Systematic pan-cancer analysis of tumour purity.
Aran D, Sirota M, Butte AJ. · 2015
Read Systematic pan-cancer analysis of tumour purity. by Aran D, Sirota M, Butte AJ. (2015) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc4671203.txt.
Introduction
Dvir Aran, Marina Sirota, and Atul J. Butte published a 2015 pan-cancer analysis of tumour purity, the share of a sample that is truly cancer cells. The rest is the tumour microenvironment: immune cells, fibroblasts, and vessel cells. That mix can distort genomic readings. The team analysed over ten thousand samples across twenty-one cancer types from The Cancer Genome Atlas. The work appeared in Nature Communications.
Purity levels shifted how tumours clustered and correlated in expression data, confirming the confounding effect. Patients were grouped by clinical features to hunt for purity-driven differences. A differential expression method that accounts for purity found an immunotherapy-related gene signature in several cancers that standard analysis missed. The study warns analysts to correct for purity before drawing biological conclusions from tumour samples.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Aran D, Sirota M, Butte AJ. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2015 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 47 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Systematic pan-cancer analysis of tumour purity By Dvir Aran, Marina Sirota, Atul J Butte Published in: Nature Communications DOI: 10.1038/ncomms9971 ABSTRACT Abstract The tumour microenvironment is the non-cancerous cells present in and around a tumour, including mainly immune cells, but also fibroblasts and cells that comprise supporting blood vessels. These non-cancerous components of the tumour may play an important role in cancer biology. They also have a strong influence on the genomic analysis of tumour samples, and may alter the biological interpretation of results. Here we present a systematic analysis using different measurement modalities of tumour purity in >10,000 samples across 21 cancer types from the Cancer Genome Atlas. Patients are stratified according to clinical features in an attempt to detect clinical differences driven by purity levels. We demonstrate the confounding effect of tumour purity on correlating and clustering tumours with transcriptomics data. Finally, using a differential expression method that accounts for tumour purity, we find an immunotherapy gene signature in several cancer types that is not detected by traditional differential expression analyses. The tumour microenvironment is a complex milieu consisting of factors that promote growth and inhibit it, as well as nutrients, chemokines, and very importantly, other non-cancerous cell types. These cells include fibroblasts, immune cells, endothelial cells and normal epithelial cells1. All of these constituents interact with one another and with the tumour as it grows. This admixture is thought to have an important role in tumour growth, disease progression and drug resistance2,3. Notably, infiltrating immune cells, and particularly infiltrating T lymphocytes, have been associated with tumour growth, invasion and metastasis in several cancer types4,5. Tumour purity is the proportion of cancer cells in the admixture. Until recently, it was estimated by a pathologist, primarily by visual or image analysis of tumour cells. With the advancement of genomic technologies, many new computational methods have arisen to infer tumour purity. These methods make estimates using different types of genomic information, such as gene expression6, somatic copy-number variation7,8,9 somatic mutations7,10 and DNA methylation7,11. Estimates made by these methods are generally consistent with one another, though, to date, no systematic sensitivity analysis in multiple cancer types has been performed. The Cancer Genome Atlas (TCGA) is currently the largest available data set for genomic analysis of tumours. It contains over 10,000 pretreatment samples across 30 cancer types and includes measurements such as RNA sequencing (RNA-seq), DNA methylation, copy-number variation and more12. The consortium had originally set a quality threshold that tumour samples included in the cohort be composed of at least 80% tumour nuclei, as determined by visual analysis13. However, this threshold was later reduced to 60%. Given the status of TCGA as a flagship project of the National Cancer Institute, we assumed that sample purity was the best possible using current conventional sample acquisition methods, and we thus hypothesized that differences in purity were due more to properties of the cancers, and less to the acquisition method. While TCGA argues that 60% purity is sufficient to distinguish the tumour’s signal from those of other cells, it remains to be evaluated if this level of purity across tumour samples affects the interpretation of genomic analyses. In recent years, sporadic analyses have sought to determine tumour purity levels and take them into account during analysis14,15,16,17,18,19,20,21. These studies used different purity estimation methods and tested only specific parameters, which were mainly in the context of detecting somatic mutations22. This current study is a systematic analysis of tumour purity across multiple cancer types using four different methods and an additional consensus method. We distinguished between the effects of intrinsic and extrinsic factors on tumour purity and analysed the implications of these effects on clinical and molecular information. Intrinsic factors imply that purity levels are a characteristic of the tumour, and that purity variation results from clinical variability. In this case, purity should be associated with clinical information and outcomes. Extrinsic factors imply that purity is dependent on how a sample is collected. In this case, we expect only confounding associations with genomic reasoning such as clustering, correlating and differential analysis of tumour samples. When we adjusted gene expression analysis to account for purity estimations, we saw upregulation of immunotherapy-related T-cell activation pathway genes in several cancer types, which cannot be detected in traditional differential expression (DE). Our systematic analysis provides a comprehensive evaluation of the importance of accounting for tumour purity in cancer studies. RESULTS Purity of TCGA tumour samples We obtained gene expression profiles (RNA-seqV2), DNA methylation profiles (HumanMethylation450) and immunohistochemistry (IHC) analysis for 9,364 tumour samples and 1,958 adjacent normal samples across 21 solid tumour types from the TCGA repository (Supplementary Table 1). For each sample, we assigned purity estimates using four methods: ESTIMATE, which uses gene expression profiles of 141 immune genes and 141 stromal genes6; ABSOLUTE, which uses somatic copy-number data (estimations were available for only 11 cancer types)7; LUMP (leukocytes unmethylation for purity), which averages 44 non-methylated immune-specific CpG sites (Supplementary Fig. 1 and Methods); and IHC, as estimated by image analysis of haematoxylin and eosin stain slides produced by the Nationwide Children’s Hospital Biospecimen Core Resource. All estimates are in Supplementary Data 1. The purity estimates from the DNA, RNA and methylation-based methods had high concordance between most cancer types (Fig. 1a; Supplementary Fig. 2). The correlation of the three genomic-based methods with IHC was lower in all cancer types (Supplementary Fig. 3). However, in all assayed methods, the correlation coefficients with IHC were positive among all cancer types, suggesting that IHC provides a qualitative estimation of purity. [Figure: Tumour purity of TCGA cancers types.(a) Pairwise correlations between tumour purity methods used in 21 cancer types and all samples combined. Grey cells: data not available from both purity methods. Correlations between the genomic-based methods are high in most cancer types. Correlations with IHC are low, yet always positive. (b) Violin plots of CPE tumour purity in 21 cancer types. The cancers were ordered according to median purity.] Next, we determined the average purity level of all associated tumour samples for each cancer type, according to each method. In accordance with previous results, there was high concordance among the DNA, RNA and methylation-based methods, and lower to no agreement with IHC (Supplementary Fig. 4). Average tumour purity across all samples from all cancer types was 81.1±13.9%, 76.1±16.1% and 75.7±21.2% (mean±s.d.) for ESTIMATE, LUMP and IHC, respectively. An exception was ABSOLUTE, with an average estimate of 62.3±19.9%. This difference is explained by methodological differences: while ABSOLUTE is a direct measure of the tumour cells in a sample, ESTIMATE and LUMP estimate purity indirectly by measuring immune and stromal counterparts in the sample. Thus, the difference in the average estimates is arguably due to the presence of non-immune and stromal cells in a sample, such as contaminating adjacent normal cells, which are not measured by ESTIMATE and LUMP. We used these methods to derive a consensus measurement of purity estimations (CPE). CPE is the median purity level after normalizing levels from all methods to give them equal means and s.d.’s (75.3±18.9%). CPE is used in all analyses below, but results were consistent in the majority of methods when individually tested (presented in Supplementary Figs 1–15). Regardless of the method used, purity patterns