Implementation, context and complexity.
May CR, Johnson M, Finch T. · 2016
Read Implementation, context and complexity. by May CR, Johnson M, Finch T. (2016) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc5069794.txt.
Introduction
Carl R. May, Mark Johnson, and Tracy Finch tackle the problem of context in implementation science in Implementation Science in 2016. Trials often strip away real-world settings to isolate an intervention, yet those settings are exactly where a new practice must survive. Building on their Normalisation Process Theory, the authors offer an ecological model of how people and contexts shape each other while a practice is put in place and spread.
Implementation, in their account, runs through resource mobilisation, collective action, and constant negotiation with context, and these mechanisms adapt as they go. Outcomes hinge on how flexible the intervention's parts are, how much discretion participants have, and how elastic the context proves. Feedback loops and practical compromise, in this view, are the machinery of self-organisation, not noise. The model also warns that rigid trial designs may misjudge interventions built for dynamic settings, a point they plan to develop.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | May CR, Johnson M, Finch T. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2016 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 62 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Implementation, context and complexity By Carl R. May, Mark Johnson, Tracy Finch Published in: Implementation Science : IS DOI: 10.1186/s13012-016-0506-3 ABSTRACT Background Context is a problem in research on health behaviour change, knowledge translation, practice implementation and health improvement. This is because many intervention and evaluation designs seek to eliminate contextual confounders, when these represent the normal conditions into which interventions must be integrated if they are to be workable in practice. Discussion We present an ecological model of the ways that participants in implementation and health improvement processes interact with contexts. The paper addresses the problem of context as it affects processes of implementation, scaling up and diffusion of interventions. We extend our earlier work to develop Normalisation Process Theory and show how these processes involve interactions between mechanisms of resource mobilisation, collective action and negotiations with context. These mechanisms are adaptive. They contribute to self-organisation in complex adaptive systems. Conclusion Implementation includes the translational efforts that take healthcare interventions beyond the closed systems of evaluation studies into the open systems of ‘real world’ contexts. The outcome of these processes depends on interactions and negotiations between their participants and contexts. In these negotiations, the plasticity of intervention components, the degree of participants’ discretion over resource mobilisation and actors’ contributions, and the elasticity of contexts, all play important parts. Understanding these processes in terms of feedback loops, adaptive mechanisms and the practical compromises that stem from them enables us to see the mechanisms specified by NPT as core elements of self-organisation in complex systems. BACKGROUND Context is a problem for implementation science. Researchers in the field have sought to identify, characterise and explain the mechanisms implicated in individual behaviour change and collective action for many years. They have sought to develop theoretical models and empirical research instruments, as well as practical toolkits that foster the implementation of innovations in practice. Against this background, context is an important practical problem for complex intervention and implementation trials. These are driven by a model of research that aims to show the operation of causal mechanisms, eliminate confounders and measure outcomes. The conceptual division between an intervention and its environment that is an inevitable consequence of trial design means that contexts are often framed as sources of obduracy and interference with the smooth delivery of the trial. Attempts to understand the dynamics of implementation and to evaluate their effects are either front-loaded into clinical trials in the form of programme theories that specify their expected mode of operation and outcomes or revealed in retrospective ‘process’ evaluations of activity over time and the effects of this activity on outcomes [1, 2]. This means that implementation theory and empirical research are skewed in favour of the beginnings of implementation-integration journeys. Longitudinal studies that specifically investigate sustainability and scaling up, and that focus on implementation processes, are rare. We thus know rather less than we should about the mechanisms involved in adaptation and sustainability over time. There is, however, a substantial literature on aspects of context, relevant to implementation research. It draws attention to factors that play out as ‘barriers and facilitators’ to specific interventions ranging from improving hand-washing in hospital [3]; pain management [4]; shared decision-making about treatment [5] and management of the end of life [6]. The problem for implementation science, however, is that contextual ‘confounders’ that act in this way in fact constitute the normal conditions of practice and are rarely taken into account in that form. As reviews by Lau et al. [7, 8] have shown, changes in policy direction, organisational turbulence and the exigencies of everyday work in complex healthcare settings, all affect implementation processes. Such problems are also consistently shown to be centrally important in studies informed by psychological theories [9]. Future studies will reveal taxonomies of the contextual factors at work in implementation processes [10, 11]. However, we can think differently now about the place of context in implementation research. Contexts are dynamic: contextual factors that might constitute barriers to implementation in one place may facilitate it in others. Understanding how this happens will, in turn, help us to understand two key problems: how implementation processes may lead to ‘scaling up’ (changes in state over time, characterised by increasing the volume of activity in a social system) and how they may lead to ‘scaling out’ (changes in state across space, characterised by diffusion or spread between settings). They may also help us to both understand how some interventions fail to ‘stick’ in everyday practice settings and why it is so difficult to de-normalise already embedded practices. These are important problems in implementation research [12–14]. These are not just problems in trials. They extend across policy-led interventions too. Changes in the organisation of clinical work in surgery [15, 16], the delivery of telemedicine systems at scale [17, 18] and the scaling out and spread of new health technologies [19, 20], all provide evidence of the role of environmental mechanisms in shaping interventions. Purpose of this paper Our aim in this paper is to develop and extend Normalisation Process Theory (NPT), to address the problem of context in implementation research. We locate the place of this paper in the development of NPT in Table 1, and define key terms in Table 2, showing how work to develop NPT began by asking what factors promote or inhibit the routine incorporation of complex interventions in everyday work [21, 22] and then moved on to develop a generic theory of implementation [23, 24]. More recently, NPT has engaged with the problem of dynamic elements of context as both the sources of resources that can be mobilised by participants in implementation processes [25] and as sources of turbulence that affect their course and direction [26]. At each stage in the development of NPT, we have been concerned with its utility as a way of understanding the dynamics of complex intervention trials [27–29]. In this paper, we extend NPT by engaging with ideas about complex adaptive systems. This will help us to better understand factors that affect implementation processes not just as part of highly controlled and structured complex intervention trials but also as larger scale implementation processes that sit outside of structured and protocol-driven projects. The paper has four objectives.Table 1Development of Normalisation Process TheoryTheoretical focusTheoretical contentResearch questionsEmpirical focus1 Users’ interactions with objects in implementation processes (2006)Analysis of mechanisms of collective action (interactional workability, relational integration, skill set workability, contextual integration) [22, 23].What factors promote or inhibit the routine incorporation of complex interventions in practice? How do they affect implementation processes and outcomes?How complex interventions are operationalised by their users.2 Agency within implementation processes (2009)Analysis of mechanisms of agents’ contributions to implementation processes (sense-making, cognitive participation, collective action, reflexive monitoring) [24, 25].What factors promote or inhibit the implementation, embedding and integration of practices? How do they affect implementation processes and outcomes?The work people do when they implement a new technique, technology or organisational intervention.3 Resource mobilisation in implementation processes (2013)Analysis of social structural resources (roles, rules, norms and material resources) and social cognitive resources (potential and commitment) available to agents as they invest in implementation [26, 27].What factors promote or inhibit the mobilisation of structural and cognitive resources for implementation? How do they affect implementation processes