Discrimination Between Normal and Cancerous Cells Using AFM.
Lekka M. · 2016
Read Discrimination Between Normal and Cancerous Cells Using AFM. by Lekka M. (2016) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc4778153.txt.
Introduction
Małgorzata Lekka, writing alone in Bionanoscience in 2016, reviews whether the softness of a cell can betray cancer. An atomic force microscope can press on a living cell with a fine tip and measure how much it gives. Across bladder, prostate, thyroid, and ovary cancers, tumor cells have repeatedly proved softer and more deformable than their healthy counterparts, in step with a thinned inner scaffold.
Lekka weighs the promise against a caution. The softness measure is relative: it shifts with the tool, the method, and the cell's state, so values from one lab rarely match another's. Used with care and common standards, stiffness could still serve as a marker that flags suspect cells. The review lays out where the measure stands and what would make it trustworthy.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Lekka M. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2016 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 65 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Discrimination Between Normal and Cancerous Cells Using AFM By Małgorzata Lekka Published in: Bionanoscience DOI: 10.1007/s12668-016-0191-3 ABSTRACT Abstract Currently, biomechanics of living cells is in the focus of interest due to noticeable capability of such techniques like atomic force microscopy (AFM) to probe cellular properties at the single cell level directly on living cells. The research carried out, so far, delivered data showing, on the one hand, the use of cellular mechanics as a biomarker of various pathological changes, which, on the other hand, reveal relative nature of biomechanics. In the AFM, the elastic properties of living cells are delivered from indentation experiments and described quantitatively by Young’s modulus defined here as a measure of cellular deformability. Here, the AFM studies directly comparing the mechanical properties of normal and cancerous cells are summarized and presented together with a few important issues related to the relativeness of Young’s modulus. Keywords: Atomic force microscopy, Cancer cell detection, Mechanosensing, Cancer cell elasticity INTRODUCTION Oncogenic transformation leads to a distinct phenotype of cancerous cells in such aspects such as variations in cellular growth, differentiation and interactions with neighbouring cells and/or the extracellular matrix (ECM) and also in internal structure and properties of single cells [1, 2]. Among others, alterations in the structure and organization of cytoskeleton manifest, in most cases, in larger deformability of single cells, as it has been reported for various cancers, such as bladder, prostate, thyroid and ovarian ones [3–8]. Furthermore, these changes are commonly related to either a partial loss of actin filaments [9] or disorganization of microtubules [10] being in fact the consequence of lower density of the cellular scaffold. The deformability of single cells has been studied for a long time using various techniques. The driving force for such studies is the assumption that, depending on the disease type, the altered cellular deformability (or lack of it) should play a critical role in the development and progression of various diseases. Thus, it can be a manifestation of diseases with genetic mutations linked with structural/molecular changes on a single cell level observed, for example, in various muscular dystrophies [11–13] or laminopathies [14, 15]. The increased/decreased deformability manifests in various cancers. This observation attracted researchers from the fields of cellular biology, biophysics and medicine due the potential ability to define a non-labelled biomarker of cancer progression. The technological development towards measurements of individual cells at the single cell level has brought powerful techniques that can bind and relate the mechanical properties with cellular functioning and structures. One of such techniques is the atomic force microscopy (AFM) [16]. The pioneering studies showed the importance of mechanical properties to characterize cancerous cells [3]. In these studies, the deformability of human bladder cancerous cells was 1 order of magnitude larger as compared to reference cells originating from non-malignant cancers. These early results have been supported (and indirectly verified) by optical tweezers measurements. Using this high-throughput technique, three cell lines were compared, namely a non-tumorigenic breast epithelial MCF10 cells; a non-motile, non-metastatic breast epithelial cancer MCF7 cells; and MCF7 cells transformed with phorbol ester. The results showed a significant increase in deformability in more invasive cells (i.e. transformed MCF7 breast cells) as compared to both non-metastatic MCF10 and non-transformed MCF7 ones [4]. Further development in the single cell elasticity measurements and data analysis delivered a large database of cases showing significantly larger deformability of single cancerous cells [5, 6, 17]. In the AFM, the deformability is expressed by Young’s modulus that delivers a quantitative measure of cellular elastic properties. It has been reported that cells in vitro have the Young’s modulus values in the range of 1–100 kPa [18]. These values characterize different types of investigated cells, including vascular smooth muscle cells, fibroblasts, bladder cells, red blood cells, platelets and epithelial cells, both normal and cancerous ones. In the presented work, I would only like to focus on papers showing a direct comparison of mechanical properties between normal and cancerous cells that were measured using AFM. Thus, the brief introduction to atomic force microscopy, the essential technical aspects of elasticity measurements together with exemplary results, is discussed. ATOMIC FORCE MICROSCOPY The construction of the atomic force microscope (AFM) [16] can be divided into three main parts, namely a cantilever, a system that detects its deflection and a system that enables scanning and positioning (Fig. 1). The principle of operation is independent of the environment surrounding the cantilever (air, vacuum or liquids). The scanning and positioning system utilizes piezoelectric materials, enabling, on the one hand, a very accurate positioning and scanning and, on the other hand, convenient sample handling and mounting. The key part of the AFM is a cantilever. Cantilevers are lithographically etched from silicon or silicon nitride in a form of long, flexible levers (rectangular or triangular ones), with a probing tip mounted at their free ends (inset in Fig. 1, showing a four-sided pyramid attached at the end of a triangular cantilever made of silicon nitride–cantilever type MLCT, Veeco). Mechanical properties of a cantilever are characterized by the corresponding spring constants which, in case of living cell studies, typically ranges from 0.01 to 0.1 N/m. Often, a probing tip has a shape of a four-sided pyramid (as shown in the inset in Fig. 1) but other geometries, such as cones or spheres, are also used in the AFM experiments. The choice of appropriate geometry of the probing cantilever depends on the type of experiments to be carried out. In the case of elasticity measurements of living cells, the more blunt tips are better since they do not induce large pressure within the contact area between the probing tip and cell surface. The majority of the results showing the differences between normal and cancerous cells have been obtained with the use of pyramidal tips. However, spheres have been also applied, since such geometry of probing tip fulfils better the Hertz model assumptions commonly used in the Young’s modulus value estimation. [Figure: The idea of the atomic force microscopy (AFM). Inset shows images of the cantilever (MLCT) obtained from scanning electron microscopy (SEM)] The forces acting between the probing tip and a sample (here, a living cell) surface cause the cantilever deflection. The most frequent way of its detection uses the optical system composed of a laser and a photodetector. In such system, the laser beam is focused at the free end of the cantilever just above a probing tip. The reflected beam is guided towards the centre of the photodiode, a position-sensitive detector, whose active area is divided into four quadrants. When the cantilever’s probing tip is far away from the surface, the cantilever is not deflected from its initial position, while the reflected laser beam is set in such a way that photocurrents from each quadrant have similar values. When interacting forces deflect the cantilever, the position of the reflected laser beam changes, leading to different values of photocurrents recorded in the quadrants. If the cantilever bends vertically (i.e. perpendicular to the investigated surface that relates to a force acting perpendicularly to the surface), by appropriate summation and subtraction of the photocurrents, the cantilever normal deflection (ND) can be obtained as follows: [formula: 1NDV=A⋅IUL+IUR−IBL+IBR] where A is the proportional coefficient and Ixy