Research on the printability of hydrogels in 3D bioprinting.

He Y, Yang F, Zhao H, Gao Q, Xia B, Fu J. · 2016

Read Research on the printability of hydrogels in 3D bioprinting. by He Y, Yang F, Zhao H, Gao Q, Xia B, Fu J. (2016) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc4951698.txt.

Introduction

Yong He and five co-authors study what makes hydrogels print well in three dimensional bioprinting. Their paper appeared in Scientific Reports in 2016. Hydrogels are soft, water rich gels that can carry living cells for tissue engineering. Printing them into organ like shapes needs exact control of how each line lands. The team printed lines, lattices, and films, then full 3D scaffolds, while varying the machine settings one at a time.

Air pressure, feed rate, and printing distance mattered most to quality. At lattice crossings the gel spread into dumbbell shapes. In tall builds, layer collapse and fusion piled up errors along the height and could ruin the print. Balancing all settings, the team printed a sound scaffold. Cells survived printing about as well as in cast gels. The authors offer their parameter map as a guide for labs tuning their own bioinks.

Catalog record

CREATORHe Y, Yang F, Zhao H, Gao Q, Xia B, Fu J.
YEAR2016
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE39 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC4951698

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Research on the printability of hydrogels in 3D bioprinting By Yong He, FeiFei Yang, HaiMing Zhao, Qing Gao, Bing Xia, JianZhong Fu Published in: Scientific Reports DOI: 10.1038/srep29977 ABSTRACT As the biocompatible materials, hydrogels have been widely used in three- dimensional (3D) bioprinting/organ printing to load cell for tissue engineering. It is important to precisely control hydrogels deposition during printing the mimic organ structures. However, the printability of hydrogels about printing parameters is seldom addressed. In this paper, we systemically investigated the printability of hydrogels from printing lines (one dimensional, 1D structures) to printing lattices/films (two dimensional, 2D structures) and printing 3D structures with a special attention to the accurate printing. After a series of experiments, we discovered the relationships between the important factors such as air pressure, feedrate, or even printing distance and the printing quality of the expected structures. Dumbbell shape was observed in the lattice structures printing due to the hydrogel diffuses at the intersection. Collapses and fusion of adjacent layer would result in the error accumulation at Z direction which was an important fact that could cause printing failure. Finally, we successfully demonstrated a 3D printing hydrogel scaffold through harmonize with all the parameters. The cell viability after printing was compared with the casting and the results showed that our bioprinting method almost had no extra damage to the cells. 3D printing (additive manufacturing) is now widely applied in the electronics, automotive, aerospace, medical engineering and other fields1. Due to high precision, high efficiency for single product and convenient operation, 3D printing gets more and more attention from the whole word. In recent years, this technology has been widely used in the tissue engineering. The term coined for the printing of tissues using these types of approaches is bioprinting, cell printing or even organ printing2. Bioprinting uses a computer-controlled 3D printing device to accurately deposit cells and biomaterials into the models of organs3. It has less danger of organ transplant rejection than traditional treatment of grafting, which is limited by the number of donors. Nowadays several bioprinting progresses have been demonstrated, such as bionic ears4, multilayered skins5, artificial bones6, vascular tissues7 and cartilaginous structures8. Hydrogels come out as a kind of biomaterial with good biocompatibility and now they are widely used as the cell-laden materials for bioprinting. A number of bioprinting methods have been explored, including cellular inkjet printing91011121314, laser-assisted bioprinting15161718, stereolithography192021 and extrusion-based printing222324. Inkjet printing owns high printing speed, low cost and wide availability, but has the risk of exposing cells to thermal & mechanical stress and unreliable cell encapsulation. Laser-assisted bioprinting represents a promising method owing to its fine resolution while the high cost of printing systems is a concern. Also, lack of commercial 3D laser bioprinters will limit its wide use. Stereolithography is known for high accuracy, but its disadvantages include lack of printing multi-cells and the damage of cell during photocuring. Although the pressure of extrusion-based bioprinting may have the effect on cell viability, it is a common method for the ability to deposit very high cell densities. Currently, the extrusion-based printer equipped with two printing heads had printed tubular constructs25. Some groups achieved fabrication and scale-up of 3D structures by the use of viscous biomaterials and extrusion-based technologies262728. “Scaffold-free” bioprinting based on extrusion-based printing has been coined, which follows the principles of tissue liquidity and tissue fusion of multi-cellular components7. Multicellular cell spheroids are deposited and allowed to self-assemble into the desired 3D structure2930. Recently, we also demonstrated that micro channels used for nutrients delivery as vessels in the printed tissues could be printed with the 3D hydrogel/cell structures at the same time with coaxial nozzle-assisted bioprinting by extrusion31. With precisely controlled deposition of cell-laden hydrogels, organs can be mimicked better as the 3D structures determine nurture morphology and growth characteristics of cells after printing. It is clear that the 3D hydrogel printability study is very important in tissue engineering. In the research of hydrogel printability, many investigations have been performed including, assessing the printability of the ink solutions using rheology and ink consistency23; discussing physical and rheological properties of hydrogel under the conditions imparted by different biofabrication instruments32; finding a direct correlation between printability and the hydrogel mechanical properties33. However, little attention has so far been paid to various process parameters during printing and discussing the relationships between the parameters and the printing fidelity. There are many parameters which will have great influences on printing resolution during the extrusion-based bioprinting process, such as the hydrogel fusion during printing, deformation caused by gravity, non-uniform extrusion due to the change of printing speed. It is short of research reports about systematically discussing the printability of biomaterials or the relationships between printing quality/fidelity and the process parameters. In this paper, the hydrogel was the mixture of sodium alginate (SA) and gelatin with a proper rate. The mixture was extruded on a cool substrate for the solidification of gelatin and fixing the biostructures. After printing, the structures were immersed in the calcium chloride (CaCl2) solution for the crosslinking of SA and acquiring the cell-laden hydrogel structures. The influence of air pressure, feedrate, printing distance, and printing sharp angle were discussed separately in printing lines (1D structures) as lines were the base units of 2D and 3D structures. Next we systemically discussed the fidelity of lattice structures (2D structures) and 3D structures, in order to reduce the diffusion and collapse during printing. Finally, we successfully demonstrated a 3D printed hydrogel structure through harmonizing all the parameters. RESULTS Bioprinting of 3D structures Our self-designed 3D bioprinter includes a XYZ moving platform with a cooling substrate (Peltier cooler) to contain the printed hydrogels and a nozzle could be heated to extrude hydrogel easily under air pressure, as shown in Fig. 1a. The hydrogel precursor used in experiments is SA, which is widely used in biofabrication34353637. For better printing quality, gelatin was mixed and was used to hold the sharp of printing structures before SA was crosslinked to hydrogel. For the simplicity, the sol (mixture of SA/gelatin/water) used before printing is also called hydrogel although it is not crosslinked. Currently, some literatures about the matrix of alginate/gelatin with enhanced properties are reported383940. These researches are mainly concerned about improving the mechanical or biocompatible performance of the mixture. As cell-laden is not required in the scaffold fabricating, interpenetrating polymer networks (IPN) can be realized with some additional cross-linking agents or processing such as freeze-drying. The fundamental purpose of gelatin used in this report is for keeping the shape of the printed structures as it will be gelled when temperature is lower than its solidification temperature. During printing, suitable viscosity is very important. Deformation and collapse will be easily happened when printing low viscosity materials. On the other hand, nozzles will be easily jammed when high viscosity materials are printed. To avoid these problems, as shown in Fig. 1b, firstly, the mixture was heated on the nozzle with a temperature T1, then it was extruded under air pressure to the substrate and cooled to a temperature T2 with two thermoelectric coolers. T1 must be higher than the melting temperature of gelatin to avoid jamming nozzle. T2 must be lower than the solidification temperature of gelatin to fix the printed

Read the complete text