directions and the necessary record booklets by addressing a letter to me. There will be no expense attached to the same; the only condition Is that I

Read the complete text