The Importance of Vibronic Coupling for Efficient Reverse Intersystem Crossing in Thermally Activated Delayed Fluorescence Molecules.
Gibson J, Monkman AP, Penfold TJ. · 2016
Read The Importance of Vibronic Coupling for Efficient Reverse Intersystem Crossing in Thermally Activated Delayed Fluorescence Molecules. by Gibson J, Monkman AP, Penfold TJ. (2016) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc5096030.txt.
Introduction
Jamie Gibson, Andrew P. Monkman, and Thomas J. Penfold reported a theory study in ChemPhysChem in 2016 on molecules for organic light-emitting diodes, or OLEDs. The molecules use thermally activated delayed fluorescence, which recycles dark triplet states into light-giving singlet states. The key step is reverse intersystem crossing, and its speed sets how well devices work.
Using a model that couples electronic states with molecular vibrations, they showed that shaking between two kinds of triplet states opens a strong second route for the crossing step. That route raised the crossing rate by about four orders of magnitude in their model. The finding shifts design advice: instead of only shrinking the energy gap between states, makers should also tune how the molecule's vibrations link its triplet states.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Gibson J, Monkman AP, Penfold TJ. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2016 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 27 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Importance of Vibronic Coupling for Efficient Reverse Intersystem Crossing in Thermally Activated Delayed Fluorescence Molecules By Jamie Gibson, Andrew P. Monkman, Thomas J. Penfold Published in: Chemphyschem DOI: 10.1002/cphc.201600662 ABSTRACT Abstract Factors influencing the rate of reverse intersystem crossing (k rISC) in thermally activated delayed fluorescence (TADF) emitters are critical for improving the efficiency and performance of third‐generation heavy‐metal‐free organic light‐emitting diodes (OLEDs). However, present understanding of the TADF mechanism does not extend far beyond a thermal equilibrium between the lowest singlet and triplet states and consequently research has focused almost exclusively on the energy gap between these two states. Herein, we use a model spin‐vibronic Hamiltonian to reveal the crucial role of non‐Born‐Oppenheimer effects in determining k rISC. We demonstrate that vibronic (nonadiabatic) coupling between the lowest local excitation triplet (3LE) and lowest charge transfer triplet (3CT) opens the possibility for significant second‐order coupling effects and increases k rISC by about four orders of magnitude. Crucially, these simulations reveal the dynamical mechanism for highly efficient TADF and opens design routes that go beyond the Born‐Oppenheimer approximation for the future development of high‐performing systems. The communication between low‐lying singlet and triplet excited states is of great importance in the field of organic electronics and plays a fundamental role in determining key molecular and material properties such as the lifetime and mobility of charge‐separated states.1, 2 Consequently, a thorough understanding of the basic principles governing the interplay between these manifolds of spin states is of great importance, with direct implications for the performance of devices such as organic photovoltaics and organic light‐emitting diodes (OLEDs). For the latter this has particular significance owing to the emergence of thermally activated delayed fluorescence (TADF).3 In OLEDs, electrical excitation of the emitting molecules generates, through spin statistics, a 3:1 ratio of triplet and singlet excited states. Therefore, efficient devices call for an effective mechanism for harvesting the triplet states, which in fluorescence molecules are simply lost to non‐radiative processes. Presently, the most popular approach is to exploit the large spin orbit coupling constant of iridium complexes to harvest the triplet population by phosphorescence.4 However, as iridium is the fourth most scarce naturally occurring element on earth, it is unsustainable to base large‐scale high‐volume industries, such as lighting, on this resource. Adachi and co‐workers7, 8 recently demonstrated the effectiveness of the TADF approach for third‐generation heavy‐metal‐free OLEDs. This harvests the triplet excited states by exploiting thermal energy to drive population transfer from the triplet to the singlet states so that they can emit as singlet states via delayed fluorescence. These systems can therefore achieve a high luminescence quantum yield using only organic molecules. Adopting the predictions of Beens and Weller,9 Adachi and co‐workers demonstrated that TADF emitters could be constructed using charge‐transfer (CT) complexes, which exhibit a negligible gap between the singlet and triplet states due to the small exchange energy splitting.10, 11 This approach has subsequently been exploited12 to achieve efficient OLEDs with 100 % internal quantum efficiency and >30 % external quantum efficiency.13 Despite the intense research interest and obvious promise of TADF materials, it is astounding that the reverse intersystem crossing (rISC) process, crucial to TADF is not fully understood. This absence is important for achieving rational material design and especially given the widening scope of TADF in applications such as fluorescence imaging.14 One of the first reports of TADF was by Parker et al.15 The authors rationalised their findings in terms of a thermal equilibrium between the lowest singlet and triplet states [Eq. (1)]:(1)K=[S1][T1]=krISCkISC=13exp(-ΔES1-T1/kbT) making it possible to calculate the rate of the whole TADF process (k TADF), that is, rISC proceeded by fluorescence as [Eq. (2)]:(2)kTADF=13kfexp(-ΔES1-T1/kbT) This approach, adopted by Adachi and co‐workers, defines the TADF equilibrium as depending exclusively on the energy gap between the singlet and triplet states and crucially, as shown in Equation (1), independent of the coupling between them, that is, k ISC and k rISC, provided it is not zero. This strongly motivates design procedures that focus upon minimising this energy gap using CT states and suppressing larger amplitude molecular vibrations to reduce non‐radiative pathways.16 However, the key assumption in this equilibrium description, that is, k ISC and k rISC≫k f must be broken to support new emitters with stronger fluorescence yields. Within this regime, TADF is cast in terms of a kinetic process,17 which in the long time limit, assuming non radiative and phosphorescence channels are small can be expressed as [Eqs. (3a) and (3)]:(3)dS1dt=-kf[S1]+krISC[T1] (4)dT1dt=-krISC[T1] Solving Equations (3a) and (3b) yields Equations (4a) and (5):(5)T1(t)=T1(0)exp(-krISCt) (6)S1(t)=krISCkf-krISCT1(0)exp(-krISCt) where T 1(0) is the population of the triplet states at t=0, S 1(t) and T 1(t) are the time‐dependent populations of the emitting singlet and triplet states, respectively. This shows that k rISC is crucial in determining the effectiveness of TADF. It is also important within a device context for the roll‐off efficiency of TADF OLEDs.18 Further supporting the breakdown of the thermal equilibrium representation, Ward et al.19 recently showed that different D–A–D molecules with very similar energy gaps (ΔE S1-T1 ) exhibit large variations in k rISC. They found that by sterically hindering the motion of D and A group, the emission can be switched from TADF to phosphorescence. This effect cannot be explained within present models for TADF and is indicative of a mechanism which is dynamic in nature, in the sense that it depends on molecular vibrations. Another aspect that remains unclear is the coupling responsible for the rISC. Spin orbit coupling (SOC) between 1CT and 3CT of D–A complexes is forbidden.20 It is therefore unlikely for the 1CT state to harvest the population of the 3CT states via rISC directly, especially in view of the large k rISC≈107 s−1 reported.21, 22 Alternatively Ogiwara et al.23 used electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy to propose that rISC is driven by hyperfine coupling induced ISC. This mechanism arises from interactions between an electron′s spin and the magnetic nuclei of its molecule. It is therefore completely local and not quenched by significant electron‐hole separation experienced in CT states like SOC.24 However, the hyperfine coupling constants are very small, usually in the range of 10−4 meV, and it therefore also appears highly unlikely that such coupling accounts for these recent observations. Recently, D–A and D–A–D molecular TADF systems19, 21, 25 have demonstrated that two of the excited states involved in the rISC step can be independently tuned. They must therefore be of different character and a 1CT and local excitonic triplet (3LE) pair appears most likely. Indeed, SOC between these two sets of states will be allowed. Two theoretical papers have recently discussed the influence of multiple excited states and vibrational motion on TADF.26, 27 Firstly, Chen et al.26 used Fermi′s Golden Rule to calculate the rate of rISC occurring via SOC. They found that their calculated value differed significantly from experimental values, even for the 1CT→3LE transition. They subsequently postulated that for D–A–D systems this deviation occurs due to an absence of nonadiabatic effects between the low‐lying excited states involved in the upconversion. Marian27 then used multi‐reference quantum chemistry methods to show, in agreement with ref. 26 that direct SOC was indeed too small to explain efficient rISC. Instead Marian proposed that it is mediated by