Uncertainty in the Timing of Origin of Animals and the Limits of Precision in Molecular Timescales.
dos Reis M, Thawornwattana Y, Angelis K, Telford MJ, Donoghue PC, Yang Z. · 2015
Read Uncertainty in the Timing of Origin of Animals and the Limits of Precision in Molecular Timescales. by dos Reis M, Thawornwattana Y, Angelis K, Telford MJ, Donoghue PC, Yang Z. (2015) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc4651906.txt.
Introduction
A 2015 study from Mario dos Reis and colleagues centres on the limits of dating animal origins with molecular clocks. Fossils place definite two-sided animals in the Cambrian, yet DNA studies often push their split far earlier. Earlier clock studies used little data and glossed over fossil uncertainty. The team used an unprecedented molecular dataset with four fossil calibration strategies. The work appeared in Current Biology.
Their estimates place the crown animal group in the Cryogenian period, with most two-sided animal phyla diversifying in the Ediacaran. But the error bars stay wide no matter the strategy. Ancient fossil ambiguity and clock irregularities cap how precise such dates can be. Pinpointing divergences tightly enough to test links with geological events is not yet possible, the authors conclude.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | dos Reis M, Thawornwattana Y, Angelis K, Telford MJ, Donoghue PC, Yang Z. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2015 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 54 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Uncertainty in the Timing of Origin of Animals and the Limits of Precision in Molecular Timescales By Mario dos Reis, Yuttapong Thawornwattana, Konstantinos Angelis, Maximilian J Telford, Philip CJ Donoghue, Ziheng Yang Published in: Current Biology DOI: 10.1016/j.cub.2015.09.066 ABSTRACT Summary The timing of divergences among metazoan lineages is integral to understanding the processes of animal evolution, placing the biological events of species divergences into the correct geological timeframe. Recent fossil discoveries and molecular clock dating studies have suggested a divergence of bilaterian phyla >100 million years before the Cambrian, when the first definite crown-bilaterian fossils occur. Most previous molecular clock dating studies, however, have suffered from limited data and biases in methodologies, and virtually all have failed to acknowledge the large uncertainties associated with the fossil record of early animals, leading to inconsistent estimates among studies. Here we use an unprecedented amount of molecular data, combined with four fossil calibration strategies (reflecting disparate and controversial interpretations of the metazoan fossil record) to obtain Bayesian estimates of metazoan divergence times. Our results indicate that the uncertain nature of ancient fossils and violations of the molecular clock impose a limit on the precision that can be achieved in estimates of ancient molecular timescales. For example, although we can assert that crown Metazoa originated during the Cryogenian (with most crown-bilaterian phyla diversifying during the Ediacaran), it is not possible with current data to pinpoint the divergence events with sufficient accuracy to test for correlations between geological and biological events in the history of animals. Although a Cryogenian origin of crown Metazoa agrees with current geological interpretations, the divergence dates of the bilaterians remain controversial. Thus, attempts to build evolutionary narratives of early animal evolution based on molecular clock timescales appear to be premature. INTRODUCTION The timing and tempo of the evolutionary emergence of animal biodiversity has been among the most enduring problems in evolutionary biology. Innumerable hypotheses have been proposed to explain how the transition to multicellularity was effected, why it occurred when it did, and why it did not occur much earlier in Earth history [1]. Much of the molecular genetic toolkit required for animal development originated deep in eukaryote evolutionary history [2], and it has been widely held that the emergence of complex multicellular organisms was precluded until the oxygenation of the biosphere [3, 4]. Other potential, but not necessarily mutually exclusive, triggers for animal diversification include the release of their forebears from the environmental strictures of the Cryogenian or Ediacaran Snowball Earth [5, 6] and the effects of cosmic radiation [7], polar wander [8], continental fragmentation [9], H2S toxicity [10], salinity [11, 12], a scarcity of trace metal micronutrients [13], a pulse of continental weathering yielding nutrients to the oceans [14], global warming [15], or an escalatory predator-prey arms race [16, 17]. Although these hypotheses propose more or less proximal causal mechanistic relationships with metazoan diversification, they rely ultimately on presumed temporal coincidence. This is challenging since the timing and the threshold of extrinsic environmental effects is invariably as unclear as the timing of the phenomena that they have been invoked to explain (e.g., [18]), varying from the origin of animals, eumetazoans, or bilaterians, to the origin of the animal phyla themselves, their crown radiations, or the sum total of this diversity. Indeed, it has been argued that the oxygenation of global oceans was a consequence, not a cause, of metazoan evolution [19]. Reconciling these competing hypotheses requires calibration to a common absolute timescale. Unequivocal fossil evidence of animals is limited to the Phanerozoic. Older records of animals are controversial: organic biomarkers indicative of demosponges [20] are apparently derived ultimately from now symbiotic bacteria [21]; putative animal embryo fossils [22] are alternately interpreted as protists [23, 24, 25]; and contested reports of sponges [26, 27], molluscs [28], and innumerable cnidarians [29], as well as putative traces of eumetazoan or bilaterian grade animals [30, 31, 32, 33, 34], all from the Ediacaran. Certainly, there are no unequivocal records of crown-group bilaterians prior to the Cambrian [35], and robust evidence for bilaterian phyla does not occur until some 20 million years into the Cambrian [36, 37]. There is, nevertheless, increasingly general acceptance of a Precambrian history to animal evolution, and it is only its extent that remains open to debate. Was there an explosive radiation of bilaterian phyla close to the base of Cambrian [36, 38, 39]? Or is there an extensive Precambrian bilaterian history that extends deep into the Cryogenian [35], the absence of a fossil record merely reflecting preservation, collection, and/or interpretation biases? It has been hoped that these questions may be answered, and a timescale for animal evolutionary history established, using molecular clock methodology. Indeed, there is a long history of attempts to estimate the timing of animal diversification [40], yielding ages for crown Metazoa that range between 1,298 Ma [41] and 615 Ma [42]. The disparity between molecular clock estimates and fossil evidence of clade age minima has diminished in association with the development of molecular clock methodology, particularly in accommodating rate variation. Molecular clock timescales are considered good enough by some to begin to synthesize evolutionary narratives integrating evidence of extrinsic environmental and ecological evolution from the geological record with intrinsic biological evolution [43, 44]. Most recent divergence time analyses have been undertaken within a framework of Bayesian inference because it is capable of integrating much of the uncertainty associated with divergence time estimation, viz. the relationships between fossil evidence and clade age, rate variation among lineages (the relaxed clock), branch length estimation, tree topology, and parameters such as data partitioning. Yet, few studies have considered the cumulative impact of these uncertainties on the precision of evolutionary timescales (e.g., [45, 46]). Here we show that the precision of molecular clock estimates of times has been grossly over-estimated. Using a Bayesian method to estimate the timescale of metazoan diversification, we performed sensitivity analyses to explore the impact of the different sources of uncertainties. We used a large amino acid alignment (38,577 sites) of 203 nuclear encoded proteins for 71 species (based on [35, 47]). We employed four fossil calibration strategies that accommodate different interpretations of the fossil record and show that these have a dramatic impact on the estimated times. We also explored the use of different relaxed clock models and show that at this level of divergence the molecular clock is significantly violated. We tested for the effects of different data partitioning strategies and show that this, too, has a significant impact on divergence time estimates. Finally, we show that competing phylogenetic hypotheses yield very different divergence time estimates. An evolutionary timescale for metazoan diversification that accommodates these uncertainties has precision that is insufficient to discriminate among causal hypotheses. Though some of this uncertainty can be reduced through increased precision of calibrations afforded by statistical modeling of fossil occurrence, more sequence data, reduced topological uncertainty, etc., the limitations of the fossil record and the confounding effect of times and rates will remain, making it difficult to achieve the precision required to test competing hypotheses on the causes and consequences of metazoan diversification. RESULTS The Impact of Uncertainty in Fossil Calibrations Fossil calibrations are affected by numerous sources of uncertainty, including phylogenetic interpretation, dating of the rocks, and