A Guide to Fluorescent Protein FRET Pairs.

Bajar BT, Wang ES, Zhang S, Lin MZ, Chu J. · 2016

Read A Guide to Fluorescent Protein FRET Pairs. by Bajar BT, Wang ES, Zhang S, Lin MZ, Chu J. (2016) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc5038762.txt.

Introduction

Bryce T. Bajar and seven co-authors guide readers through fluorescent protein FRET pairs in Sensors in 2016. FRET is an energy hand-off between two glowing proteins placed very close together, and it fades fast as the gap grows, which makes it a ruler for changes inside living cells. Sensors built on FRET watch proteins meet, change shape, and switch on, all without harming the cell.

The guide explains the main ways to measure FRET and then walks the palette of protein pairs, weighing brightness, stability, and color for each. Some pairs change strongly but glow dimly, others the reverse, so the choice must fit the job. The authors give special weight to the size of the signal swing when the event is brief or subtle. Their closing picks flag the pairs with the widest swings known and point to brighter proteins as seeds for better pairs.

Catalog record

CREATORBajar BT, Wang ES, Zhang S, Lin MZ, Chu J.
YEAR2016
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE77 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC5038762

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A Guide to Fluorescent Protein FRET Pairs By Bryce T. Bajar, Emily S. Wang, Shu Zhang, Michael Z. Lin, Jun Chu, Niko Hildebrandt, Igor Medintz, Russ Algar Published in: Sensors (Basel, Switzerland) DOI: 10.3390/s16091488 ABSTRACT Förster or fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) technology and genetically encoded FRET biosensors provide a powerful tool for visualizing signaling molecules in live cells with high spatiotemporal resolution. Fluorescent proteins (FPs) are most commonly used as both donor and acceptor fluorophores in FRET biosensors, especially since FPs are genetically encodable and live-cell compatible. In this review, we will provide an overview of methods to measure FRET changes in biological contexts, discuss the palette of FP FRET pairs developed and their relative strengths and weaknesses, and note important factors to consider when using FPs for FRET studies. 1. INTRODUCTION Förster or fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET), first described by Theodor Förster in 1946, is a physical phenomenon in which a donor fluorophore in its excited state non-radiatively transfers its excitation energy to a neighboring acceptor fluorophore, thereby causing the acceptor to emit its characteristic fluorescence [1]. Since FRET is highly sensitive to the distance between donor and acceptor dipoles within the 1–10 nm range, FRET-based biosensors, composed of fluorophores and sensing domains, have been widely adopted as spectroscopic rulers to monitor a variety of biochemical activities that produce changes in molecular proximity, such as protein–protein interactions, conformational changes, intracellular ion concentrations, and enzyme activities [2,3]. An advantage of FRET biosensing over biochemical assays is that it is performed optically, enabling interrogation of live cells in a non-destructive and minimally invasive way [3]. Depending on whether the two fluorophores are conjoined to the same molecule, FRET biosensors can be classified into two categories: (1) intramolecular type, in which donor and acceptor fluorophores are conjoined to the same molecule, whereby conformational changes in the molecule induce FRET changes; and (2) intermolecular type, in which donor and acceptor fluorophores are fused to different molecules, and FRET changes occur when the independent molecules come into close proximity [3] (Figure 1C). In all FRET biosensors, choosing optimal FRET pairs (donor and acceptor fluorophores) are key to the high performance of biosensors in living cells [4]. Three main types of fluorophores have been used as FRET pairs in FRET biosensors: small organic dyes, fluorescent proteins (FPs), and quantum dots (QDs). Unlike dyes and QDs, FPs are genetically encoded and can be particularly useful in live cell FRET imaging. First, FP-based FRET sensors are easily constructed by simply fusing FPs to sensing domains via genetic engineering. In contrast, dyes and QDs do not have the ability to label sensing domains without the aid of antibodies [5], which limits the number of sensors that can be made. Second, FPs confer high cellular specificity by using tissue-specific promoters, and also have high subcellular specificity through introduction of subcellular targeting sequences, which enables FRET probes to report activity solely in cell types of interest or subcellular regions of interest. Third, FP-based FRET sensors can be readily introduced into cells in vitro and in vivo through transfection or virus infection, whereas introducing dye- or QD-based FRET biosensors into cells has been challenging. Fourth, dye- and QD-based sensors are not stable in living cells and can be quickly cleared away from the body in vivo [5]. However, FP-based FRET sensors are stable in cells for long time due to high intracellular stability of FPs. For example, EGFP has a half-life time of greater than 24 h in cells [6]. Lastly, stable cell lines expressing FRET biosensors are easily achievable in the presence of antibiotic pressure, which reduces cell-cell viability in FRET imaging and facilitates high-throughput drug screening [7]. Indeed, the variety of engineered FPs with improved optical properties has made it possible to tailor FPs for FRET pairs with high FRET efficiency and develop highly sensitive FRET biosensors. In this review, we first discuss the means to measure FRET efficiency and dynamic range. Next, we examine commonly used and recently developed FP FRET pairs and their respective applications, advantages, and disadvantages. Finally, we explore important photophysical considerations when selecting FP FRET pairs, as well as future perspectives on new FP FRET pairs for FRET biosensors. 2. FRET EFFICIENCY, FRET DYNAMIC RANGE AND FRET MEASUREMENT FRET occurs between two fluorophores in close proximity with substantial overlap (>30%) between the donor’s emission and acceptor’s absorption spectra [8] and is characterized by FRET efficiency (E). FRET E refers to the percent of energy transfer from the donor to acceptor fluorophores at a given state and is quantitatively described in the two following equations: (1)E=1/(1+r6/r06) (2)r0=0.02108(κ2ϕDn−4(∫0∞fD(λ)εA(λ)λ4dλ))1/6 (in nm) where r is the distance between donor and acceptor dipoles; r0 is the distance at which the FRET E is 50%; and κ2 is the interdipole orientation factor (assumed to be 2/3 corresponding to a random orientation). Note that the dynamic average assumption that κ2 for FPs is 2/3 is not appropriate because autofluorescent FPs do not undergo much rotational diffusion (15–20 ns) during the short excited state lifetime (<5.1 ns) because of their relatively large molecular weights (27 kDa) [9]. However, the exact κ2 value for FPs is unknown. Using other values of κ2 will change the magnitude of r0, but the trends between the different FP pairs will remain the same [10]. Thus far, the Förster radii (r0) for FP FRET pairs are based on κ2 of 2/3 in almost all FP FRET papers. To make all FP FRET pairs comparable, κ2 of 2/3 is still used in this paper just to show the difference of r0s from different FP pairs; n is the refractive index of the medium surrounding the fluorophores; φD is the quantum yield (QY) of the donor in absence of the acceptor; fD(λ) is the (wavelength dependent) corrected donor fluorescence intensity at wavelength λ with the total intensity (area under the curve) normalized to unity and is dimensionless; εA is the (wavelength dependent) extinction coefficient (EC) of the acceptor (in M−1·cm−1), and λ is the wavelength, whereby the integral term represents the spectral overlap between the donor emission and the acceptor excitation (Figure 1A). Thus, the key elements that determine E of FRET pairs are the spectral overlap, the QY of the donor, the EC of the acceptor, the wavelength, and the interfluorophore distance and orientation. To maximize FRET E, a red-shifted FRET pair with improved optical properties including QY, EC and spectral overlap should be used. For a given FRET pair, the FRET E is proportional to the inverse sixth power of the distance between two fluorophores and works only over a distance shorter than 10 nm (Figure 1B). Given that the chromophores of autofluorescent FPs (directly from amino acids of protein sequence) are centrally buried in the β-barrel structure with a diameter of about 2.4 nm, the effective distance for autofluorescent FP-based FRET pairs is less than 7 nm, resulting in practical maximal FRET efficiencies of 40%–55% [2,4]. By contrast, the non-autofluorescent FP LUMP (lumazine-binding protein) binds noncovalently at its surface to the chromophore molecule ribityl-lumazine, and exhibits a high FRET efficiency of up to 62% when paired with the autofluorescent yellow FP Venus [11]. FRET dynamic range refers to the range of E in which

Read the complete text