Chemical proteomics approaches for identifying the cellular targets of natural products.

Wright MH, Sieber SA. · 2016

Read Chemical proteomics approaches for identifying the cellular targets of natural products. by Wright MH, Sieber SA. (2016) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc5063044.txt.

Introduction

M. H. Wright and S. A. Sieber review chemical proteomics for natural product targets in Natural Product Reports in 2016. Natural products inspired many drugs, but when one changes a living cell, finding which proteins it actually touches is hard. Chemical proteomics answers with tailor-made probes: a product is fitted with a handle that lets researchers fish out its protein partners from living cells and name them.

The review surveys the last five years of probe designs, from light-activated traps to two-step tagging done after the probe has found its mark inside the cell. Working in living cells at natural protein levels is the field's strength, and dose and competition tests can even measure binding strength in place. The authors then face the weaknesses head-on: probes that stick to many proteins, background noise, and handles that change how the product behaves, with practical fixes for each.

Catalog record

CREATORWright MH, Sieber SA.
YEAR2016
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE118 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC5063044

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Chemical proteomics approaches for identifying the cellular targets of natural products By M H Wright, S A Sieber Published in: Natural Product Reports DOI: 10.1039/c6np00001k ABSTRACT This review focuses on chemical probes to identify the protein binding partners of natural products in living systems. INTRODUCTION Natural products (NPs) have always been the inspiration for the development of drugs and a source of tools to elucidate cellular mechanisms. Drug discovery typically takes one of two approaches: a target-based approach, where a compound is developed to target a particular enzyme, and phenotypic screening, where libraries of small molecules are screened against live cells with a phenotypic read-out. A target-based approach has the advantages that mode of action is, in principle, known right from the outset, enzyme assays are typically reliable and easy to perform, and compound design is often aided by structural biology. Phenotypic screening, on the other hand, already takes issues such as cell uptake and efflux into account, and non-specific cytotoxicity is more easily assessed. For the phenotypic approach in particular, it is very challenging to discover and validate the mode of action of a compound. An added complexity is that compounds may have different modes of action in different organisms or contexts, or may have pleiotropic effects. Chemical proteomics is a rapidly evolving area of chemical biology that draws on synthetic chemistry to generate probes that inform on small molecule mode of action and protein function. In the context of understanding the mode of action of NPs and other small molecules, chemical proteomics primarily provides information on the proteins a compound interacts with. Chemical proteomic strategies for NP target identification were reviewed in 2010 (ref. 1 and 2) and several reviews since have touched on the different approaches for target identification, of natural products, drugs and other molecules of interest.3–5 Here we aim to survey and analyse studies from the last five years on chemical proteomics technologies for mode of action, focusing on the following aspects: natural products, ‘discovery’ chemical proteomics (i.e. where the mode of action and binding partner of the NP is unknown at the outset), in situ approaches using covalent or photoprobes, two-step labelling protocols that exploit bioorthogonal ligation chemistry, and finally the advantage that can be taken of recent advances in quantitative mass spectrometry-based proteomics methods. We define ‘in situ’ chemical proteomics as labelling with a ‘free’ probe in living cells, to distinguish it from classical affinity chromatography (where lysates are incubated with resin functionalised with the NP of interest and binding partners retained, whilst non-binders are washed away), or incubation of cell lysates with probes. Whilst affinity chromatography has been widely and, in some cases, very successfully applied for target identification, it suffers from several disadvantages: weak but true binders are often missed (false negatives), the in vitro setting is more artificial than applying a probe in live cells (and therefore potentially prone to false positives), and the ‘modification’ to the probe is large and may perturb protein binding. Incubation of a free probe with lysates avoids some of these issues but not the artificial setting; approaches that apply a probe in situ have the significant advantage of being more biologically relevant. However, it is generally accepted that in order to be used in situ, the probe should be functionalised to covalently link with binding partners. This can be accomplished by incorporating either an intrinsically chemically reactive group or a photoreactive group within the probe structure. We will first cover some general points on probe design, validation and chemical proteomics workflows. The second part of the review covers recent case studies and we conclude with a discussion on the advantages, limitations and challenges of these approaches. Two-step activity and affinity-based protein profiling 1.1. Chemical proteomics and bioorthogonal ligation chemistry 1.1.1. In situ chemical proteomics approaches take a small molecule of interest and create a probe by functionalising it with (1) a tag that will allow downstream analysis and, if necessary, (2) a handle to stabilise the interaction between the molecule and its protein binding partner (Fig. 1). This second handle could be a photoreactive or intrinsically chemically reactive moiety. In some cases it is possible to directly attach a fluorophore or biotin affinity group in place of the tag; however, a two-step tag-then-capture approach is becoming increasingly popular. Two-step methods take advantage of bioorthogonal ligations, highly chemoselective reactions that take place under physiological conditions between two partners – probe-bound protein and fluorophore for example – in high yields and with high specificity.6 These reactions enable the tag incorporated into the molecule of interest to be very small: for example, a terminal alkyne, azide or cyclopropene. This approach minimises the alteration to the structure of the small molecule and therefore reduces the chances that such functionalisation will perturb binding to the target protein, as well as preserving as much as possible physicochemical properties so that cellular uptake is relatively unaffected and the probe can be applied in the context of a live cell. The most widely used bioorthogonal ligation is the copper-catalysed azide–alkyne cycloaddition reaction (CuAAC) between an alkyne and azide.7,8 These two functional groups are relatively easy to introduce synthetically, small, inert in biological contexts and the reaction is robust. The main disadvantage of CuAAC is that it is limited, largely, to use in lysates and fixed cells because the copper catalyst is toxic. However, for most identification strategies such toxicity is not a problem: the probe is applied in live cells (‘in situ’), the cells lysed and CuAAC carried out in lysate. CuAAC also denatures and, sometimes, causes protein aggregation and precipitation, which may make it incompatible with some downstream applications, although some efforts have been made to optimise reagents to reduce this effect.9 Two-step protocols also allow the type of label introduced to be easily varied; for example, a biotin or FLAG group can be introduced for affinity enrichment of tagged proteins and subsequent identification by standard proteomic workflows, or a fluorophore can be attached for visualisation in SDS-PAGE gels or for imaging in cells (Fig. 1). Alkynes have emerged as preferred tags due to their small size and the empirical observation that having the azide on the labelling partner during CuAAC sometimes results in lower background.10–12 It is worth noting that removing excess probe can sometimes be important for efficiency of CuAAC and can be accomplished by washing cells or precipitating lysates. More importantly, unreacted CuAAC labelling reagent must usually be removed before affinity enrichment analysis, since excess reagent can bind to the beads and prevent efficient pull-down of labelled proteins. This introduces an extra clean-up step, usually protein precipitation, and any additional steps in a complex workflow can introduce variability. Therefore, in some cases, direct labelling may have advantages: for example, in labelling of secreted proteins, where cell permeability of probes is less of a concern. Due to its wide applicability compared to other bioorthogonal ligations, we will focus here on CuAAC approaches for NP target identification. [Figure: Compound-centric chemical proteomics approach for identifying the targets of natural products (NPs). The probe is designed based on the structure of the NP, is added to live cells and binds to its target protein. It reacts covalently (via an electrophilic trap or

Read the complete text