Note on the Causation of Diseases of the Heart and Aorta in Europeans in India.
Megaw JWD. · 1910
Read Note on the Causation of Diseases of the Heart and Aorta in Europeans in India. by Megaw JWD. (1910) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc5140425.txt.
Introduction
J. W. D. Megaw examined what causes heart and aorta disease in Europeans living in India, in The Indian Medical Gazette in March 1910. He analyzed cases from the Calcutta General Hospital, whose patients were mostly Europeans or Eurasians long resident in India, plus newcomers such as sailors.
Megaw warns that the records rarely stated the underlying cause, so he re-read each case's notes and judged the cause himself, accepting that the figures claim no great accuracy. He used two sets: three years of hospital cases and nine months of his own patients, where direct inquiry was possible. The analysis sorts cases into groups such as rheumatic and syphilitic disease, seeking patterns in how heart disease arises under Indian conditions.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Megaw JWD. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 1910 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 16 KB |
| LICENSE | Public Domain |
| RIGHTS | PUBLIC DOMAIN |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Note on the Causation of Diseases of the Heart and Aorta in Europeans in India *Read at the January Meeting of the Medical Section of the Asiatic Society of Bengal. By J. W. D. Megaw Published in: The Indian Medical Gazette Mar., 1910. J CAUSATION OF HEART AND AORTIC DISEASES. 81 riginat Hu'fitles. C note on the causation of diseases OF the heart and aorta in EUROPEANS IN INDIA." By J. W. D. MEGAW, m.b., CAPT., I.M.S., First Surgeon, Presidency General Hospital, Calcutta. The following analysis was made with a view to finding whether the experience of the Calcutta General Hospital would throw any light on the causation of heart disease in India. The major- ity of the patients dealt with are Europeans or Eurasians, who have spent the whole or the greater part of their life in India, but there are 51 good many who have recently c >me to India f?om Europe either as sailors, or to take up work in the country. The figures deal with two sets of enquiries, one set (Series 1) gives an analysis of the cases ?f disease of the heart and aorta recorded as occurring during a period of three years ; these cases were under the care of several medical men, and at the outset of the investigation it became evident that a mere tabulation of the information found in the records would be of little value owing to the fact that the diagnosis tnade did not usually state the serological condi- tions which were responsible for the disease. It was, therefore, necessary to study the notes of each case and form an opinion regarding the etiology of each case from the facts recorded, so that the figures given cannot claim to any great degree of scientific accurac}'. So far as is feasi- ble the possible fallacies connected with the figures will be stated, but making every allow- ance for these there are certain generalizations which can safely be made, which appear to be ?f some importance in connection with the ques- tion under discussion. The second set of figures deals with the cases the same diseases which have come under my Personal ol servation during nine months of the past year, and though the number of cases is much smaller, the figures have the advantage of being the result of a direct enquiry into the Points under investigation. For the sake of clearness only the largest and most important groups of cardiac diseases have been analysed, viz.:? I- Rheumatic Cases.?Originating from the general infection which causes "acute" and ' sub-acute rheumatism " and inflammation of the endo and pericardium. Syphilitic Cases.?Including syphilitic ai'teritis of the aorta and its valves with the Secondary changes resulting therefrom. 3. Myocardial Degenerative Cases.?In which signs of cardiac breakdown have made their appearance for the first time in advancing years, and in which there is 110 history of previous heart disease or of other disease to account for the condition. In the table it will be noted that of 144 eases in the three years' record (Series I) 37 are clearly of rheumatic origin : of these 12 were contracted in India, 21 were contracted in Europe, while 4 are doubtful. But of the cases contracted in India the history made it clear that four suffered from the rheu- matism which was the origin of the disease^ either in Darjeeling or Simla, where the tempera- ture conditions correspond much more closely to those prevailing in Europe than to those found in the plains of India. There are, there- fore, only eight cases contracted in the plains against 25 contracted in Europe and the hills. The group in which there is no clear history of rheumatism, but in which it was considered just possible that the disease may have originated from this cause does not show nearly so marked a preponderance in favour of cold climates as the places of origin, the figures being seven contracted in Europe and seven contracted in the plains of India. My personal view is that most of these doubtful cases were really not rheumatic, but they have been shown in that group to preclude any possibility of an unfair statement of the case. In the rheumatic group there were two cases in which the disease appeared, while the patient was living in the plains and in which there was an active affection of the joints while the patients were in hospital, but there was only one case returned as acute rheumatism during the three years, and in it there was no mention of the heart being affected. There was only one case of chorea during the same period. In the personally investigated series there were 14 cases of rheumatic origin during the nine months, all but three of these having been under mj7 treatment in the waids of the hospi- tal. Of these only four contracted rheumatism in the plains of India. One was a youth of 17, who had suffered from acute rheumatism and chorea in Calcutta at the age of 9, and who is now the subject of marked mitral regurgitation with a slight degree of aortic incompetence, another had a prolonged attack of rheumatism 12 years ago, at the age of 17,* he has now mitral and aortic regurgitation. The other two gave histories of slight rheumatic affections in childhood, but there is no reason to doubt that their cardiac trouble resulted from these attacks. Three cases which I saw quite recently are of some interest, one was a girl of 14, who contracted sub-acute rheumatism in Simla* this had not completely passed off when she was admitted to hospital, and she had also typical rheumatic peri and endocarditis; the second was suffering from a mild attack of chorea the ?5ac}.at the January Meeting of the Medical Section of Slatic Society of Bengal 82 THE INDIAN MEDICAL GAZETTE. [Mar., 1910. which had been contracted in Darjeeling, where she had also suffered from a severe attack of the same disease a year previously ; there was no evidence of cardiac involvement, but in her elder sister who was the third case there was double mitral disease with aortic regurgitation and a history of chorea associated with rheumatism contracted in Darjeeling in early life. During the period there was no case of acute or sub-acute rheumatism which had been con- tracted in the plains of India, but just after the end of the period under analysis there was a case of slight sub-acute rheumatism contracted in Calcutta in December in a man of about 35, in which, however, there is no sign of cardiac involvement. While at the Medical College about three years ago I saw a case of acute rheumatism complicated by endocarditis in a Mahomedan bo}' of nine years old. It seems safe to conclude that rheumatism of the type with which endocarditis is associated does definitely occur in the plains of India, but that it is much less common than in colder climates. There appears to be no evidence that its rarity is due to racial causes, but on the other hand if, as many suspect, the causal organism gains entrance by the tonsils, it is