A Pseudo-Talent for Words: The Teacher's Report to Dr. Witmer.
Parker SW. · 1917
Read A Pseudo-Talent for Words: The Teacher's Report to Dr. Witmer. by Parker SW. (1917) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc5145060.txt.
Introduction
Sarah Warfield Parker contributed a teacher's case report to The Psychological Clinic in March 1917, part of a series of orthogenic cases reported to Dr. Lightner Witmer. Her subject is Gordon, a boy nearing ten, small and frail for his age, whose gift for words first struck her on a staircase.
Parker heard him singing vaudeville songs with strong rhythm and evident delight in rhyme. She found a child with a courtly manner and a quick memory for verses. It was a talent she calls a pseudo-talent for words. The report describes his appearance, his undersized frame, and his behavior in detail, as part of the clinic's case-study method for children with developmental difficulties. It stands as an example of early clinical writing about a child whose verbal flair outran his other development.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Parker SW. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 1917 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 44 KB |
| LICENSE | Public Domain |
| RIGHTS | PUBLIC DOMAIN |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Pseudo-Talent for Words By Sarah Warfield Parker Published in: The Psychological Clinic The Psychological Clinic Copyright, 1917, by Lightnor Wltmer, Editor. Vol. XI, No. 1 March 15, 1917 ORTHOGENIC CASES.1 XI. A PSEUDO-TALENT FOR WORDS?THE TEACHER'S REPORT TO DR. WITMER. By Sarah Warfield Parker, M.A. Philadelphia, Pa. "In my harem, in my harem! There's Rosie, Posie, Josie." I stopped on the stairs and listened to a high, childish voice beating out the measures with exaggerated accent. "And there never was a minute King Solomon wasn't in it." I turned on the landing and saw a dark, undersized little fellow shuffling, circling about the room with the cr^de rhythmic jerk of knee and hand which enlivens our vaudeville stage. "Wise for breakfast, wise for dinner, And wise for supper time; Lots of fancy dances, And it doesn't cost a dime." He stopped with a laugh of sheer delight in the rhyme of time and dime. 'I looked at Gordon. If I had not known that on his next birthday he would be ten, I should have judged him no more than 1 The following reports of Cases treated by the Orthogenic Method, have appeared: I. A Case of Chronic Bad Spelling. Lightner Witmer. Vol. 1, p. 53. II. The Fifteen Months' Training of a Feebleminded Child. Lightner Witmer. Vol. 1, p. 69. III. Retardation through Neglect in Children of the Rich. Lightner Witmer. Vol. 1, p. 157. IV. The Treatment and Cure of a Case of Mental and Moral Deficiency. Lightner Witmer. Vol. 2, p. 153. V. The Restoration of Children of the Slums. Lightner Witmer. Vol. 3, p. 266. VI. The Irrepressible Ego. Lightner Witmer. Vol. 4, p. 193. VII. Children with Mental Defects Distinguished from Mentally Defective Children. Lightner Witmer. Vol. 7, p. 173. VIII. The Outlook for James. Sarah Warfield Parker. Vol. 10, p. 71. IX. Tom the Enigma. Sarah Warfield Parker. Vol. 10, p. 209. X. A Fettered Mind. Lightner Witmer. Vol. 10, p. 241. (1) 2 THE PSYCHOLOGICAL CLINIC. eight. He was frail and undersized, with legs comparatively short, and long trunk, head, and arms. An unusually heavy mass of coarse, waving brown hair grew down partially to conceal a fore- head so abnormally low as to seem no forehead at all. Even then, with his body all tense, rhythmic movement, I could see how ugly his face was, with its small broad nose and thick lips, partly opened. I could see, too, the somewhat underdeveloped ear set far back and, in the shuffling movement, caught a suggestion of the flat, square foot. Suddenly, he saw me and came forward with a courtly bow and cordially proferred hand that would do credit to the most punctilious of the old time southern gentlemen. I felt his hand in mine? coarse, inert, stubby, with short, blunt fingers, For the moment, he looked almost attractive with his brown eyes sparkling and his cheeks flushed with the animation of the courteous host. "Have you ever been to Savannah?" he asked, bending toward me graciously. But the welcome over, the light died out of his face, and I saw, sitting in the corner, alone, a different Gordon. I saw the pallid, yellow skin of a face that was old, weary beyond any weariness I had ever seen, a face marked with tired, quivering lines, and eye- lids that flickered ceaselessly. Yet again, after supper, he was all animation. "Have you ever heard 'Cavalliera Rusticana' sung by Enrico Caruso?" he asked. As the record was played, he stood directly in front of the graphophone, marking time with head, arms, in fact with rhythmic movement of his whole body. He came back to me, humming, his face a bit perplexed. "What is it I am singing?" "The Toreador," I answered. His face lighted with recognition. "I heard that when I saw the play called Carmen at the theater. Carmen was a lady. This is what she sang," and he hummed again, a few measures from one of Carmen's solos. Gordon's abilities were foremost this first evening?his sense of rhythm, and his audito-motor memory for words and tunes. Only his physical characteristics led one to suspect the disabilities which these concealed. In reality, Gordon, this finished young gentleman of ten with the society manner and the excellent memory, stood very near the zero point in the scale of social efficiency, and as sixteen months of subsequent observation have proved, he is incapable of being trained to even a passable level of such efficiency. Underneath his excessive excitability to a certain few stimuli which interest him, lies an A PSEUDO-TALENT FOR WORDS 3 organism of low vitality and sluggish response to material environ- ment. With the exception of a few charged areas energized for immediate and violent response, his mind is in a state of unperceiv- ing, irresponsive detachment from surroundings. Not inability to do a thing per se, but inability to do it efficiently, is his marked defect in practical performances. lie learned to dress himself but emerges in such a rumpled state that someone must straighten everything he has on. He learned to fold a napkin, to lace a shoe, to tie a bow, but unless coerced, does them wretchedly. He is incapable of putting anything straight, for he lays it down dreamily, scarcely looking. He will always dream across a city street, oblivious of traffic, until he is under the horses' very feet. He will lose himself in the city, for he can wander on for an hour with no consciousness that he has lost his companion. He continually bumps into people, for he never looks where he is walking, and despite his courtesy, does not awake to the situation quickly enough to apologize. He loses everything he carries, even candy for which he has an inordinate passion. He drops everything, spills every- thing, tumbles everything he touches. If his hat blows off, he does not know enough to pick it up. He never pays enough attention to a game to remember his turn or to keep consistently in view the aim of the contest. One season, Gordon was actually energetic enough to coast in the snow, but at the foot of the hill he remained lying on his stomach flat on his sled. Some one told him to get up. "Why?" he asked vaguely. Though his coordination has improved so that it is possible for him to fill in neatly the outlines from the Montessori insets, he does not develop sufficiently sustained attention to boundary and to precision of line to impel him to do the possible. Though he has learned to write in good form, and because of his verbal memory and facile flow of ideas, composes fluently, his penmanship is care- less and smudgy unless he is constantly stimulated. Though by persistent illustration, the concepts which at first were totally lack- ing, of middle, upper, lower, right, left, under, on top of, turn over, flat, straight, etc., have been formed in Gordon's mind, his habitual inattention to position makes him unable to use these concepts without hesitation and indecision. This inability to react effectively to the animate and inanimate objects about him cannot be corrected. Persistent drill can,