Cortical contributions to the auditory frequency-following response revealed by MEG.
Coffey EB, Herholz SC, Chepesiuk AM, Baillet S, Zatorre RJ. · 2016
Read Cortical contributions to the auditory frequency-following response revealed by MEG. by Coffey EB, Herholz SC, Chepesiuk AM, Baillet S, Zatorre RJ. (2016) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc4820836.txt.
Introduction
Emily B. J. Coffey and four co-authors locate the sources of a brain response to sound in Nature Communications in 2016. When a steady-pitched sound plays, the brain answers at the same pitch, a response called the frequency-following response. Clinics use it to study sound processing, and textbooks assigned it to the brainstem alone, below conscious hearing.
Using a magnetic brain scanner that can separate sources, the team found a strong contribution from the hearing cortex itself, stronger on the right side, at the sound's base pitch. The expected deep stations, from the ear nerve relay to the midbrain and the relay to cortex, also contributed. The cortex's share means the response reflects higher processing too, so past readings of it as a pure brainstem gauge need rethinking.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Coffey EB, Herholz SC, Chepesiuk AM, Baillet S, Zatorre RJ. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2016 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 71 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Cortical contributions to the auditory frequency-following response revealed by MEG By Emily B J Coffey, Sibylle C Herholz, Alexander M P Chepesiuk, Sylvain Baillet, Robert J Zatorre Published in: Nature Communications DOI: 10.1038/ncomms11070 ABSTRACT Abstract The auditory frequency-following response (FFR) to complex periodic sounds is used to study the subcortical auditory system, and has been proposed as a biomarker for disorders that feature abnormal sound processing. Despite its value in fundamental and clinical research, the neural origins of the FFR are unclear. Using magnetoencephalography, we observe a strong, right-asymmetric contribution to the FFR from the human auditory cortex at the fundamental frequency of the stimulus, in addition to signal from cochlear nucleus, inferior colliculus and medial geniculate. This finding is highly relevant for our understanding of plasticity and pathology in the auditory system, as well as higher-level cognition such as speech and music processing. It suggests that previous interpretations of the FFR may need re-examination using methods that allow for source separation. Auditory brainstem responses (ABRs) are time-locked neural reactions to sound that are recorded from the scalp using electroencephalography (EEG)1. Because they are uniquely suited to studying fine temporal encoding in the intact human auditory system, an accumulation of ABR-based results now supports some of our general understanding of the auditory system, particularly as it relates to the human pursuits of language and music. ABRs to complex sounds such as speech and musical tones have two main characteristics: a transient response to a sudden sound onset or a click, and a sustained frequency-following response (FFR) to periodicity1. The click or onset response is a relatively straightforward progression of auditory information from the auditory nerve to the cortex and is valuable particularly for clinical diagnosis. Its neural origins are quite well understood2,3. The FFR portion of the ABR is of a different nature to the onset response, as it appears to provide information to different higher-level systems and co-vary with distinct behavioural and clinical measures1,4. As such, it is thought to reflect the basic neural representation of periodic sound on which higher-level processing of language and music is based5. As the name ‘auditory brainstem response' implies, the ABR (including the FFR) is generally thought to arise from the summation of signals from interconnected subcortical sources in auditory brainstem nuclei6. However, measures of the FFR's strength, consistency and frequency content are susceptible to modulation by processes with known cortical involvement, including learning7, task-related suppression8 and selective attention9; FFR measures also relate more strongly to complex cognitive skills such as reading than to basic sound perception10. These results have been interpreted as local effects within the brainstem or as reflecting efferent modulation of subcortical processes from the cortex; however, the neural origins of the FFR are very much an open question6,11. A large number of recent studies in basic and applied research areas have taken FFR measures as proxies for measuring subcortical activity. For example, the locus, extent and variety of experience-based plasticity in the auditory system have been inferred partially from FFR studies12. These include results from studies demonstrating that the FFRs of musicians and tonal language speakers are more robust than those of non-musicians, and that sound representation is malleable to short-term training13,14,15,16,17,18. FFR studies have also provided insights into auditory processing changes during early development and in ageing19,20,21,22,23. Music training in adolescence confers benefits for language skills, and this is thought to occur in part due to its effect on subcortical sound processing24. Performance deficits in speech and language processing in older adulthood are attributed to a loss of temporal precision of sound processing at the brainstem level25,26. Understanding speech in noisy conditions has also been studied using FFRs. Degradation of the FFR in the presence of noise is reduced following perceptual training26,27, suggesting that training causes changes to the neural encoding of complex sounds by improving neural synchrony in the auditory brainstem. Various studies have also reported differences in the FFR of clinical populations, such as children with learning disabilities and autism, and attributed them to functional impairments at the brainstem level28,29,30. FFR measures have also proven sufficiently sensitive for use as biomarkers to identify and evaluate the treatment of disorders that feature abnormal sound processing31,32,33,34,35. Measures such as the strength and consistency of sound representation in the FFR or of transient peaks after the ABR onset response are used in all of these studies. Magnetoencephalography (MEG) is suitable for studying the anatomical origins of FFRs, as neural signals remain largely unaffected by the geometry and electromagnetic properties of the head tissues through which they pass, making source localization from MEG data more accurate than EEG data36. Attempts to use MEG to study ABRs date back over two decades37,38,39, but robust and reproducible responses to clicks were only recently reported40. A previous study40 showed the onset response ascending the auditory system by using equivalent current dipoles, a technique which they note is unsatisfactory for later ABR waves with simultaneously active generators; hence, the origins of the FFR remain unknown. Methods for MEG analysis have evolved rapidly. In particular, distributed source modelling analysis offers the possibility of localizing and separating simultaneous sources—a prerequisite for looking at the FFR. It is now possible for MEG to accurately localize deeper structures such as the hippocampus, amygdala and thalamus (for example, Attal and Schwartz41; Dumas et al.42), suggesting that with sufficient signal to noise, brainstem activity might also be measured. Clarifying the neural origins of the FFR is therefore of broad interest in auditory cognitive neuroscience. Also, our understanding of early and rapidly time-varying processes in the auditory system is being shaped by the widespread assumption of an exclusive subcortical FFR origin. Here we present the first measurements of the FFR using MEG, and locate its origins. Our principal aim was to use MEG to test whether the FFR emerges only from the brainstem nuclei, as is widely held, or whether a cortical origin may also exist. Specifically, we evaluate the hypothesis that at the relatively low fundamental frequency that is typically used in the literature (Supplementary Fig. 1), the FFR reflects a contribution from the auditory cortex (AC) in addition to contributions from subcortical nuclei6. We simultaneously collected MEG and EEG data to first establish that the MEG equivalent of the EEG–FFR can be observed. Using several complementary methods to examine localization, temporal order and behavioural relevance that rely on different assumptions, we present evidence in support of a contribution from the AC, with a right-hemisphere bias. Finally, to test the validity of the conclusions regarding cortical origins of the FFR, we demonstrate that the amplitude of the right AC component of the FFR correlates with behavioural variables relevant for musical processing. RESULTS MEG equivalent of the scalp-recorded EEG–ABR To ensure that the observed MEG response represents the magnetic counterpart of the EEG–ABR, we compared the time and frequency domain averages of the EEG–ABR with the MEG sensor trace that maximally correlated with it (Fig. 1a; mean Pearson's r=0.59, s.d.=0.13). Both the onset response and FFR were visible in the EEG and MEG recordings. In the frequency domain (Fig. 1b), both EEG and MEG show clear peaks at the fundamental frequency of the stimulus (f0) and smaller harmonic peaks (integer multiples