Rodent models in neuroscience research: is it a rat race?

Ellenbroek B, Youn J. · 2016

Read Rodent models in neuroscience research: is it a rat race? by Ellenbroek B, Youn J. (2016) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc5087838.txt.

Introduction

Bart Ellenbroek and Jiun Youn ask whether neuroscience picked the wrong rodent, in Disease Models and Mechanisms in 2016. Rats led biomedical research for a century, but over two decades mice took over, rising from about a fifth of neuroscience studies in the 1970s to about half in recent years. The cause was tools: mice got gene-editing and stem cell methods first, starting with the first knockout mouse in 1987.

Now rat genome tools, from chemical mutagenesis and zinc-finger nucleases to CRISPR, are closing the gap. That makes the real differences between the species worth weighing again: size, physiology, drug handling, and behaviour all diverge, and strains differ within each species too. The authors, writing with an accompanying poster, focus on brain and psychiatric disease models. Their advice is to choose the animal by the question, not by habit, now that the technical excuse for always choosing mice is fading.

Catalog record

CREATOREllenbroek B, Youn J.
YEAR2016
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE67 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC5087838

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Rodent models in neuroscience research: is it a rat race? By Bart Ellenbroek, Jiun Youn Published in: Disease Models & Mechanisms DOI: 10.1242/dmm.026120 ABSTRACT ABSTRACT Rodents (especially Mus musculus and Rattus norvegicus) have been the most widely used models in biomedical research for many years. A notable shift has taken place over the last two decades, with mice taking a more and more prominent role in biomedical science compared to rats. This shift was primarily instigated by the availability of a much larger genetic toolbox for mice, particularly embryonic-stem-cell-based targeting technology for gene disruption. With the recent emergence of tools for altering the rat genome, notably genome-editing technologies, the technological gap between the two organisms is closing, and it is becoming more important to consider the physiological, anatomical, biochemical and pharmacological differences between rats and mice when choosing the right model system for a specific biological question. The aim of this short review and accompanying poster is to highlight some of the most important differences, and to discuss their impact on studies of human diseases, with a special focus on neuropsychiatric disorders. INTRODUCTION Rats and mice have been the leading model organisms used in biomedical research for well over a century, although other animals, such as non-human primates, zebrafish, fruit flies and roundworms, are also used. However, in recent years a shift in rodent-based research has taken place, with mice rapidly overtaking rats as the major model of choice in biological research. Accordingly, there has been a shift in the proportion of neuroscience-related research using mice from about 20% in the 1970s and 1980s to around 50% in recent years (see poster, panel 1). This shift in preference is likely to be related to the availability of techniques for genetic manipulation of mice, and temporally coincides with the publication of the first knockout mouse in 1987 (Thomas and Capecchi, 1987). Although lagging behind that of mice (see poster, panel 2), the genetic toolbox for rats is now rapidly filling up, with the introduction of N-ethyl-N-nitrosourea (ENU) mutagenesis (Zan et al., 2003), zinc-finger nucleases (Geurts et al., 2010), homologous recombination (Tong et al., 2011) and, most recently, clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats (CRISPR)/Cas-mediated genome editing (Shao et al., 2014). Together with the elucidation of the complete genome of the rat more than a decade ago (Gibbs et al., 2004) and ongoing functional annotation of the genome (data are collected, consolidated and integrated at the Rat Genome Database; see Shimoyama et al., 2016), these advances in technology will likely lead to a rapid increase in genetic rat models as well. This leads to the inevitable question of whether there is a purpose in generating rat models where mouse models are already available. If these two rodents are more or less identical, it would be pointless, and unethical, to replicate the findings in one organism in the other without a valid reason. However, based on a large body of evidence, rats are not simply ‘big mice’ and, although similar in many aspects, there are fundamental differences between these rodents. Indeed, it has long been recognized that, especially in neuroscience and behavioural research, rats have a number of clear advantages, such as the relatively large size of their brains, which makes brain surgery much easier (see poster, panel 3). Rats are also much easier to handle than mice and less easily stressed by human contact. In fact, repeatedly handling rats prior to a behavioural experiment is a routine practice, whereas this procedure in mice often induces more stress in the animal (Meijer et al., 2007). In this At a Glance poster review, we will highlight the major differences between mice and rats that could impact on neuroscience research. We begin by discussing the evolution of these organisms, and then detail some basic differences between rats and mice. We then discuss how these differences impact on technical considerations, social, addictive, impulsive and cognitive behaviours, and studies of neurodegenerative disorders. Overall, we aim to show that rats and mice both have an important role to play in understanding the aetiology, pathophysiology and pharmacology of neuropsychiatric diseases, and that a careful examination of both organisms is necessary before a choice of model for a translational study can be made. [Figure: A high-resolution version of the poster is available for downloading at http://dmm.biologists.org/lookup/doi/10.1242/dmm.026120.supplemental.] EVOLUTIONARY DIVERGENCE OF RATS AND MICE Rats and mice belong to the order Rodentia, which, with over 2200 species, is by far the largest order within the class Mammalia (Wilson and Reeder, 2005). Within the Rodentia, the Muridae constitutes the largest family, with about 700 species, including the Old World rats and mice (rodents found in Eurasia, Africa or Australia, grouped together in the sub-family of the Murinae) (Wilson and Reeder, 2005). Of these, strains derived from Mus musculus and Rattus norvegicus are used in the overwhelming majority of animal research for biomedical purposes. Thus, in the remainder of this article, when we refer to ‘species differences’, we refer specifically to differences between these two species. The degree of evolutionary divergence between rats and mice has been hotly debated, especially because estimates of the most recent common ancestor (MRCA) originally led to rather different results depending on the methodology used. Paleontological studies indicated that the MRCA existed 15- to 20-million years ago (mya) (Jaeger et al., 1986), whereas estimates of 27 and even 42 mya were given based on molecular clock data (Huchon et al., 2000; Kumar and Hedges, 1998). The molecular clock technique uses the mutation rate of DNA to deduce when two species have diverged and therefore assumes that mutation rates are constant. However, it has been suggested that murids have higher than normal mutation rates, which would lead to an apparent ‘slowing’ of the molecular clock (because mutations occur faster than in other species). Using complex modelling, and taking the different mutational rates of rats and mice into account, more recent studies estimate the MRCA of rats and mice to have lived about 15-20 mya (Adkins et al., 2001; Steppan et al., 2004) (in line with paleontological data), roughly in the same range as the separation between the macaque monkeys and the great apes, including Homo sapiens (Zhou et al., 2014). It follows that the genetic distance between rats and mice is quite substantial and, consequently, it can be assumed that the functional differences, both at the molecular and behavioural level, are equally large. Differential expression of genes in the mouse and rat brains was recently investigated in two of the most often used rodent models (especially in the neuroscience field), namely the Sprague Dawley rat and C57BL/6 mice (Francis et al., 2014). Using microarray-based analysis, the authors found that 4713 out of a total of 10,833 genes were differentially expressed in the dendrites of hippocampal neurons between rats and mice. By comparison, only 54 genes were differentially expressed between two different, often-used, mouse strains (C57BL/6 and Balb/c). Considering the importance of the hippocampus in behaviour (especially memory), this finding is relevant in understanding the species differences in many cognitive tests, as discussed below. Intriguingly, the authors also compared other tissues (including heart, skeletal muscle, intestines etc.) between rats and mice, and, although differences in these tissues were also substantial, they

Read the complete text