Guidelines for diagnostic next-generation sequencing.

Matthijs G, Souche E, Alders M, Corveleyn A, Eck S, Feenstra I, Race V, Sistermans E, Sturm M, Weiss M, Yntema H, Bakker E, Scheffer H, Bauer P, EuroGentest, European Society of Human Genetics. · 2016

Read Guidelines for diagnostic next-generation sequencing. by Matthijs G, Souche E, Alders M, Corveleyn A, Eck S, Feenstra I, Race V, Sistermans E, Sturm M, Weiss M, Yntema H, Bakker E, Scheffer H, Bauer P, EuroGentest, European Society of Human Genetics. (2016) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc4795226.txt.

Introduction

Gert Matthijs leads a twelve-author group in the European Journal of Human Genetics in 2016 setting standards for gene sequencing in diagnosis. Modern sequencers read thousands of gene stretches at once, and clinics across Europe are adopting them to pin down rare inherited disease. Speed brings risk: labs vary in how they check their tests, read results, and counsel patients.

The guidelines, issued for two European genetics bodies, cover the full path from buying machines to reporting a result. A new rating system grades sequencing tests so doctors can see what a given test can and cannot claim. Worked examples help labs meet accreditation rules. The authors report a warm welcome from the field, which they read as a step toward uniform, trustworthy genetic testing.

Catalog record

CREATORMatthijs G, Souche E, Alders M, Corveleyn A, Eck S, Feenstra I, Race V, Sistermans E, Sturm M, Weiss M, Yntema H, Bakker E, Scheffer H, Bauer P, EuroGentest, European Society of Human Genetics.
YEAR2016
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE26 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC4795226

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Guidelines for diagnostic next-generation sequencing By Gert Matthijs, Erika Souche, Mariëlle Alders, Anniek Corveleyn, Sebastian Eck, Ilse Feenstra, Valérie Race, Erik Sistermans, Marc Sturm, Marjan Weiss, Helger Yntema, Egbert Bakker Published in: European Journal of Human Genetics DOI: 10.1038/ejhg.2015.226 ABSTRACT Abstract We present, on behalf of EuroGentest and the European Society of Human Genetics, guidelines for the evaluation and validation of next-generation sequencing (NGS) applications for the diagnosis of genetic disorders. The work was performed by a group of laboratory geneticists and bioinformaticians, and discussed with clinical geneticists, industry and patients' representatives, and other stakeholders in the field of human genetics. The statements that were written during the elaboration of the guidelines are presented here. The background document and full guidelines are available as supplementary material. They include many examples to assist the laboratories in the implementation of NGS and accreditation of this service. The work and ideas presented by others in guidelines that have emerged elsewhere in the course of the past few years were also considered and are acknowledged in the full text. Interestingly, a few new insights that have not been cited before have emerged during the preparation of the guidelines. The most important new feature is the presentation of a ‘rating system' for NGS-based diagnostic tests. The guidelines and statements have been applauded by the genetic diagnostic community, and thus seem to be valuable for the harmonization and quality assurance of NGS diagnostics in Europe. Next-generation sequencing (NGS) allows for the fast generation of thousands to millions of base pairs of DNA sequence of an individual patient. The relatively fast emergence and the great success of these technologies in research herald a new era in genetic diagnostics. However, the new technologies bring challenges, both at the technical level and in terms of data management, as well as for the interpretation of the results and for counseling. We believe that all these aspects warrant consideration of what the precise role of NGS in diagnostics will be, today and tomorrow. Before even embarking on acquisition of machines and skills for performing NGS in diagnostics, many issues have to be dealt with. It is in this context that we propose the guidelines. These guidelines mostly deal with NGS testing in the context of rare and mostly monogenic diseases. They mainly focus on the targeted analysis of gene panels, either through specific capture assays, or by extracting data from whole-exome sequencing. In principle, whole-genome sequencing may – and shortly will – also be used to extract similar information. In that case, the guidelines would still apply, but because whole-genome sequencing would also allow detecting other molecular features of disease, they would have to be extended accordingly. The different aspects of NGS and diagnostics were discussed during three workshops. The first took place in Leuven, 25–26 February 2013. The preliminary views were presented during the EuroGentest Scientific Meeting in Prague, 7–8 March 2013. The second was an editorial workshop in Leuven, 1–2 October 2013, where the different people involved in writing the document came together to discuss the layout of the document and prepare the first draft. The first draft was finalized prior to the third meeting in Nijmegen, 21–22 November, 2013. To the latter meeting, a larger group of stakeholders was invited. They were invited to comment on the draft, and on the statements presented therein. The comments were included in a new version, which was circulated among the editorial group, prior to publication on the EuroGentest and European Society of Human Genetics websites. Eventually, the document was presented to the Board of the European Society of Human Genetics, for endorsement. Endorsement was formally obtained on 1 July 2015. The statements that emerged during the writing of the guidelines are briefly presented in this paper. They are more extensively explained in the full version of the guidelines, available as supplementary material. The supplementary material also includes definitions, general recommendations and importantly, a number of practical examples and templates. STATE OF THE ART The available NGS platforms are not stable yet in a sense that the technology and applications change constantly and rapidly. However, this should not prevent the implementation of NGS technology in diagnostics as NGS offers a potential overall benefit for the patient. The one thing that should prevent people from prematurely offering NGS diagnostics is poor quality. Insufficiently validated tests do present a threat to patients, and their use in a clinical diagnostic setting is unacceptable. STATEMENT 01: NGS should not be transferred to clinical practice without an acceptable validation of the tests according to the emerging guidelines. Whether the aim of a diagnostic test is to exclude or confirm a diagnosis has to be defined beforehand as the distinction is significant. The distinction mainly depends on the completeness of the test and warrants not only different settings but more importantly a different view on diagnostics. STATEMENT 02: The laboratory has to make clear whether the test that is being offered may be used to exclude a diagnosis, or to confirm a diagnosis. DIAGNOSTIC/CLINICAL UTILITY The benefit of implementing NGS in diagnostics is the introduction of testing many genes at once in a relatively short time and at relatively low costs, and thereby yielding more molecular diagnoses. The limitations of NGS are dependent on the platform and on the enrichment methods (if any) and have to be considered as they will influence the choice of enrichment method and sequencing platform and determine which additional tests (if any) will be necessary to deliver high-quality diagnostics. STATEMENT 03: The aim and the utility of the test or assay should be discussed at the beginning of the validation and a summary should be included in the validation report. The ‘diagnostic yield' is defined as the chance that a disease-causing variant is identified and molecular diagnosis can be made. The value is calculated per patient cohort. It establishes the performance of NGS primarily from a clinical point of view and may be a good indicator of the efficiency of the test (beyond its analytical aspects) and of its clinical utility. STATEMENT 04: When a laboratory is considering introducing NGS in diagnostics, it first has to consider the diagnostic yield. In practice, diagnostic laboratories will preferably offer gene panels. The conditions for including a gene into a panel have to be defined when developing a diagnostic test. Ideally, this is an issue that should be dealt with at the community level, in a multidisciplinary way. The aim is to compile the list of genes that should be included in all diagnostic offers. This is important to harmonize genetic testing. It is definitely important from the standpoint of the patients and medical practitioners who would like to see equal access and uniform services across Europe. STATEMENT 05: For diagnostic purpose, only genes with a known (ie, published and confirmed) relationship between the aberrant genotype and the pathology should be included in the analysis. There is a strong opinion that for genes that are responsible for a significant proportion of the defects, referred as ‘core genes', the sensitivity should not be compromised by the transition from Sanger to NGS. A strong issue is made about the BRCA1 and BRCA2 genes, where the sensitivity of Sanger

Read the complete text