Physical and Mental Factors Involved in the Formboard Test.
Young HH. · 1916
Read Physical and Mental Factors Involved in the Formboard Test. by Young HH. (1916) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc5144600.txt.
Introduction
Herman H. Young analyzed the formboard test in The Psychological Clinic in November 1916. Young, psychologist at the Psychopathic Laboratory of the Juvenile Court in Cincinnati, set out a tentative account. It covers the physical and mental factors a child uses when fitting shaped blocks into their holes, against the clock.
Clinicians quoted in the article rank the formboard first among clinical tests. Goddard calls it unmatched for showing a child's condition quickly. Witmer credits it with separating feebleminded children from those of normal intelligence. It also reveals recognition, discrimination, memory, and coordination. Wallin and Norsworthy add form perception, constructive capacity, learning ability, and response to a new situation. Young's analysis aims to sort out which of these many factors the single score actually mixes together.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Young HH. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 1916 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 45 KB |
| LICENSE | Public Domain |
| RIGHTS | PUBLIC DOMAIN |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Physical and Mental Factors Involved in the Formboard Test By Herman H. Young Published in: The Psychological Clinic The Psychological Clinic Copyright, 1916, by Lightner Witmer, Editor. Vol. X, No. 6 November 15, 1916 PHYSICAL AND MENTAL FACTORS INVOLVED IN THE FORMBOARD TEST. By Herman H. Young, Ph.D., Psychologist, Psychopathic Laboratory, Juvenile Court, Cincinnati, Ohio. 1/ The purpose of this discussion is to present a tentative analysis of the various physical and mental factors involved in the per- formance of the formboard test. The existence of these factors places the formboard at the head of the list of clinical tests. That it really holds this exalted position is supported by statements coming from various clinical laboratories. Thus Goddard says, "We have in our laboratory no other test that shows us so much about a child's condition in so short a time as this formboard." (1) Witmer considers the formboard to be first among clinical tests. He may be quoted as follows, "It is one of the best tests for distinguishing the feebleminded from the child of normal intelligence. It very quickly gives the experimenter a general idea of the child's powers of recognition, discrimination, memory, and coordination. Repetition of the experiment often leads to a conclusion as to his ability to learn." (6) Wallin employs the formboard test in determining intellectual status, to throw light upon the patient's ability visually to identify forms, upon his constructive capacity and his power of muscular coordination. (5) Norsworthy con- siders the formboard a test of form perception and rate of movement. She also sought to learn something of the individual's learning capacity and his ability to meet a new situation. (2) Sylvester, in the introduction to his standardization of the formboard, values the test as follows, "It appeals to the child's interest, affording him a short and fascinating task which calls for his best efforts, and it helps to free him from the fear and self-consciousness which often interfere seriously in a mental examination. At the same time the test gives the examiner a good general view of the child's mentality (149) 150 THE PSYCHOLOGICAL CLINIC. and it usually indicates more or less clearly the nature of his defects." (4). The above citations serve two purposes. In the first place they show the general agreement among clinicians as to the value of the formboard as a general diagnostic test. In the second place they name the various functions or capacities which are sought to be explored and tested by different examiners. Perhaps no one quoted above intended to name all the qualities or capacities revealed by the test, but they no doubt did mean to name those which they considered to be most significantly revealed in the performance of the test. The fact that they did not attempt to catalog it as a test of this or that particular mental function or capacity is of more than ordinary importance. It is an indication of the growing tendency to recognize the complexity and interdependence of the mental functions involved in the performance of apparently very simple tests. In addition, it indicates the great need of carefully studying and analyzing the elementary mental qualities involved in the performance of each test as a basis for correctly evaluating the behavior of an individual. Perhaps the chief obstacle to a more rapid analytic develop- ment of tests has been the desire to express results in quantitative terms in order to establish norms for comparative purposes. To accomplish this aim, since only measurements of objects or qualities belonging to the same general class or order can be compared, inves- tigators have been forced to posit and assume that the particular test which they were standardizing tested only one quality, as memory, imagination, form perception, or rate of movement. If, however, the investigator was aware that other factors were involved and not infrequently exerted a powerful, and only somewhat less frequently a dominating influence on the quantitative expression of an individual's record, he failed to give them the prominence and emphasis necessary to prevent others from falling into the error of being content to assume that only one quality is being tested and that its value is adequately expressed in quantitative terms and may be directly compared, in those terms alone, with the results of others. Group comparisons may be justifiable, but even then we are not safe in concluding that this summation which obscures individual- ities insures the measurement of the same quality in different groups. When applied to an individual, a comparison with this narrow outlook is sure to be unjust and misleading. No attempt is made to minimize the value of quantitative measurements and the establishment of norms. That has great value and is an important part of the further development of tests. FACTORS INVOLVED IN FORMBOARD TEST. 151 The emphasis here is on the careful establishment, proper use, and interpretation of norms. Objection is raised against the habit of assuming that figures tell the whole story. They have value only when supplemented by qualifying terms determined by the require- ments of the particular case under consideration. The value of any test is great or small in direct proportion to the examiner's ability carefully to observe, recognize, and analyze the various mental functions, capacities, or limitations revealed by the subject during his performance of the test. To facilitate rating the performance of an individual on the formboard an attempt is here made to include in one chart many of the more elementaly men- tal and physical factors involved. This is not proposed as an exhaustive list. If revision is needed it will be by addition rather than subtraction. Various other peculiarities of habit and mental traits are often revealed, but it has not seemed advisable to carry the list beyond those factors likely to be revealed in the testing of every individual. This list is intended to be suggestive of possi- bilities and aims, to stimulate further and more careful observation, and to induce the examiner to cultivate the habit of analyzing behavior. It is in no way intended to pieclude further and addi- tional observations. To evaluate correctly the performance of a given individual a certain amount of information is necessary. There is (1) a slight but constant sex difference in formboard ability running throughout life, men and boys tending on the whole to do the test quicker than women and girls; and (2) an indirect ratio between age and form- board ability up at least to the age of maturity. Consequently sex is chosen as the primary and age as the secondary basis of classifica- tion. It is possible that there is a closer correlation between physio- logical age and formboard ability than between chronological age and formboard ability, but such classification is impossible at present, because there is no ready means of adequately determining physio- logical development. Although not a part of the established system of classification, it has been found advisable to record the subject's educational or professional standing. After the sex, age, and educational standing of the subject have been obtained, his performance may be compared with the performances of normal subjects of the same sex, age, and educational standing, or