The Phenomenon of Scattering in the Binet-Simon Scale.

Wallin JEW. · 1917

Read The Phenomenon of Scattering in the Binet-Simon Scale. by Wallin JEW. (1917) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc5145054.txt.

Introduction

J. E. Wallace Wallin examined score scatter on the Binet-Simon intelligence scale in The Psychological Clinic in 1917. Wallin, of the St. Louis psycho-educational clinic, addresses the claim that children classed as feebleminded develop unevenly, passing some tests above their level while failing easier ones below it.

He quotes Binet and Simon's view that a defective child differs from a normal one in kind, not just degree. That opinion had hardened into a supposed diagnostic sign. Heavy scatter in test scores was taken to mark potential feeblemindedness early. Wallin stresses that the claim rests on personal opinion, with no supporting facts offered, and sets out to test whether such children really scatter more than normal children do.

Catalog record

CREATORWallin JEW.
YEAR1917
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE40 KB
LICENSEPublic Domain
RIGHTSPUBLIC DOMAIN
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC5145054

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Phenomenon of Scattering in the Binet-Simon Scale By J. E. Wallace Wallin Published in: The Psychological Clinic THE PHENOMENON OF SCATTERING IN THE BINET-SIMON SCALE. By J. E. Wallace Wallin, Ph.D., Psycho-Educational Clinic and Special Schools, Board of Education, St. Louis. It has been said that feebleminded children are more uneven in their intellectual development than normal children. According to Binet and Simon1 "a defective child does not resemble in any way a normal one whose development has been retarded or arrested. He is inferior, not in degree, but in kind. The retardation of his development has not been uniform. Obstructed in one direction his development has progressed in others. ... So far as certain faculties are concerned, he remains at the level of a younger child; but in respect to others, he is on a level with normal children of his own age. An unequal and imperfect development is consequently his Specific characteristic. These inequalities of development may Vary to any degree in different subjects. They always produce a want of equilibrium, and this want is the differentiating attribute of the defective." The difference between the feebleminded and the normal is qualitative rather than quantitative. We assume it is on the basis of these sweeping generalizations, which, we are led to conclude, represent merely the personal opinion of the authors as no supporting facts are adduced, that the conclusion has been drawn that the feebleminded "scatter" more in the Binet- Simon scale than do normal children, i. e. they fail on more tests m lower age levels while passing more tests in various age levels above the basal age than do the normals. This alleged fact has almost been given the significance of a pathognomonic sign by which we are able to identify those who are "potentially feeble- minded," and by which we are thus enabled to make an early prog- nosis of feeblemindedness in the case of doubtful children who scatter" considerably, but who cannot be diagnosed as feeble- minded on the basis of the degree of mental deficiency which they evince. Thus we find Doll2 affirming that "In general a normal child develops intellectually more consisently than a potential defective. The component mental processes which determine the intellectual capacity develop uniformly in the former and not so 1 Mentally Defective Children, 1914, p. 13. ?Preliminary Note on tbe Diagnosis of Potential Feeblemindedness, Training School Bulletin, 1916, May. (179) 180 THE PSYCHOLOGICAL CLINIC. uniformly in mental defectives. In the Binet tests the typical normal child has a basal year not more than one year below his chronological age and passes but a few tests beyond his chronological age. The potential feebleminded, on the other hand, has the basal year more than one year below the chronological age or at least seriously below the total mental age rating and may have more than one basal year, that is to say, he 'scatters,' failing in tests one would expect a normal child of that age to pass, and succeeding in others not expected. Thus a normal child 'testing' 8 may have a basal year of 7 and pass 3 tests at 8 and 2 at 9, whereas the potential feebleminded 'testing' 8 may have a basal year of 5, pass 4 tests at 6, 4 at 7, 3 at 8, 2 at 9, and 2 at 10. The normal child thus tests 7.5 and the potential feebleminded 5.15, the total rating in each case being1 8. This brings us to a second premise, namely, that although the individual Binet tests at any age are of equal difficulty for normal children, they are of somewhat unequal difficulty for mental defectives." It is evident that if unevenness in a child's mental development, as indicated by scattering on the Binet-Simon scale, is an indication of potential or actual feeblemindedness, it is worth while determining whether feebleminded children do, in point of fact, "scatter" more than normal children. We do not know that any one has thus far presented any experimental data in support of the correctness of this hypothesis. Doll's conclusions are admittedly tentative: "It is at present only a result of observation that such differences do exist and experiment has too often demonstrated that observa- tion is mistaken." We have ourselves already called attention to the extensive scattering on the Binet-Simon scale by epileptics (which we noted as early as 1910) and by insane subjects.1 From our data which have thus far appeared in print it has not been possible to determine the extent of the excess of scattering found among the epileptics and the insane as compared with other classes of persons. During the last eight years we have occasionally noticed that some feebleminded subjects scatter very widely on the Binet- Simon scale, while other feebleminded subjects scatter very little. We, however, deemed it inadvisable to attempt to compile definite figures until we had a considerable accumulation of data available. We now have records for thousands of subjects whom we have personally examined and diagnosed (with the aid of cooperating physicians), but, owing to the lack of time to work up all our records Experimental Studies of Mental Defectives, 1912, p. 22. Problems of Subnormality, 1917. p. 161f. The Individual Tests in the Binet-Simon Scale, The Psycho1.. Clinic, 1917, p. 79. Wide Range versus Narrow Range Binet-Simon Testing, Journal of Delinquency, 1917, 315f. SCATTERING IN THE BINET-SIMON SCALE. 181 (and the unfortunate circumstance that nearly a thousand of our records are not now accessible to us), we are obliged to limit this study to 840 consecutive1 cases examined in the Psycho-Educational Clinic conducted by the Board of Education in the City of St. Louis. These cases were diagnosed as follows: normal, 5.5 per cent; retarded, 7.9 per cent; backward, 38 per cent; borderline, 12.5 per cent; deferred, 6.4 per cent; and feebleminded, 29.4 per cent (morons, 17.1 per cent and imbeciles 12.2 per cent). The average chrono- logical age of the boys was 11.10 years; of the girls, 10.87; and of both sexes, 11.07. Results. Table I shows the number of advance points which were earned by the pupils in the different classifications. The results differ somewhat according as we follow the 1908 scale or 1911 (Vineland) scale. Turning to the 1908 averages for the two sexes, we find that the smallest number of advance points were won by the pupils designated as normal, followed by the borderline and backward, who earned the same number of points, while the highest number of points were earned by the "deferred" cases (i. e. the diagnosis was deferred because the classification was uncertain) and the morons. The same number of points were earned by the retarded and the imbecile children. The greatest difference in the number of advance points earned is between the normal and the deferred, amounting to .58 of a year. Exclusive of these two categories the greatest difference amounts to one-fifth of a year, or only one point. The difference between the four of the seven .categories which show the smallest differences varies from 0 to .04 of a year, an insignificant amount. The smallest number of advance points among the boys, 1908 scale, was earned by the normal cases,

Read the complete text